THE ELECTORAL COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
BLOEMFONTEIN
Not reportable
Case no: 0031/26EC
In the matter between:
ANDRÉ DAWID LÖTTER Applicant
and
ELECTORAL COMMISSION OF SOUTH AFRICA Respondent
Neutral citation: André Dawid Lötter v Electoral Commission of South Africa
(0031/26EC) [2026] ZAEC 18 (06 November 2026)
Coram: ADAMS J, YACOOB and MANGCU-LOCKWOOD AJJ
Heard: Decided in Chambers on the Papers
Delivered: This judgment was handed down electronically by circulation to the parties
representatives by email, publication on the Supreme Court of Appeal
website and by release to SAFLII. The date and time for hand -down is
deemed to be 09h00 on 06 November 2026.
Summary: Local Government Elections – s 23 of the Local Government: Municipal
Electoral Act 27 of 2000 – review of the Electoral Commission’s design of ballot papers –
use of the identifier ‘IND’ for independent ward candidates – whether the decision is lawful
and rational – whether the application is out of time in terms of rule 6 of the Electoral
Court Rules – application for condonation – application dismissed with no order as to
costs.
2
ORDER
1. The application is dismissed.
2. There is no order as to costs.
JUDGMENT
Adams J (Yacoob and Mangcu-Lockwood AJJ concurring):
[1] On 3 November 2026, we issued an order dismissing the application, with no order
as to costs. We indicated that reasons for the said order would be provided in due course.
These are the reasons for the order we granted.
[2] The applicant (Mr Lötter ) is contesting the upcoming 2026 Local Government
Elections (2026 LGE), as a registered independent candidate in Ward 13 of the Setsoto
Local Municipality in the Free State Province . The elections were scheduled for
4 November 2026 and special voting had already commenced on Monday, 2 November
2026. The respondent (Electoral Commission) is the election management body in South
Africa. Mr Lötter, acting in person, applies on an urgent basis for an order reviewing and
setting aside the Electoral Commission’s decision to approve the entry ‘IND’ in the party
identification block alongside his candidature on the Ward 13 ward ballot for the 2026
LGE. He also seeks an order directing the Electoral Commission to remove the said entry
‘IND’ from that block and to leave the block entirely blank.
[3] Having read the papers and the written argument filed on behalf of both parties,
this Court has determined that it is expedient and in the interests of justice to determine
the matter in chambers without an oral hearing, in accordance with its powers in terms of
rule 2 read with rule 11 of the rules regulating the conduct of the proceedings of the
Electoral Court (Electoral Court Rules) . The parties were informed of this possibility in
paragraph 6 of the Directives issued on 26 October 2026.
3
[4] To place in context the issues in dispute between the parties in this matter, it is
apposite to cite in full the relevant part of the Mr Lötter’s notice of motion, which indicates
that he will be seeking an order in the following terms:
‘5. Reviewing and setting aside, to the extent necessary, the respondent's decision, approval
or conduct in authorising or providing for the entry ‘IND’ in the party identification block
alongside the applicant's candidature on the Ward 13 ward ballot for the 2026 Local
Government Elections in Setsoto Local Municipality, Free State.
6. Directing the respondent to remove the entry ‘IND’ from that block and to leave the block
entirely blank, with no abbreviation, word, label, description or substitute entry of any kind.
7. Directing that the applicant's full name, André Dawid Lötter, and his photograph be retained
in their appropriate places on the Ward 13 ward ballot, and that the correction in paragraph
6 not result in the removal or alteration of his candidature, name or photograph.
8. Directing the respondent, to the extent reasonably and practically possible before polling
day on 4 November 2026, to implement the correction and take such steps as the Court
considers appropriate to give effect to its order.’
[5] Mr Lötter is therefore challenging the Electoral Commission’s decision to include
the abbreviation ‘IND’ – which is short for ‘independent’ – in the party identification column
alongside his name on the Ward 13 ballot paper. He seeks an order reviewing and setting
aside this design choice and an order directing the Electoral Commission to leave the
block entirely blank, while retaining his name and photograph.
[6] The Electoral Commission opposes the application. It raises two primary defences.
First, it contends that the application is materially out of time in terms of rule 6 of the
Electoral Court Rules and that no proper case has been made out by Mr Lötter for the
Electoral Court Rules and that no proper case has been made out by Mr Lötter for the
matter to be heard as one of urgency. Second, it submits that the decision to include ‘IND’
is lawful and rational, falling squarely within the Electoral Commission’s statutory mandate
under s 23 of the Local Government: Municipal Electoral Act 27 of 2000 (Municipal
Electoral Act).
[7] The crisp, narrow and pertinent issue to be decided in this matter is this: whether
the Electoral Commission in deciding to include ‘IND’ next to the name of Mr Lötter on the
Ward 13 Setsoto ballot paper for the 2026 LGE, acted unlawfully. Put differently, has
4
Mr Lötter made out a case to have reviewed and set aside the aforesaid decision as
unlawful? This issue is to be decided against the factual backdrop of the matter, most if
not all of the facts herein, as set out in the paragraphs which follow, being common cause.
[8] The main difficulty faced by Mr Lötter is s 23, which provides as follows:
‘23 Ballot papers
The Commission must determine the design of the ballot paper or ballot papers to be used in an
election.’ (Emphasis added).
[9] In Action SA v The Electoral Commission of South Africa (Action SA),1 this Court
interpreted s 23 as empowering and obliging the Electoral Commission to determine the
design of the ballot paper or ballot papers for use in an election. It held as follows:
‘[24] From the above provisions of s 23, it is plain that the Commission has the requisite power,
and is in fact, obliged to determine the design of the ballot paper or ballot papers for use in an
election. No one else has such power, and clearly two types of ballot papers are envisaged. There
are clearly no other restrictions, directions, conditions or guidelines, or discretionary instructions
accompanying the Commission’s exercise of its powers in this regard. This, for obvious reasons
too. One of these is that the Commission may not, in the exercise of its powers to design the ballot
paper or ballot papers, consult any of the registered political parties privately, or independently
on its own initiative, as to how to design the ballot paper or papers. Admittedl y, there are
numerous other political parties involved here, not cited in this application. In any event, such
eventuality would, undoubtedly, violate the trite principles of natural justice principle of audi
alteram partem (hear the other side).’
[10] That brings me to the facts in the matter, which, as I have already indicated, are
by and large common cause.
[11] On 25 September 2026, in Ficksburg, Mr Lötter attended a presentation in
[11] On 25 September 2026, in Ficksburg, Mr Lötter attended a presentation in
Ficksburg by the Electoral Commission, which displayed proposed ballot designs on a
large screen. Mr Lötter observed the entry ‘IND’ beside his name. He raised concerns
about the design, as well as about the placement of the voting boxes and the ‘IND’ entry
and refused to sign off on the proposed ballot. He was not provided with a physical copy
1 Action SA v The Electoral Commission of South Africa (006/2021/EC) [2022] ZAEC 2 (18 January 2022)
at para 24.
5
of the proposed ballot. He later prepared an AI -assisted illustrative reconstruction of the
ballot, which he readily concedes is not an official document. Mr Lötter does not disclose
whether he noticed that other independent candidates, if any, also had IND next to their
name. He seeks only that the indicator be removed from his own name on the ballot
paper.
[12] On 19 October 2026, Mr Lötter attended a further ceremony where candidates
were invited to sign an undertaking to abide by the Electoral Code of Conduct. He raised
concerns regarding special voting percentages and the lack of substantive discussion on
the Code. On 26 October 2026, more than a month after becoming aware of the ballot
paper design, and a week before special voting would begin, he launched the present
application.
[13] The Electoral Commission is the constitutionally designated authority to manage
elections and to ensure that they are free and fair . The rationality standard requires that
any and all decisions taken by it must be rationally related to the purpose for which the
relevant power to make that decision was given. The Electoral Commission confirms in
its answering affidavit that it has designed the ballot papers to use ‘IND’ as an identifier
for every independent ward candidate across the country, and that this has been used in
the 2021 local government elections and the 2024 national and provincial elections.
[14] As was held in Action SA, although s 23 of the Municipal Electoral Act confers on
the Electoral Commission a wide discretion in the true sense , such discretion and the
powers of the Commission under the said section must still be exercised correctly,
judiciously and properly, taking into account all relevant factors and circumstances. The
powers are not without restrictions and must be read and interpreted together with the
Constitution and other relevant legislative provisions.
[15] In Maxrae Estates (Pty) Ltd v The Minister of Agriculture, Forestry & Fisheries ,2
[15] In Maxrae Estates (Pty) Ltd v The Minister of Agriculture, Forestry & Fisheries ,2
the Supreme Court of Appeal puts the principle as follows:
2 Maxrae Estates (Pty) Ltd v The Minister of Agriculture, Forestry & Fisheries 2021 JDR 1115 (SCA);
(407/2020) [2021] ZASCA 73 (9 June 2021) at para 17.
6
‘… However, the wide Ministerial discretion essentially entailed the consideration by him of the
factors that were relevant to the decision he was required to make. The exercise of a wide
discretion was no licence for disregarding those factors and making an arbitrary decision. And the
Minister could not use the doctrine of separation of powers to shield such arbitrary decision from
reviews by the Court. Mere mention that the Ministerial discretion has been exercised for the given
purpose was not sufficient. The court was constrained to intervene where the decisionmaker had
ignored the relevant factors and taken into account irrelevant considerations.’
[16] The question to be considered by this Court in light of the aforegoing principles is
whether the Electoral Commission exercised its power under s 23 lawfully. In that regard,
the Commission has the exclusive authority to determine ballot design . T here is no
legislative prohibition on the use of an identifier for independent candidates.
[17] The Electoral Commission accordingly maintains that its decision, insofar as one
was taken to use ‘IND’ as an identifier for independent candidates, is lawful, rational and
constitutional. I agree. It cannot be said with any conviction that the insertion of the ‘IND’
identifier to denote that a candidate is independent is irrational. It serves the legitimate
purpose of enabling voters to identify the candidate of their choice with confidence and
minimising the risk of miscast and spoilt ballots. It tells voters, accurately, that the
candidate is independent and not nominated by a party. It ensures that the identifier
column is populated consistently, so that a voter reading down the column can see
whether each contestant represents a party or stands independently. It is uniform across
all wards in the country, supporting coher ent voter education messaging. By contrast, a
blank space is used for party -nominated candidates whose party has not registered an
blank space is used for party -nominated candidates whose party has not registered an
abbreviated name. Leaving Mr Lötter’s space blank would make his entry resemble that
of a party candidate without a registered abbreviation, which would be more, not less,
likely to cause confusion.
[18] Moreover, Mr Lötter’s claim that the identifier will cause voter confusion is at best
speculative. He concedes that he has not observed any voter being confused by the ‘IND’
identifier. It has also not been demonstrated that ballots have been spoiled purportedly
as a result of the aforesaid design of the ballot paper. By all accounts, the adverse effects
which concern him, as conceded by Mr Lötter, have not been and cannot be quantified,
7
probably because there are no such negative effects. The point is simply that there is no
evidence, expert or otherwise, of confusion or negative impact as a result of the ‘IND’
identifier other than in Mr Lötter’s imagination. The voters who asked him which party he
belongs to did so in the course of campaigning, not on seeing the ballot paper. The
identifier ‘IND’ in fact answers that very question.
[19] Importantly, the relief sought by Mr Lötter , if granted, would create a single
bespoke deviation from the design applied to all independent ward candidates. The
Constitutional Court has emphasised that the electoral framework protects the integrity of
the electoral process by avoiding ad hoc decisions and treating all candidates and parties
equally. So, for example, it was held in Electoral Commission v Inkatha Freedom Party
(Inkatha Freedom Party),3 as follows:
‘It is necessary that the integrity of the electoral process be maintained. Indeed, the acceptance
of the election as being free and fair depends upon that integrity. Elections must not only be free
and fair, but they must be perceived as being free and fair. Even-handedness in dealing with all
political parties and candidates is crucial to that integrity and its perception by voters. The
Commission must not be placed in a situation where it has to make ad hoc decisions about
political parties and candidates who have not complied with the Act. The requirement that
documents must be submitted to the local offices of the Commission does not undermine the right
to vote and to stand for election. It simply gives effect to that right and unde rscores the
decentralised and local nature of municipal elections.’
[20] Mr Lötter has not been singled out . T he same identifier is applied to all 636
independent ward candidates contesting the 2026 LGE. On the other hand, the
suggestions by Mr Lötter – that he should have been afforded an opportunity to comment
suggestions by Mr Lötter – that he should have been afforded an opportunity to comment
on and give input in relation to the way in which his details are reflected on the ballot –
are impractical and innately unreasonable. In addition to adding unnecessary costs, to be
borne by South Africans, the proposed course would be adding further procedural steps,
which would prolong the preparations for the elections . The same consideration applies
to the proposal by Mr Lötter that ward candidates should be provided with sample ballot
3 Electoral Commission v Inkatha Freedom Party [2011] ZACC 16; 2011 (9) BCLR 943 (CC); 2011 JDR
0421 (CC) at para 55.
8
papers, which, according to him, would promote transparency and permit meaningful
scrutiny of ballot design.
[21] Lastly, and importantly, Mr Lötter’s political rights under s 19 of the Constitution
remain fully respected and are not in any way violated by the insertion of the independent
identifier. He has been accepted as a n independent ward candidate and has been
registered as such. He appears on the ballot paper under his full name and photograph.
Conversely, if Mr Lötter is to be granted the relief sought by him in this application, there
is a real risk that the freeness and the fairness of the upcoming elections would be
adversely affected by, for example, a postponement of certain segments of the elections.
The relief sought by Mr Lötter should not be granted so as to maintain the integrity of the
electoral process , upon which the acceptance of the election as being free and fair
depends (to borrow from Inkatha Freedom Party).
[22] I therefore conclude that the decision by the Electoral Commission relative to the
design of the Ward 13 Setsoto ballot paper, is not unlawful or unconstitutional. Mr Lötter’s
judicial review application should therefore be refused.
[23] There is another reason why the application should fail and that relates to urgency
or rather the fact that Mr Lötter failed miserably in demonstrating that the application
should be heard as an urgent application. Rule 6 of the Electoral Court Rules requires a
review application to be lodged within three days of the decision being made. Rule 10
provides that a party who fails to comply is barred unless the court, on good cause shown,
directs otherwise.
[24] Mr Lötter became aware of the ‘IND’ identifier on 25 September 2026. He explicitly
states in his founding affidavit that he raised concerns about it on that date. At the very
latest, he had actual knowledge of the feature he now challenges on that day. The three-
day period expired on 28 September 2026. The application was launched on 26 October
day period expired on 28 September 2026. The application was launched on 26 October
2026, some 31 calendar days later.
[25] Mr Lötter’s primary contention is that the three-day period should not be treated as
having begun on 25 September 2026 because he was not provided with an official copy
9
of the ballot and because the decision was not clearly communicated. I find this argument
unpersuasive. Mr Lötter admits he saw the identifier, understood it, and objected to it on
the day. The absence of a physical copy did not prevent him from identifying the feature
he wished to challenge. The decision was the Electoral Commission’s determination of
the ballot design under s 23, which was made and communicated to candidates at the
presentation.
[26] Even if Mr Lötter’s understanding of the legal implications evolved over time, that
does not suspend the running of the time limit. The rule is designed to ensure prompt
adjudication of electoral disputes. Mr Lotter’s reliance on the development of his legal
argument is insufficient to explain the delay.
[27] His alternative request for condonation must also fail. He has not provided a full
and satisfactory explanation for the entire period of the delay. He explains that between
25 September and 10 October 2026 he had not yet developed his legal argument; that
between 10 and 14 October 2026 he focused on the issue; and that he faced personal
difficulties, including lack of electricity and internet access. However, he attended election
events during this period, including the 19 October 2026 ceremony, and was able to
communicate with the Electoral Commission. As this Court recently held in Phoshoko v
Electoral Commission of South Africa (Phoshoko),4 a candidate who leaves matters to
the last minute places himself in the position in which he finds himself.
[28] Mr Lötter ’s personal circumstances as a self -represented litigant are
understandable, but they do not constitute good cause for a delay of this magnitude in a
forum where statutory urgency applies. The delay has prejudiced the Electoral
Commission, which has had mere hours to respond, and has brought the matter before
the court when ballot papers have already been printed and are in distribution. The
application should therefore fail for lack of urgency.
application should therefore fail for lack of urgency.
4 Phoshoko v Electoral Commission of South Africa (0019/26EC) [2026] ZAEC 10 (22 October 2026)
para 33.
10
[29] One last issue requires my attention, that being the Electoral Commission’s
application for condonation of the late filing of its answering affidavit. The Commission
was required to file its answering affidavit by 19h30 on 27 October 2026. It filed on
28 October 2026, approximately 18 hours late. The explanation provided by the Electoral
Commission is that the Chief Electoral Officer was attending to urgent duties at the
National Results Operation Centre, and that a comprehensive response required
consultation with staff across different provinces.
[30] While the explanation is not perfect, the delay was short, and Mr Lötter, who
bizarrely opposed the application for condonation, was able to file a replying affidavit
within the time available to him. Mr Lötter has not demonstrated any, let alone substantial
prejudice. In Phoshoko, this Court granted condonation for a late answering affidavit filed
by the Electoral Commission in comparable circumstances. In the interests of justice,
condonation should be granted.
[31] The late filing of the Electoral Commission’s answering affidavit is accordingly
condoned, and same is received and admitted into the record.
[32] In the circumstances, Mr Lötter’s application falls to be dismissed.
Costs
[33] The award of costs is a matter which is within the discretion of the court considering
the issue of costs. This discretion must be exercised judicially, having regard to all the
relevant considerations. One such consideration is the practice in this Court, in line with
Biowatch Trust v Registrar, Genetic Resources, and Others,5 that no costs orders should
be granted against an unsuccessful party. But this is not an inflexible rule, and it can be
departed from where there are strong reasons justifying such departure, such as in
instances where the litigation is frivolous or vexatious. I mention – only in passing – that,
in my view, the litigation by Mr Lötter in casu was clearly frivolous. Objectively viewed, it
5 in Biowatch Trust v Registrar Genetic Resources and Others [2009] ZACC 14; 2009 (6) SA 232 (CC);
2009 (10) BCLR 1014 (CC).
11
is difficult to comprehend why, in the circumstances of the matter, Mr Lötter insisted on
persisting with his ill-advised application.
[34] All the same, I remain of the view that there is no reason why the aforegoing
general rule should be departed from. Each party should therefore bear its own costs.
Order
[35] In the result and for these reasons, the following order was granted on Tuesday,
3 November 2026:
1 The application is dismissed.
2 There is no order as to costs.
_______________________________________
L R ADAMS
JUDGE OF THE ELECTORAL COURT
Bloemfontein
12
Appearances:
For the applicant: André Dawid Lötter
Instructed by: In person
For respondent: M De Beer
Instructed by: Eversheds Sutherland (SA) Incorporated,
Johannesburg
Honey Attorneys, Bloemfontein