Semantis Law Reports

My Library

Emmanuel Assemblies NPO v Mabitsela and Another (2464/2023) [2026] ZALMPPHC 109 (3 November 2026)

Administrative Law — Non-Profit Organization — Validity of Executive Council — Applicant seeking declaratory order regarding the legitimacy of its National Executive Council — Respondents, former members, attempting to disrupt operations and claim authority — Court finding that the Applicant's Executive Council was validly elected and that the Respondents had no authority to interfere — Interdict granted against Respondents to prevent disruption of Applicant's activities.

Administrative Law
Score: 57

Lombard Insurance Company Ltd v Bonifacio (2026/018758; 2026/018792) [2026] ZAGPJHC 1252 (3 November 2026)

Insolvency Law — Sequestration applications — Applications for sequestration of Jorge and Sergio Bonifacio by Lombard Insurance Company — Claims based on failure to satisfy a court judgment of R100m — Bonifacios evading service of writs — Court finding that Bonifacios committed acts of insolvency as defined in the Insolvency Act — Sequestration orders granted against both respondents.

Insolvency Law
Score: 55

Zibi v Amahlubi Chairman's Foundation and Another (2481/2025) [2026] ZANWHC 283 (3 November 2026)

Administrative Law — Authority to institute proceedings — Dispute regarding authority of traditional leader to represent juristic person — Applicant challenging validity of proceedings instituted by Foundation — Court determining necessity of oral evidence to resolve factual disputes regarding authority and compliance with Foundation's constitution — No finding made on validity of resolution or authority of traditional leader at this stage.

Administrative Law
Score: 55

Bongani Cibi v Independent Electoral Commission of South Africa (0024/26EC) [2026] ZAEC 16 (3 November 2026)

Electoral Law — Review jurisdiction of Electoral Court — Applicant seeking to contest municipal elections as a political party — Application for registration submitted late — No condonation sought — Commission's officials providing information regarding deadlines — Court finding no reviewable decision established as exclusion from election resulted from applicant's failure to comply with statutory requirements — Application dismissed.

Constitutional Law
Score: 45

Rodpaul Construction (Pty) Ltd t/a Rods Construction v City of Cape Town and Others (2026/209737) [2026] ZAWCHC 655 (3 November 2026)

Administrative Law — Tender Award — Urgent application for interim interdict against the City of Cape Town's decision to award a tender — Applicant's bid deemed unresponsive due to failure to provide a letter of good standing with the Bargaining Council — Court finding no urgency established and no irreparable harm demonstrated — Application dismissed with costs.

Administrative Law
Score: 45

Apex Autoservice Centre Proprietary Limited v Apex Performance Clutch and Brake Proprietary Limited (CT02693ADJ2026) [2026] COMPTRI 133 (3 November 2026)

Companies Tribunal — Default judgment — Application for default judgment against respondent for failure to respond — Applicant failing to serve initiating document within prescribed period as required by Regulation 142(2) of the Companies Act — Tribunal finding non-compliance with service requirements fatal to application — Application for default judgment refused.

Company Law
Score: 40

Rev Danzel P van Rensburg/Pose v Electoral Commission of South Africa and Others (0023/26 EC) [2026] ZAEC 15 (3 November 2026)

Electoral Law — Local government elections — Objection to candidacy — Applicant seeking clarification on the employment status of a ward candidate — Court finding that Schedule 3 of the Electoral Act does not provide for objections to candidacy — Application dismissed as unsustainable and outside the Court's jurisdiction.

Constitutional Law
Score: 40

Kgetlengrivier Concerned Citizens v Kgetlengrivier Local Municipality and Another (361/2025) [2026] ZASCA 148 (2 November 2026)

Administrative Law — Public Procurement — Appointment of service provider — Kgetlengrivier Concerned Citizens challenging the Municipality's appointment of Magalies Water without following due process — High Court dismissing the review application — Supreme Court of Appeal finding that the Municipality's decision was irrational and did not comply with constitutional procurement requirements — Appointment set aside and costs awarded to the appellant.

Administrative Law
Score: 78

Magwenyane v S (631/2025) [2026] ZASCA 149 (2 November 2026)

Criminal Law — Sentencing — Appeal against sentence — Applicant convicted of rape and sexual assault of minors — Age of applicant at time of offences not determined by regional court — Minimum sentencing regime inapplicable due to applicant being under 18 years old — Misapplication of law regarding age led to excessive cumulative sentence of 70 years — Sentence set aside and substituted with effective sentence of 11 years' imprisonment after proper consideration of age and mitigating factors.

Criminal Law
Score: 72

Aspen Pharmacare Holdings Limited v Aspen Enterprises (Pty) Ltd and Another (CT02530ADJ2025) [2026] COMPTRI 136 (2 November 2026)

Company Law — Name dispute — Applicant seeking to compel First Respondent to change its name — First Respondent's name found to be confusingly similar to Applicant's registered trademarks — Tribunal determining that First Respondent's name contravenes Section 11(2) of the Companies Act — Order issued for First Respondent to change its name to avoid public confusion and protect Applicant's reputation.

Company Law
Score: 65

Khoza v Road Accident Fund (A2025-115445) [2026] ZAMPMBHC 125 (2 November 2026)

Appeal — Delictual damages — Road Accident Fund — Appellant claiming damages for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident — Trial court dismissing claim due to lack of evidence — Appeal court finding that trial court misapplied Rule 38(2) of the Uniform Rules regarding the admission of evidence by affidavit — Appeal upheld and matter remitted for trial de novo before another judge.

Delict
Score: 62

Ithuba Lottery RF (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition and Others (Economic Freedom Fighters Intervening) (2 November 2026) NGP (108644/2025 ; 228028/2025) [2026] ZAGPPHC 1266 (2 November 2026)

Administrative Law — Review of Ministerial decision — Award of Fourth National Lottery License — Minister appointing a new committee for re-evaluation without notifying applicants — Conduct deemed procedurally and substantively unfair — Decision set aside and remitted for reconsideration — Application by Economic Freedom Fighters for broader interpretation of financial interest prohibition refused.

Administrative Law
Score: 60