About SAFLII
Databases
Search
Terms of Use
RSS Feeds
South Africa: Cape Town Labour Court, Cape Town
You are here:
SAFLII
>>
Databases
>>
South Africa: Cape Town Labour Court, Cape Town
>>
2026
>>
[2026] ZALCCT 188
|
Noteup
|
LawCite
South African Municipal Workers Union (SAMWU) obo Dous v Oudtshoorn Local Municipality and Others (C363/2024) [2026] ZALCCT 188 (5 November 2026)
Download original files
PDF format
RTF format
THE
LABOUR COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
HELD AT CAPE TOWN
Case
No:
C363/2024
(1)
Reportable: No
(2)
Of interest to other Judges: No
(3)
Revised
05
November 2026
In
the matter between:
SOUTH
AFRICAN MUNICIPAL WORKERS
Applicant
UNION
(SAMWU) obo MORENA DOUSE
and
OUDTSHOORN
LOCAL MUNICIPALITY
First Respondent
SOUTH
AFRICAN LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Second Respondent
BARGAINING
COUNCIL
FRANCOIS
VAN DER MERWE (N.O.)
Third Respondent
Heard:
29 April 2026
Delivered:
05 November 2026
Summary
(Review – dismissal for
misconduct – senior employee – long service –
serious insubordination and false
claim of assault - arbitrator’s
decision within the band of reasonable outcomes on the available
evidence – application
dismissed)
JUDGMENT
LAGRANGE J
Introduction
[1]
This is an opposed application brought in
terms of section 145 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 ('the
LRA') to review and
set aside an arbitration award issued on 19 July
2024 by the third respondent ('the arbitrator') under case number
WCP012402, under
the auspices of the South African Local Government
Bargaining Council ('the SALGBC'). In his award, the arbitrator found
that the
dismissal of the applicant's member, Mr M Douse ('Douse'),
was both substantively and procedurally fair.
[2]
The applicant seeks
an order setting aside the award and substituting it with an order
that Douse was unfairly dismissed, together
with retrospective
reinstatement. The first respondent ('the municipality') opposes the
application, maintaining that the award
is unassailable and one that
a reasonable arbitrator could have reached on the evidence before
him.
Outline Chronology of
Events Leading to Dismissal
[3]
Douse commenced employment with the
municipality in 2005. At the time of the events giving rise to this
dispute, he occupied the
post of Senior Superintendent in the Parks
Division, earning a gross monthly remuneration of R41 563,71.
[4]
Following an
internal restructuring and redesign process, Douse was redesignated
and instructed to take up a placement at the Bergoord
section. Douse
lodged an internal appeal against this placement. It is common cause
that he had still not reported to his assigned
post at Bergoord,
despite several interactions with the Municipal Manager, Mr W
Hendricks ('Hendricks'), who had directed him to
take up his duties
there.
[5]
On 3 May 2023,
Hendricks convened a meeting in his office with staff of the Human
Settlements Department. Douse and two colleagues,
who had also been
affected by the placement exercise, went to the office to attend the
meeting. Hendricks informed Douse that he
was not permitted to attend
because he was no longer attached to the
Human
Settlements Department. He instructed him to return to his
workstation and to wait outside.
[6]
After the
departmental meeting concluded and the attendees had exited, Douse
went into the Municipal Manager's office. An altercation
between
Douse and Hendricks followed in the foyer to the office. Hendricks
again instructed Douse to leave and go to his workstation,
gesturing
toward the door. Douse asserted that Hendricks pushed him and laid
hands on him. Douse also made statements referring
to a former
municipal manager, one Mr R Lottering ('Lottering').
[7]
Immediately following the incident, Douse
and his two colleagues lodged a grievance with the executive mayor,
alleging that Hendricks
had acted in a rude, threatening, and
intimidating manner and had committed an assault on Douse. They asked
for Hendricks' dismissal.
Douse was subsequently charged with three
counts of misconduct, namely: dishonesty (falsely alleging that
Hendricks assaulted him
by pushing him), intimidation (acting
aggressively and uttering threats toward Hendricks), and gross
insubordination (refusing
a lawful instruction to return to his
workstation and challenging Hendricks). Following an internal
disciplinary hearing and an
unsuccessful internal appeal, Douse was
dismissed on 29 December 2023.
Arbitrator's Award
Summary of Factual
Findings
[8]
The arbitrator found that Douse committed
all three counts of misconduct levelled against him. On the charge of
dishonesty, the
arbitrator found on the evidence that Hendricks did
not push or assault Douse. He found that, at most, there had been a
gentle
touch to the shoulder while Hendricks was gesturing toward the
door to usher Douse out of the office, and that in context this
contact could not constitute an assault. Accordingly, the arbitrator
found that Douse's allegation of an assault was false and dishonest.
[9]
In respect of the charge of intimidation,
the arbitrator found that Douse confronted Hendricks in an
aggressive, defiant, and heated
manner. He found that Douse's
statement warning Hendricks that he would see what would happen to
him, coupled with the express
invocation of Lottering , who had been
charged and dismissed, constituted a threat.
[10]
Regarding the charge of gross
insubordination, the arbitrator found that Douse failed to comply
with a lawful and reasonable instruction
from the Municipal Manager
to leave and return to his workstation at Bergoord. The arbitrator
found that Douse chose to remain
behind to confront Hendricks, and
that this insubordination was gross in the light of the history of
the matter and Douse's persistent
refusal to take up his assigned
placement.
[11]
On the question of parity, the arbitrator
found that the municipality did not act inconsistently in
disciplining only Douse and
not his two colleagues. The evidence
demonstrated that the two colleagues walked away once the altercation
commenced and played
no active part in the confrontation, uttered no
threats, and did not disobey instructions.
Summary of Arbitrator's
Reasoning
[12]
The arbitrator narrowed the true dispute
before him by separating the allegations of misconduct from
background organisational disputes.
He reasoned that the arbitration
was not about whether Douse's placement at Bergoord was fair, whether
his appeal had merit, or
whether his director had told him to attend
the meeting. The critical inquiry was simply whether Douse committed
the misconduct
on 3 May 2023 by virtue of his statements and actions.
[13]
In weighing the conflicting versions
regarding the alleged assault, the arbitrator had regard to the
balance of probabilities and
the absence of corroboration. Not a
single witness called by Douse confirmed that Hendricks pushed him.
By contrast, the municipality's
witness, Mrs Jones, stated that
Hendricks merely touched Douse's shoulder while ushering him out, and
she had spontaneously refuted
Douse's assertion of assault at the
time of the incident.
[14]
In evaluating the threatening statements,
the arbitrator rejected Douse's explanation that he was merely making
a passing observation
about the expiry of fixed-term contracts of
municipal managers when he mentioned Lottering. The arbitrator
reasoned that this version
lacked the ring of truth and that an
aggrieved employee engaged in an argument was, on the probabilities,
issuing an intimidatory
warning.
[15]
In determining the appropriateness of the
sanction of dismissal, the arbitrator considered Douse's long service
since 2005 and clean
disciplinary record, but concluded that these
factors did not outweigh the gravity of the misconduct. He reasoned
that insubordination
toward the accounting officer, aggravated by
threats and a false assault claim, materially compromised the
relationship of trust,
respect, and confidence required in the
workplace. Consequently, from a risk management perspective,
dismissal fell within the
band of reasonable penalties.
Grounds of Review
[16]
The applicant advances four main grounds of
review against the award.
[17]
Firstly, the applicant contends that the
arbitrator committed a gross irregularity in finding Douse dishonest.
It is argued that
because it was common cause that Hendricks touched
Douse on the shoulder, Douse held an honest and genuine belief that
he had been
assaulted, particularly while voices were raised. The
applicant further criticizes the arbitrator for failing to make an
adverse
credibility finding against Hendricks, who maintained in his
testimony that he never touched Douse at all.
[18]
Secondly, the applicant argues that no
reasonable arbitrator could have found that Douse's statements
constituted a threat. It is
submitted that the reference to Lottering
was a statement of fact concerning an accounting officer who had been
dismissed, and
that what Douse meant, was that if his grievance
succeeded, Hendricks would suffer the same fate. The applicant
contends that the
arbitrator failed to evaluate the statement
holistically.
[19]
Thirdly, the applicant argues that the
arbitrator erred in finding that Douse committed gross
insubordination. It is argued that
Douse had reason to believe he was
entitled to attend the meeting while challenging his placement, and
that the interaction was
characterized by mutual annoyance rather
than gross defiance.
[20]
Fourthly, the applicant challenges the
sanction of dismissal as shockingly inappropriate, having regard to
Douse's 18 years of service,
clean record, and the fact that
colleagues who signed the same grievance were not charged.
Evaluation
[21]
It
is trite that a review under section 145 of the LRA is not an appeal.
The review court does not ask whether the arbitrator's
decision was
correct, but whether the conclusion reached is one that a reasonable
decision-maker could reach on the evidence before
them. In
Gold
Fields Mining SA (Pty) Ltd (Kloof Gold Mine) v Commission for
Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
,
[1]
the Labour Appeal Court emphasized that the inquiry must be conducted
on the totality of the evidence and not on a fragmented,
piecemeal
analysis that assumes the form of an appeal.
[22]
The applicant's first ground of review is
essentially a challenge to the arbitrator's evaluation of the
conflicting versions and
credibility. The charge of dishonesty was
based on Douse's initial claim that Hendricks had aggressively pushed
and shoved him
out of the office. Not a single witness supported the
version that a push occurred. The arbitrator accepted that Hendricks
made
light physical contact with Douse's shoulder while showing him
out. The arbitrator was fully entitled to find that an administrative
guiding gesture did not constitute an assault, and that Douse's
escalation of the incident into a formal complaint of criminal
conduct against the Municipal Manager was dishonest. That finding was
reasonable on the material before the arbitrator.
[23]
In respect of the threatening remarks,
Douse admitted making the statement referencing Lottering and warning
Hendricks that he would
see what would happen to him. The arbitrator
was faced with two competing interpretations of those words. Given
that the words
were uttered during a confrontational exchange in
which Douse was shouting and angry, the arbitrator's conclusion that
the statement
was intended to intimidate Hendricks is a sensible and
probable inference. An arbitrator is entitled to reject self-serving,
benign
reinterpretations of confrontational statements that lack
credibility.
[24]
Turning to the charge of insubordination,
it is undisputed that Hendricks instructed Douse to leave and go to
his workstation. Douse
did not comply. Instead, he remained in the
foyer to confront Hendricks and declared that he would not report at
Bergoord. Whatever
Douse's views may have been regarding his
placement appeal, he was not entitled to defy a direct and lawful
instruction issued
by the head of the administration. Defiance of
managerial authority can be established by a single act of defiance.
In this instance,
the defiance was displayed openly in front of
office staff, and the arbitrator's categorization of the misconduct
as gross was
not unwarranted on the evidence.
[25]
Finally, on the question of sanction, the
arbitrator was required to take into account all the relevant
circumstances. The parity
argument raised by the applicant is without
merit because the two colleagues in question were not similarly
situated. They walked
away when the altercation began and did not
engage in insolent, threatening, or insubordinate conduct. While
Douse had 18 years
of service and a clean disciplinary record, long
service did not immunise him against dismissal in circumstances
where, as
an employee in a senior supervisory position, he displayed
sustained defiance, uttered threats, and fabricated an assault charge
against the accounting officer. The arbitrator's finding that the
employment relationship had been materially damaged and that
dismissal was a fair sanction is entirely within the range of
reasonable outcomes.
Conclusion
[26]
In the circumstances, the applicant has
failed to establish that the arbitrator committed any gross
irregularity in the conduct
of the arbitration or that the award is
one that a reasonable arbitrator could not reach on the record. The
application must accordingly
be dismissed.
[27]
On the question of costs, this Court has a
broad discretion in terms of section 162 of the LRA. The applicant
trade union litigated
in good faith on behalf of its member, and the
requirements of law and fairness do not warrant a costs order in this
instance.
Order
1.
The
application to review and set aside the arbitration award issued by
the Third Respondent under case number WCP012402 is dismissed.
2.
There is no
order as to costs.
R Lagrange
Judge
of the Labour Court of South Africa
Appearances:
For the
Applicant:
--- E Geldenhuys from Macgregor
Erasmus Attorneys Inc
For the
Respondent: --- A
Erasmus
Instructed
by:
--- Van Rooyen Inc
[1]
(2014)
35
ILJ
943 (LAC)