Semantis Law Reports

My Library

Elyas v Democratic Alliance and Others (2026/258188) [2026] ZAWCHC 648 (2 November 2026)

Interim Interdict — Political party membership — Applicant sought to suspend termination of membership pending review — Urgency established due to imminent local government elections — Applicant failed to demonstrate a prima facie right; interpretation of disciplinary settlement pact barred him from standing for any position — Clause interpreted to exclude campaign roles, and unauthorized subsequent invitations by party leaders did not alter the disciplinary sanction — Application for interim interdict dismissed, with costs awarded against the applicant.

Administrative Law
Score: 55

Mukansi N.O and Others v Nedbank and Others (2019/25860) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1245 (2 November 2026)

Execution — Rescission of judgment — Applicants seeking rescission of summary judgment order for execution against property — Court finding that applicants had notice of proceedings and failed to participate adequately — Rescission application dismissed as no valid grounds established for rescission under rule 42(1)(a) or common law.

Civil Procedure
Score: 55

Freedom Nkululeko Jojiyasi and Another v Eastern Cape PEC of the ANC and Others (0021/26EC) [2026] ZAEC 14 (2 November 2026)

Electoral Law — Party Lists — Challenge to ANC Eastern Cape party list for 2026 Local Government Elections — Applicants, members of the ANC, allege non-compliance with ANC constitution and internal procedures in candidate nominations — Application to declare party list unlawful and compel revision dismissed — Electoral Commission's authority to amend election timetable does not extend to exempting individual parties from deadlines — Decision upheld as lawful, rational, and reasonable — Application dismissed with no order as to costs.

Constitutional Law
Score: 45

R.H.K v Lawrence (587/2023) [2026] ZAWCHC 647 (2 November 2026)

Subpoena duces tecum — Application to compel compliance — Applicant sought to enforce a subpoena issued to the respondent for extensive financial documentation — Respondent opposed, arguing the subpoena was overly broad and irrelevant — Court found insufficient justification for the wide-ranging request and determined that the subpoena constituted an abuse of process — Application dismissed and subpoena set aside.

Civil Procedure
Score: 45

S.L.R v Tee Jay Trading (Pty) Ltd (2024/128725) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1256 (2 November 2026)

Insolvency Law — Winding up — Disputed debt — Applicant seeking winding up of company based on alleged debt — Respondent disputing existence of debt and claiming prescription — Court applying Badenhorst rule, determining that debt was bona fide disputed on reasonable grounds — Provisional winding up order not confirmed as applicant failed to establish debt at final stage.

Insolvency Law
Score: 45

Oppressed ACSA Minority 1 (Pty) Ltd and Others v Airports Company South Africa Soc Ltd and Others (27286/15) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1262 (2 November 2026)

Companies — Minority Shareholders — Unfair Prejudice — Applicants, minority shareholders in Airports Company South Africa (ACSA), alleging unfair prejudice by majority shareholder (Government) and seeking relief under s 163 of the Companies Act — Court determining that applicants failed to establish conduct constituting unfair prejudice — Application dismissed.

Company Law
Score: 40

Shoprite Checkers Proprietary Limited and Another v Junior Freshmark Market and Another (CT02941ADJ2016) [2026] COMPTRI 134 (1 November 2026)

Company Law — Name registration — Confusingly similar names — Applicants objecting to the registration of the name 'Junior Freshmark Market' by the First Respondent on grounds of similarity to their registered trademarks 'FRESHMARK' — Court finding that the First Respondent's name is confusingly similar and may mislead the public regarding association with the Applicants — First Respondent ordered to change its name to avoid confusion.

Company Law
Score: 60

African National Congress Youth League and Another v Independent Electoral Commission of UNISA and Others (2026/184797) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1257 (1 November 2026)

Administrative Law — Review of election proceedings — Applicants challenging the validity of the National Student Representative Council elections at Unisa — Allegations of procedural unfairness and lack of jurisdiction raised by respondents — Court finding that the applicants were denied the opportunity to respond to evidence presented by the IEC — Jurisdiction established based on historical areas of jurisdiction — Review application upheld, and election results declared invalid.

Administrative Law
Score: 45

Gabriel NO v Road Accident Fund (10758/2018) [2026] ZAWCHC 646 (30 October 2026)

Delict — Damages — Future loss of earning capacity and general damages — Minor child sustaining traumatic brain injury in motor vehicle collision — Plaintiff claiming R3 219 510 for future loss of earning capacity and R1 300 000 for general damages — Court finding substantial impairment of educational and vocational potential due to neurocognitive deficits — Damages awarded as claimed, with interest and costs

Delict
Score: 70

Gallant v S (Appeal) (A186/2026) [2026] ZAWCHC 643 (30 October 2026)

Criminal Law — Appeal — Conviction based solely on single witness testimony — Appellant convicted of murder based on evidence of Eileen Jacobs, who later contradicted herself — Court finding that the Regional Magistrate failed to properly assess the credibility of the witness and the appellant's version — Appeal upheld, conviction and sentence set aside.

Criminal Law
Score: 70

Minister of Electricity and Energy v African Climate Alliance and Others (516/2025) [2026] ZASCA 146 (30 October 2026)

Constitutional Law — Environmental Rights — Minister of Electricity and Energy's determination for 1500 MW coal-fired power generation challenged — Respondents arguing infringement of constitutional rights of children under sections 24 and 28 — High Court declaring decisions invalid due to lack of consideration for environmental impact — Appeal dismissed as moot due to subsequent publication of Integrated Resource Plan 2025, which excludes coal-fired power.

Constitutional Law
Score: 70

Radebe v S (AR435/18) [2026] ZAKZPHC 107 (30 October 2026)

Criminal Law — Rape — Appeal against conviction and sentence — Appellant convicted of two counts of rape and sentenced to 20 years and life imprisonment — Appeal court finding both convictions potentially unsound — Convictions set aside and replaced with verdicts of 'Not Guilty' — Court emphasizing the importance of justice over strict procedural adherence.

Criminal Law
Score: 70