1
IN THE COMPANIES TRIBUNAL OF SOUTH AFRICA
CASE NO: CT02941ADJ2016
In the matter between:
SHOPRITE CHECKERS PROPRIETARY
LIMITED FIRST APPLICANT
FRESHMARK PROPRIETARY LIMITED SECOND APPLICANT
AND
JUNIOR FRESHMARK MARKET FIRST RESPONDENT
COMPANIES AND INTELLECTUAL
PROPERTY COMMISSION SECOND RESPONDENT
Date of Decision: 1st November 2026
DECISION
INTRODUCTION
1. he First Applicant is Shoprite Checkers Proprietary Limited, a private
company with registration no. 1929/001817/07 registered in accordance with
the company laws of the Republic of South Africa with its principal place of
2
business being, Cnr William Dabbs Street and Old Paarl Road, Brackenfell
7560, South Africa.
2. The Second Applicant is Freshmark Proprietary Limited, a private
company with registration no. 1989/003165/07 registered in accordance with
the company laws of the Republic of South Africa with its principal place of
business being, Cnr William Dabbs Street and Old Paarl Road, Brackenfell
7560, South Africa
3. The First Respondent is Junior Freshmark Market Proprietary Limited,
a private company incorporated on 20 June 2024, with registration no.
2024/364655/07, with registered address being 321 Frederick Street, Flat
104 Indaba Flat, Pretoria, Gauteng, 0183, South Africa.
4. The Second Respondent is the Companies and Intellectual Property
Commission, an organ of state established in terms of Section 185 of the
Companies Act, with its registered office at DTI Campus, Block F, 77
Meintjies Street, Sunnyside, Pretoria, Gauteng (“CIPC”),
5. The Applicant applies to the Companies Tribunal in terms of Section
11(2) of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 (“the Companies Act” ), a name of a
company must not be the same as the name of another company,
domesticated company, registered external company, close corporation or
co-operative and must not be confusingly similar.
3
APPLICANT’S SUBMISSIONS
6. The Applicant is the proprietor, in South Africa, of the several
trademarks in the term FRESHMARK
7. The FRESHMARK Marks have been used on an extensive scale in
relation to inter alia the supply of fresh fruit and vegetables by the Second
Applicant since at least 1989, which is sold in the First Applicant's stores, i.e.
in excess of thirty-five years before the registration of the First Respondent;
8. JUNIOR FRESHMARK MARKET is confusingly similar to the First
Applicant's FRESHMARK Marks and the Second Applicant's company name
that if JUNIOR FRESHMARK MARKET were to be used and members of the
public were to see the First Respondent's name, they may think that the First
Respondent is associated with the Applicants. The inclusion of the word
"Market" provides an indication of the intended use of the company name in
relation to the sale of goods which falls within the business of the First
Applicant as a retailer of goods, and which includes the marketing and of a
variety of products under the FRESHMARK marks in its stores. It is
submitted that of itself "Junior" is descriptive and does not serve to
distinguish the respondent's names from the applicant's marks signifies as it
signifies a smaller or diminutive version of the market with the result that
FRESHMARK is undoubtedly the dominant and most memorable part of the
First Respondent's name.
4
9. The registration of the First Respondent's name would affect the
Applicants financially, thereby enabling the First Respondent to ride on the
coattails of the Applicants. Furthermore, the First Respondent's name falsely
imply, and would reasonably mislead the public into incorrectly believing that
the First Respondent is part of, affiliated with, or associated with the
Applicants, in contravention of Section 11 (2)(c)(i) of the Act.
10. The Applicant has attempted to resolve this matter without resorting to
litigation but has not received the First Respondent’s co- operation.
Therefore, the Applicant has no option but to proceed with this formal
objection.
NAME DISPUTES
APPLICABLE LAW
11. Section 11 of the Companies Act provides the criteria for names of
companies.
Subsection (2) is most relevant and states as follows:
“(2) the name of a company must –
(a) not be the same as, or confusingly similar to –
(i) the name of another company, registered external
company, close corporation or co- operative unless the
company forms part of a group of companies using
similar names;
(ii) ... Not relevant
(iii) a registered trademark belonging to a person other than
the company, or a mark in respect of which an
5
application has been filed in the Republic for registration
as a trademark or a well -known trademark as
contemplated in section 35 of the trademarks act; or
(iv) ... Not relevant
2 (b) not falsely imply or suggest, or be such as would reasonably
mislead a person to believe incorrectly, that the company –
(i) is part of, or associated with, any other person or entity;
EVALUATION AND FINDINGS
12. The purpose of section 11 of the Companies Act is to protect names
from being passed off by new companies registering similar names at the
expense of the original name holder of the company or trade mark . In the
case before me the First Respondents’ name is similar to several trade
marks held by the Applicant. Both Have the term FRESHMARK in them.
This may give members of the public the impression that the Respondent is
associated with the Applicant. This may affect the Applicants reputation and
financially.
13. The First Respondent is thus ordered to change its name to one that
does not include FRESHMARK in it.
ORDER
14. I find in favour of the Applicant
6
a. The First Respondent is directed to change its name to one
which does not incorporate “ FRESHMARK” and is not
confusingly and or deceptively similar to Applicant's.
b. The First Respondent is to file a notice of an amendment of its
Memorandum of Incorporation, within 60 days of receipt of this
order in order to change its name as per above.
c. In the event that the First Respondent fails to comply with the
order as aforementioned, within 3 months, from the date of the
order, that Companies and Intellectual Property Commission
(CIPC) be directed, in terms of Section 160(3) (b) (ii) read with
section 14(2) of the Act, to change the First respondent’s name
to is registered company number being 2024/364655/07 as the
First Respondent’s interim company name on the Companies
register.
d. The First Respondent is hereby exempted from the requirement
to pay the prescribed fee for filing the notice of amendment
contemplated in this paragraph.
e. The Second R espondent is required to register the name
applied for by the applicant once the Respondents name is
removed from the registrar by the First Respondent or by CIPC
within three months of the First Respondent failing to do so.
f. The registrar of the Tribunal is instructed to bring this ruling to
the attention of CIPC.
MOHAMED ALLI CHICKTAY
MEMBER OF THE COMPANIES TRIBUNAL