Appeal — Return of minor children — Section 18(1) of the Superior Courts Act 10 of 2013 allowing court to make decisions effective pending appeal under exceptional circumstances — Appellant removing children from Australia without consent — Court finding that irreparable harm must be proven alongside exceptional circumstances — Appeal upheld, order for immediate return of children set aside, children to remain in South Africa pending Supreme Court of Appeal decision.
Criminal Procedure — Review — Sentence exceeding jurisdiction — Applicant convicted of housebreaking with intent to steal and theft — Original sentence of four years' imprisonment imposed by district magistrate's court — Court finding that sentence exceeded statutory limits — Substituted sentence of three years' imprisonment imposed, reflecting seriousness of offence and jurisdictional constraints.
Criminal Law — Possession of firearms — Appeal against conviction and sentence for unlawful possession of prohibited firearms and ammunition — Appellants found in possession of firearms with obliterated serial numbers — Trial court rejecting appellants' evidence and accepting police testimony — Appeals dismissed as the trial court's findings were justified and no material irregularities were found.
Criminal Procedure — Discharge application — Application for discharge in terms of s 174 of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 — Accused charged with incitement to commit terrorism and public violence — Court finding that State presented prima facie case against accused — Application for discharge refused as evidence requires holistic evaluation at trial's conclusion.
Local Government Elections — Review of Electoral Commission's decision — Applicant challenging the inclusion of 'IND' identifier for independent candidates on ballot paper — Court finding that the Electoral Commission acted within its lawful powers under s 23 of the Municipal Electoral Act — Application dismissed as out of time and lacking urgency, with no order as to costs.
Family Law — Divorce — Interim maintenance — Rule 43 application for maintenance and care arrangements — Applicant seeking maintenance for children and spousal support — Respondent providing evidence of financial contributions and disputing applicant's claims — Court finding applicant failed to disclose true financial position — Application dismissed due to lack of merit and no prejudice to children.
Administrative Law — Leave to appeal — Applicants seeking leave to appeal against a judgment regarding municipal infrastructure maintenance — Court dismissing application for leave to appeal on grounds of lack of reasonable prospects of success — Applicants failing to demonstrate compelling reasons for appeal — Costs awarded against applicants upheld.
Insolvency Law — Locus standi — Application for relief regarding the Pieters Family Trust's insolvent estate — Applicant, a former trustee, lacks standing to seek declaratory relief and accounting from the respondents — Application dismissed due to improper service, lack of urgency, and unresolved disputes of fact — Court finds that the applicant's claims are barred by the provisions of the Insolvency Act 24 of 1936.
Civil Procedure — Motion proceedings — Referral to trial — Irresolvable dispute on material facts in motion proceedings concerning the Goliatskraal Trust — Applicants seeking removal of trustees and variation of trust deed — Respondents opposing and seeking counter-relief — Court finding that factual disputes necessitate a trial for proper resolution — Main and counterapplications referred to trial for determination of live issues.
Labour Law — Collective dismissals — Section 189/189A LRA — Urgent application under s189A(13) for interim relief to halt purported retrenchments and VSPs — Applicant union sought to interdict implementation and set aside VSPs on behalf of members, alleging failure to consider potential purchaser and lack of meaningful consultation — Facts: merger conditions, s197 transfer, section 189 notices issued, CCMA facilitation held with multiple meetings, employer presented business rationale and VSP offering two weeks' pay per year (with limited enhancements), vast majority of affected employees accepted VSPs, only one applicant member remained unsigned and facilitation to continue in respect of that employee — Legal issue: whether s189A(13) jurisdiction is engaged and whether employer complied with a fair procedure so as to preclude interim relief — Holding: Court found jurisdiction under s189A(13) properly invoked but that the employer had complied with a fair and meaningful consultation process; applicants failed to show clear-cut procedural unfairness going to the core of the process; urgent relief and set-aside of VSPs not justified; application dismissed.
Electoral Law — Review application — Internal party disputes — Applicants seeking to review final candidates list published by the Electoral Commission — Claims of non-compliance with nomination process and election timetable — Application dismissed due to lack of proof of service and failure to lodge application within prescribed time limits — No order as to costs.
Delict — Road Accident Fund — Future loss of earnings — Plaintiff claiming future loss of earning capacity for minor child injured in pedestrian accident — Court determining quantum based on expert evidence and contingencies — Causation established with pre-morbid and post-morbid contingencies applied — Award of R1 778 118.70 for future loss of earning capacity granted, with specific provisions for costs and interest.