Semantis Law Reports

My Library

Mkhize and Others v S (AR158/2022) [2026] ZAKZPHC 106 (30 October 2026)

Criminal Law — Appeal against conviction and sentence — Appellants convicted of murder, attempted murder, robbery, and possession of firearms — Appeal dismissed; cross-appeal partially upheld — Court finding identification evidence reliable and sentencing appropriate under the Criminal Law Amendment Act — Life imprisonment for murder and concurrent sentences for other counts imposed.

Criminal Law
Score: 65

C.G.S v J.H.S (2026-133005) [2026] ZANCHC 92 (30 October 2026)

Family Law — Rule 43 application — Contribution to costs — Applicant seeking contribution towards legal costs in divorce proceedings — Respondent ordered to pay a contribution of R259,210.00 towards applicant’s legal costs, with additional payments for expert fees — Court emphasizing the need for equitable contributions to ensure fair litigation process.

Family Law
Score: 60

Strydom v Van Der Merwe (660/2025) [2026] ZANCHC 93 (30 October 2026)

Contempt of Court — Urgent application — Respondent found in contempt of court for violating an interim interdict prohibiting defamatory statements — Applicant required to prove existence of order and non-compliance — Respondent admitted knowledge of the order but failed to provide credible explanation for non-compliance — Court held that respondent's actions constituted wilful contempt, imposing a suspended term of imprisonment to ensure future compliance.

Civil Procedure
Score: 60

Electoral Commission of SA and Another v Good Party and Others (002/25EC) [2026] ZAEC 11 (30 October 2026)

Application for leave to appeal — Political Funding Act — Applicants seeking leave to appeal against findings of contraventions of the Political Funding Act — Court granting leave to appeal based on important questions of law and compelling reasons — Condonation for late filing of heads of argument granted due to lack of prejudice to other parties — Jurisdictional requirements for penalties and administrative actions under the Act discussed.

Administrative Law
Score: 57

Democratic Alliance v ActionSA and Others (0016/26EC) [2026] ZAEC 12 (30 October 2026)

Electoral Law — Municipal Elections — Proportional Representation — Democratic Alliance challenging party lists submitted by ActionSA and others — Allegations of bad faith and violation of electoral legislation — Court finding no evidence of bad faith or unlawfulness — Applications for declaratory and review relief dismissed, with constitutional challenge postponed sine die.

Constitutional Law
Score: 55

De Oliveria and Others v Morel and Others (D289/2025) [2026] ZAKZDHC 70 (30 October 2026)

Contempt of Court — Breach of court orders — Applicants seeking to hold first respondent in contempt for failing to comply with two court orders — Court finding that the first respondent was aware of the orders and failed to comply — Court issuing a Rule Nisi for the first respondent to show cause why he should not be sentenced to one month’s imprisonment, suspended on compliance with the orders — Costs awarded to the applicants.

Civil Procedure
Score: 55

Lee v Van Rooyen NO and Others (2025/242944) [2026] ZAWCHC 644 (30 October 2026)

Liquidation — Removal of liquidators — Application for removal of liquidators of Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd — Applicant failing to establish grounds for removal — Court finding application constituted an abuse of process — No case made out for interdictory or supervisory relief — Costs awarded on a punitive scale against the applicant.

Insolvency Law
Score: 55

Ndlovu v S (1256/2023) [2026] ZASCA 147 (30 October 2026)

Criminal Law — Appeal — Special leave to appeal — Application for reconsideration of refusal of special leave to appeal against conviction and sentence — Applicant convicted of murder and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment — Full bench of High Court dismissing appeal — Supreme Court of Appeal confirming refusal of special leave — High threshold for reconsideration not met — No special circumstances warranting interference with lower court's decision established.

Criminal Law
Score: 55

Sivuyile Jacquin Tshikila v Electoral Commission of South Africa and Others (0020/26EC) [2026] ZAEC 13 (30 October 2026)

Electoral Law — Candidate nomination — Inclusion without consent — Applicant seeking removal from candidate list after being nominated without his consent by the EFF — Court finding that the applicant's rights to freedom of association and dignity were violated — Electoral Commission ordered to ensure applicant's name is not on the ballot paper — Application partially granted.

Constitutional Law
Score: 55

Supalift Trading CC v Donner (2026-077349) [2026] ZAKZDHC 72 (30 October 2026)

Insolvency Law — Sequestration application — Applicant claiming R2.4 million debt from respondent — Respondent asserting debt was incurred by his company, Abspec, and not personally — Court finding respondent established a bona fide defence to the claim, dismissing the application and ordering costs against the applicant.

Insolvency Law
Score: 55

Dyantyi v Norton Rose Fulbright South African Inc (C21/2025) [2026] ZALCCT 187 (30 October 2026)

Employment Law — Unfair discrimination — Jurisdiction — Plaintiff alleging unfair discrimination and constructive dismissal against employer — Employer raising special pleas regarding lack of jurisdiction due to failure to conciliate dispute as required by Employment Equity Act — Court finding that the discrimination dispute was not conciliated, thus lacking jurisdiction to adjudicate — Referral struck off the roll.

Employment Law
Score: 45

Enoch Mgijima Local Municipality v South African Local Government bargaining Council and Others (PR237/23) [2026] ZALCPE 28 (30 October 2026)

Labour Law — Exemption from Collective Agreement — Municipality seeking review of exemption ruling from Bargaining Council — Ruling denied based on financial distress and historical maladministration — Court finding that the Municipality's financial difficulties do not absolve it from obligations under the Collective Agreement — Application for exemption dismissed.

Labour Law
Score: 45