Semantis Law Reports

My Library

Herzenberg v GM Loubser Family Trust and Others (Appeal) (A117/2026) [2026] ZAWCHC 645 (30 October 2026)

Spoliation — Mandament van spolie — Requirements for peaceful and undisturbed possession — Applicant's occupation arising from a romantic relationship and domestic goodwill — Court finding no autonomous control over access established — Absence of own keys relevant within broader factual matrix — Tolerated and shared occupation insufficient to constitute protected possession — Final interdict sought in addition to mandament — Applicant failing to establish clear right — Appeal and cross-appeal dismissed.

Civil Procedure
Score: 45

Lombardy Home Owners Association NPC ta Lombardy Home Owners Association v Malebye and Another (2025/090421) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1254 (30 October 2026)

Property Law — Homeowners' Association — Arrears in levies — Applicant seeking relief for unpaid levies and related charges from respondents, who admitted liability but contested the imposition of penalties — Court finding that the applicant's claims included duplicated interest and legal fees not properly substantiated — Relief granted only for amounts due without duplication.

Land and Property Law
Score: 45

Mokobane v Gauteng Department of Education (145324/2024) [2026] ZAEQC 7 (30 October 2026)

Equality Court — Jurisdiction — Applicant alleging unfair discrimination following sexual harassment complaint — Respondent's failure to suspend alleged harasser and inadequacy of investigation — Court finding that the matter arises from employment relationship and is governed by labour law, not PEPUDA — Application dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

Employment Law
Score: 45

Sotyo v Kgasapane and Another (2026-184974) [2026] ZAFSHC 495 (30 October 2026)

Rei vindicatio — Right of retention — Applicant seeking return of motor vehicle — Respondent asserting lien for unpaid repair costs — Court finding applicant failed to establish possession by second respondent and that first respondent had a valid lien — Application dismissed with costs.

Civil Procedure
Score: 45

Ehlers and Others v Willemse (2024-094886; 2023-013850) [2026] ZAGPPHC 1265 (30 October 2026)

Civil procedure — Rule 45A — Suspension of execution — Applicants seeking stay of warrants of execution issued for costs pending determination of underlying litigation — Applicants did not challenge validity of costs orders but sought to defer enforcement on grounds of irreversible prejudice, alleged security in respondents' favour, prospective set-off from pending litigation and alleged misconduct by respondents' attorney — Applicants tendered a further affidavit and transcript of evidence from separate proceedings late in the process — Court refused admission of further affidavit and transcript for lack of adequate explanation, context and material connection to issues in present application — Legal issue whether real and substantial justice requires suspension of execution under Rule 45A and whether applicants established prima facie right, irreparable harm, balance of convenience and absence of alternative remedy — Held that mere pendency of related litigation or possibility of future costs does not constitute a present reciprocal debt for set-off; existence of security for respondents relevant but insufficient to show irreparable prejudice to applicants; allegations of misconduct by attorney not shown to be connected to present execution or to demonstrate ulterior purpose; applicants failed to furnish sufficient evidence of irreparable harm or substantial injustice and did not justify departure from ordinary affidavit sequence — Application for stay and admission of further affidavit refused.

Civil Procedure
Score: 44

Mahlatsi and Others v Member of the Executive Council: Department of Education and Others (4442/2025) [2026] ZAFSHC 494 (30 October 2026)

Review — Appointment of principal — Locus standi — Applicants, as members of the School Governing Body, sought to review the appointment of the eighth respondent as principal of ltokisetseng Combined Farm School, alleging unlawful processes in the appointment. Respondents challenged the applicants' standing, asserting that they lacked a resolution from the SGB to institute proceedings. Court found that the applicants failed to establish locus standi as they did not provide evidence of authorization to act on behalf of the SGB. Application dismissed with costs.

Administrative Law
Score: 40

Simelane and Another v Standard Bank of South Africa Limited (2025/137618) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1251 (30 October 2026)

Execution — Variation of order — Applicants seeking to vary a default judgment for mortgage arrears — Court finding that application was brought out of time without condonation and that no valid grounds for variation were established — Application dismissed as the order was clear and unambiguous, and the applicants had no bona fide defense to the bank's claim.

Civil Procedure
Score: 35

Drakenstein Municipality v Lolo and Others (625/2023) [2026] ZASCA 145 (29 October 2026)

Constitutional Law — Housing obligations — Municipality's failure to provide emergency housing — Appellant (Drakenstein Municipality) appealed against High Court's finding of breach of constitutional obligations to provide housing — Court held that the municipality had not adequately fulfilled its statutory and constitutional duties regarding emergency housing, particularly for evictees — Appeal upheld, High Court order set aside.

Constitutional Law
Score: 70

Halfgewaagd Boedery (Pty) Ltd v Bester NO and Another (2025/146990) [2026] ZAWCHC 656 (29 October 2026)

Winding up — Executory contract — Liquidation of Lamolor (Pty) Ltd — Applicant seeking compliance from liquidators to fulfill obligations under deed of sale — Court finding that liquidators must decide on the benefit of continuing obligations — Election to abide by contract established — Respondents ordered to evict occupiers and demolish dwellings as per agreement.

Insolvency Law
Score: 62

I.P v C.P and Others (913/2022) [2026] ZANWHC 282 (29 October 2026)

Divorce — Ancillary relief — Maintenance and accrual — Plaintiff seeking maintenance and inclusion of trust assets in accrual calculation — Court finding marriage irretrievably broken down and determining maintenance obligations — Trust assets not included in first defendant's estate due to lack of control by plaintiff over trust affairs — Maintenance awarded based on needs of adult children and plaintiff's limited employment prospects.

Family Law
Score: 62

T.S v Road Accident Fund (2861/2025) [2026] ZAFSHC 492 (29 October 2026)

Delict — Road Accident Fund — Damages for personal injury — Plaintiff, a minor pedestrian, injured in a collision with a vehicle — Claim for loss of past and future earnings due to mild traumatic brain injury and cognitive impairments — Defendant denying liability and alleging plaintiff's negligence — Court finding merits conceded in favor of plaintiff — Expert evidence on quantum accepted, leading to award for future loss of earnings calculated at R5,551,700 with contingencies applied.

Personal Injury
Score: 62

African Rainbow Minerals Ltd v Technology and Mineral Holdings (Pty) Ltd and Others (2025/113077; 2025/113159) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1250 (29 October 2026)

Insolvency Law — Business rescue proceedings — Intervention and postponement applications — ARM, a major creditor, seeking to set aside voluntary business rescues of Mintech and TAM — Late intervention applications by PGVM and the business rescue practitioner — Court finding that while the applications were late and lacked sufficient justification, the intervenors had a prima facie interest in the proceedings — Postponement granted with costs to be borne by the intervenors personally.

Insolvency Law
Score: 55