Contempt of Court — Breach of court orders — Applicant seeking declaration of contempt against First and Second Respondents for violating court orders regarding the hosting of an annual religious ceremony — Court finding that First and Second Respondents were in contempt of the 2019 order but dismissing the application against the Third and Fourth Respondents — Costs awarded against the First and Second Respondents.
Labour — Review — Dismissal for misconduct — Senior municipal employee redesignated and instructed to report to new workstation but failed to do so — Altercation with Municipal Manager during meeting; employee alleged assault and lodged grievance; charged with dishonesty (false assault claim), intimidation (threatening remarks invoking former manager), and gross insubordination (refusal to obey instruction to return to workstation) — Dismissal after disciplinary hearing and unsuccessful internal appeal — Arbitration found dismissal substantively and procedurally fair — Review under s 145 LRA — Whether arbitrator committed gross irregularity in credibility findings, mischaracterised statements as threats, erred in finding gross insubordination, and whether sanction was shockingly inappropriate — Held: review court confined to whether outcome was one a reasonable decision-maker could reach; arbitrator reasonably found no assault beyond a light touch, that employee's allegation was dishonest, that his statements in context amounted to intimidation, and that his open defiance constituted gross insubordination; long service and clean record did not render dismissal inappropriate given senior position and erosion of trust — Application dismissed, no costs order.
Subcontracting — Liquidated monetary claim — Applicant seeking order compelling Second Respondent to pay amount owed by First Respondent — Court determining that Second Respondent, not party to agreement, cannot be compelled to pay Applicant — Application dismissed with costs.
Electoral Law — Local government elections — Non-compliance with nomination deadlines — Applicant seeking to review decision of Electoral Commission not to accept nomination as independent candidate — Court finding that applicant failed to submit nomination before deadline and that Commission had no power to condone non-compliance — Application dismissed.
Administrative Law — Review of municipal council resolutions — Applicant seeking to review resolutions reinstating Municipal Manager — Resolutions found to have material non-compliance with mandatory procedures — Council's failure to follow proper protocols for reinstatement — Resolutions reviewed and set aside, with the question of restoration remitted for lawful reconsideration.
Execution — Sale in execution — Special execution of primary residence — Appellants seeking to declare respondents' home specially executable for unpaid judgment debt — Magistrates' Court dismissing application — High Court upholding appeal, declaring property executable, and setting reserve price — Judicial oversight required before sale of primary residence, especially when debtors are unrepresented.
Criminal Procedure — Review — Deportation order — Accused convicted under s 49(1)(a) of the Immigration Act — Magistrate imposing sentence of 90 days' imprisonment and ordering deportation — Court finding that magistrate lacked authority to order deportation — Sentence set aside and substituted with a wholly suspended sentence — Review conducted under s 304(4) of the Criminal Procedure Act despite absence of automatic review provisions.
Property Law — Eviction — Unlawful occupation — Applicant seeking eviction of respondents from property purchased at public auction — Respondents claiming rights under purported leases — Court finding leases invalid due to liquidation and sequestration of previous owner — Eviction granted under common law and Prevention of Illegal Eviction Act 19 of 1998, with punitive costs awarded against respondents.
Delict — Occupational injury — Claim for damages arising from chemical exposure at workplace — Applicant injured by chemical sprayed by co-worker during employment — Respondent raising exception based on Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act (COIDA) — Court finding that injuries sustained did not arise out of Applicant's employment duties — Exception upheld, claim dismissed.
Legal Practice — Disciplinary proceedings — Application for removal from roll of legal practitioners — First respondent contending that disciplinary hearing was flawed due to incomplete record and failure to consider mitigating factors — Court determining that the application is not solely dependent on the Disciplinary Committee's recommendation and can proceed independently — Court empowered to adjudicate on the conduct of legal practitioners under section 44 of the Legal Practice Act.
Criminal Law — Appeal against conviction and sentence — Appellant convicted of murder and assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm — Appellant claiming self-defence — Court finding that the appellant was the aggressor and that the killing was unlawful — Appeal dismissed and sentence upheld as appropriate.
Criminal Law — Appeal against conviction — Appellant convicted of robbery with aggravating circumstances and murder — Appeal dismissed — Court finding that the doctrine of common purpose was correctly applied despite appellant's absence at the crime scene — Sufficient circumstantial evidence established appellant's involvement in the crimes — Testimony of section 204 witness corroborated by video evidence — Appeal court affirming trial court's findings on mens rea and reasonable doubt.