Khoza v Road Accident Fund (A2025-115445) [2026] ZAMPMBHC 125 (2 November 2026)

62 Reportability

Brief Summary

Appeal — Delictual damages — Road Accident Fund — Appellant claiming damages for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident — Trial court dismissing claim due to lack of evidence — Appeal court finding that trial court misapplied Rule 38(2) of the Uniform Rules regarding the admission of evidence by affidavit — Appeal upheld and matter remitted for trial de novo before another judge.

SAFLII Note: Certain personal/private details of parties or witnesses have been redacted from this
document in compliance with the law and SAFLII Policy

IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
MPUMALANGA DIVISION, MBOMBELA MAIN SEAT
JUDGMENT


Not Reportable
Case no: A2025-115445


In the matter between:

KHOZA HLULANI OBEDIENCE APPELLANT

and

ROAD ACCIDENT FUND RESPONDENT

Coram: Ratshibvumo DJP, Nobanda -Mooti et Mangena AJJ
Heard: 21 August 2026
Delivered: 02 November 2026
Summary: Appeal—Rule 38(2) of the Uniform Rules of Court —Failure to properly
adduce evidence on affidavit — Court could not make a determination— Uniform Rule
33.

2


ORDER



On appeal from: The Mpumalanga Division of the High Court, Mbombela, per Zakwe
AJ (Sitting as a court of first instance)
1. The Appeal is upheld.
2. The order of the court a quo is set aside, and the matter is remitted for trial de
novo before another judge.
3. There shall be no order as to costs.



JUDGMENT



Mangena AJ (Ratshibvumo DJP & Nobanda AJ concurring).

Introduction.
[1] The appellant appeals against a judgment and order granted by the trial court on
05 May 2025 dismissing his claim for delictual damages arising out of a motor vehicle
accident. Leave to appeal was granted by the trial court on 13 June 2025. The notice of
appeal was filed two days late, and a condonation application was filed for the late filing.
The attorney explained that he made a mistake in computing the days, calculating from
the date of the court stamp on the court order instead of the actual date the appeal was

3

granted. It appears to us to be a genuine error, and the delay is not inordinate. The
prospects of success are also good, and condonation is granted.


Background.
[2] The appeal arises from the following background facts. The appellant was
knocked down by a motor vehicle with registration letters KMH[…], driven by the
insured driver, Mr Zwelithini. The insured driver, according to him, deviated from his
path of travel to avoid a collision with an oncoming motor vehicle. He then knocked
down the appellant in the middle of the road, who, at the time, was a pedestrian.

[3] The appellant was later taken to hospital for treatment and was admitted for some
considerable time. He subsequently lodged a claim against the Road Accident Fund (“the
RAF”) for payment of damages suffered from the alleged negligence of the insured
driver.

[4] When the claim was not settled within the prescribed timeframe, he instituted
action proceedings setting out the facts in his particulars of claim upon which he alleged
that the insured driver was negligent and that his negligence caused him the damages he
suffered.

[5] The RAF defended the claim and denied liability on the basis that the insured
driver was not negligent; alternatively, and if it is found that he was negligent (which is
denied), that such negligence did not cause the accident or that he contributed to it.

[6] From the foregoing, it is clear that the RAF squarely placed liability in dispute,
and in particular that the insured driver was the cause of the accident through his

4

negligence. This became more pronounced during the pre- trial hearing where it recorded
its position in the minutes as follows: -
“It is the Defendant’s contention that the Plaintiff contributed to the occurrence of the
accident and the extent thereof will be decided by the Court. It further indicated that it
would like to cross-examine Plaintiff and any of his witnesses(s).”

[7] The matter came up for trial on 04 November 2024, and upon enquiry by the Court
into its status, the Presiding Judge was briefly informed by the legal representatives that
they had agreed to proceed on paper, and that heads of argument would be filed
according to the agreed timelines.

[8] As is evident, no application was made to adduce evidence by way of affidavit, as
provided for in Rule 38(2) of the Uniform Rules of Court (“the Uniform Rules”). For the
avoidance of doubt, we consider it necessary to quote in full the interaction between the
Court and the legal representatives of the parties. The exchange is short and reproduced
here as it appears in the transcribed record

8.1 Court proceedings held on 04 November 2024 at Mbombela High Court—
“Registrar: Matter number 3 case number 795/2024, Khoza Hlulani
Obedience versus RAF.
Plaintiff’s Counsel: May it please you my Lord I confirm appearance on behalf of the
Plaintiff.
Defendant’s Counsel: May it please you my Lord, I appear for the
Defendant.
Court: Thank you, what is the position with regards to this matter?

5

Plaintiff’s Counsel: My Lord, we are ready to proceed; only damages
is currently in dispute. However, there is an agreement between
the Plaintiff and Defendant to proceed on paper, My Lord.
Court: Okay, Defendant’s Counsel.
Defendant’s Counsel: As the court pleases, My Lord. My Lord, I do admit that we are
ready to proceed, and the matter is going to proceed on paper.
Court: Okay, alright, the matter will stand down for a few minutes,
then.
Plaintiff’s Counsel: As the Court pleases.
Defendant’s Counsel: As the Court pleases.

Court adjourns

Registrar: Recalling matter number 3, case number 795/2024 Khoza
Hlulani Obedience versus RAF.
Plaintiff’s Counsel: May it please you, My Lord, I am for the Plaintiff.
Court: Alright, is Defendant’s Counsel back online as well?
Plaintiff’s counsel: I do believe she is online, My Lord.
Defendant's counsel: I am here, my Lord.
Court: Okay, I have just quickly checked the file, and I noticed that
there are no heads of argument. I am going to need heads in
respect of this matter. I can make arrangements as to when the
Plaintiff can file, and the Defendant can respond.
Plaintiff’s counsel: As the court pleases, My Lord, the Plaintiff can file by the 13th of
November, My Lord.
Court: Defendant’s counsel.

6


Defendant’s counsel: My Lord, I can file my heads by the 15 th of November, My Lord.

Court: Alright, the court will make the following order.

Order

Court: The matter stands down, and the plaintiff is ordered to file the
heads on or before the 13th November 2024, and the Defendant is
ordered to file the heads on or before 15 November 2024.”

[9] Consequent to the order above, the trial court delivered its judgment and order on
05 May 2025 as alluded to above. In the judgment, the trial court identified the issues for
determination as follows:
“[47.1] Whether the Plaintiff succeeded to prove on a balance of probabilities that the
insured driver negligently or wrongfully caused the accident.

[47.2] And whether, as a result of the accident, the Plaintiff sustained injuries which
entitle him to claim for damages.”

[10] After traversing the provisions of Section 17(1) of the Road Accident Fund Act,
1996, the Court established that the Plaintiff bore the onus to prove on a balance of
probabilities that the insured driver drove the vehicle “wrongfully or negligently”. It then
proceeded to “evaluate the facts” to determine whether the Plaintiff proved, on a balance
of probabilities, that the injuries he sustained in the accident were caused by the insured
driver's wrongful or negligent driving.

7

[11] As part of its “evaluation”, the trial court considered, amongst others, the Section
19 (f)(i)-(ii) affidavit and statements made by the insured driver to the police, as well as
the statement of another passenger in the insured vehicle who explained how the accident
happened. It also considered what the appellant told the experts during his consultation to
quantify his damages. The Plaintiff reportedly stated that he does not know how the
accident happened as he lost consciousness and regained it later while in hospital. This
factor apparently weighed heavily with the trial judge. We say so because the court said
in the body of the judgment, “there is no evidence to gainsay the evidence of the insured
driver and his witness. No effort was made by the Plaintiff to do so, probably because he
does not know what happened.” It proceeded to say that “on the evidence of the insured
driver and his witness, it cannot be found that the insured driver acted negligently and it
appears that he might have been faced with what the defendant described as a sudden
emergency”.

[12] Based on the above, the trial judge concluded that the RAF could not be held
liable for compensation and dismissed the claim with costs.


The appeal.
[13] The appellant is aggrieved by the order and attacks it on various grounds,
including that the learned judge misapplied the law governing the admission of evidence
by affidavit. It is submitted on his behalf that the trite principle of our law is that parties
are bound by their pleadings. Factual allegations contained in the pleadings stand
unchallenged where parties have agreed to place evidence by way of an affidavit. In

8

support of this contention, we were referred to Esorfranki Pipelines (Pty) Ltd v Mopani
District Municipality1 where Goosen AJA (as he then was) said the following:
“There is no procedural impediment to the reception of evidence, by a trial court, by way of
affidavit. If the parties agree that facts may be placed before a court by way of affidavit and
agree that the deponent will not be cross- examined, then the factual allegations contained in the
affidavit stand unchallenged. Where that occurs, no dispute of fact arises.”

Rule 38 (2) procedure

[14] As a matter of law, Goosen AJA is correct. The position he expressed above is an
articulation of the provisions of Rule 38(2) of the Uniform Rules which reads as follows:
-
“(2) The witnesses at the trial of any action shall be orally examined, but a court may at any time,
for sufficient reason, order that all or any of the evidence to be adduced at any trial be given on
affidavit or that the affidavit of any witness be read at the hearing, on such terms and conditions
as to it may seem meet: Provided that where it appears to the court that any other party
reasonably requires the attendance of a witness for cross- examination, and such witness can be
produced, the evidence of such witness shall not be given on affidavit.”

[15] In Bafokeng Land Buyers Association and Others v Royal Bafokeng Nation and
Others 2 , the full court of that Division provided the following guideline regarding
presentation of evidence in trial proceedings. It said:
“[62] The general rule in trials is that evidence should be given viva voce. This not only
enables the court to assess the witness giving the evidence, but, more importantly, it also affords
the party that has not called the witness the opportunity to cross- examine the witness, both to test

1 Esorfranki Pipelines (Pty) Ltd v Mopani District Municipality, 2022 (2) SA 355 (SCA) at para 27.
2 Bafokeng Land Buyers Association and Others v Royal Bafokeng Nation and Others , 2018(5) SA 566 (NWM) at

para 62.

9

the evidence that the witness has given and, equally importantly, the opportunity to elicit
evidence from the witness which supports the cross-examiner's case.

[63] Rule 38(2) contains an exception to this general rule. An applicant who seeks to invoke
the exception must prove that 'sufficient reason' exists to do so. While this requirement confers a
broad discretion on a court, in determining whether sufficient reason exists a court must bear in
mind the disadvantages above of permitting this to both the court and the other side, and then
consider whether the interests of justice nonetheless requires that the evidence be admitted on
affidavit. The rule also contains an express proviso limiting the court's discretion, namely that,
where it appears to the court that a party reasonably requires the attendance of the witness for
cross-examination, and the witness can be produced, then the evidence of the witness shall not be
given on affidavit.

[64] The determination of 'sufficient reason' necessarily involves the exercise of a discretion,
which discretion has to be exercised judicially, having regard to the options available to the court.
A court on appeal may interfere with the exercise of discretion only if there has been a wrong
application of legal principle or a misdirection of fact. The court on appeal does not have the
power to substitute its own discretion on the basis that it would have exercised the discretion
differently.”3

[16] We align ourselves with the position set out in the above cases, including the
paragraph relied upon by the appellant in Esorfranki (supra).

[17] With the above said, however, we do not believe the appellant’s reliance on
Esorfranki is well placed. We say so because, in this matter, the parties did not agree to
place facts before the court by way of affidavit, and the deponents (if any) will not be
examined. In addition, no application was made to the presiding judge to adduce

examined. In addition, no application was made to the presiding judge to adduce
evidence by affidavit. In our view, the learned judge did not have an opportunity to
exercise his discretion to determine whether there was “sufficient reason” to depart from
the general rule governing how evidence is presented or adduced in trial proceedings.

3 Footnotes omitted. See also Madibeng Local Municipality vs Public Investment Corporation, 2008 (6) SA
55(SCA) at para 26.

10


[18] In the absence of a formal application detailing facts and circumstances warranting a
deviation from the general rule, there was, in our view, no evidence placed before the
court for evaluation in order to determine a factual dispute relating to liability. This is
significant because it is a procedural issue. It reaffirms the position in our law that certain
matters can be adjudicated through motion proceedings, and others only through action
proceedings. Harms DP puts it better in Cadac (Pty) Ltd vs Weber – Stephen Products
Company&Others4, wherein he says:
“Motion proceedings are not geared to deal with factual disputes — they are principally for the
resolution of legal issues — and illiquid claims by their very nature involve the resolution of
factual issues.”

[19] In Summermania Eleven (Pty) Ltd v Hattingh N.O,5 it was held that:-
“In trial proceedings parties discharge the onus on them by giving oral evidence. The words ‘shall
be orally examined’ in rule 38(2) affirm this as the standard procedure. Reliability and credibility
of the evidence given is then assessed and analysed through cross- examination. The trial court,
however, has a discretion under the rule, to receive evidence given by way of affidavit…”

[20] We conclude on this aspect of the procedure for adducing evidence on disputed facts
in unliquidated damages claims by quoting what the Supreme Court of Appeal said in
Economic Freedom Fighters and Others v Manuel,6 where it said:
“[92] …An unliquidated claim for damages must be pursued by institution of an action…


4 Cadac (Pty) Ltd v Weber – Stephen Products Company & Others, 2011 (3) SA 570 (SCA) at para 10.
5 Summermania Eleven (Pty) Ltd v Hattingh NO, (316/2022) [2024] ZASCA 42 at para 16.
6 Economic Freedom Fighters and Others v Manuel 2021 (3) SA 425 (SCA) at paras 92-101. see also MMK obo MK
v RAF (497/2024) [2025] ZASCA 136 (25 September 2025) paras 15-16

11

[93] This is not mere technicality. Claims for unliquidated damages by their very nature
involve a determination by the court of an amount that is just and reasonable in the light of a
number of imponderable and incommensurable factors. That exercise cannot be undertaken in
proceedings by way of application. As Harms DP said in Cadac:

‘(M)otion proceedings are not geared to deal with factual disputes — they are principally for the
resolution of legal issues — and illiquid claims by their very nature involve the resolution of
factual issues.’

…

[101] In essence, the court held that in cases where damages are claimed in delict one would, in
the normal course, require evidence in relation to the damages allegedly sustained. In motor
collision cases, of course, questions arise concerning negligence, contributory negligence and,
where applicable, the apportionment of damages, in relation to all of which oral evidence is
required.” (Emphasis added)

[21] As we pointed out above, the RAF placed liability at the centre of the dispute, and
the trial court correctly identified it as an issue for determination. It is indisputable that in
delictual claims, Plaintiff is required to prove causation as one of the five elements of a
delict. It is also trite that causation is a factual dispute which cannot be resolved on paper,
as the Supreme Court of Appeal so aptly tells us. Indeed, law reports are replete with
warnings to both legal practitioners and presiding officers that where the cause of action
is delictual, damages can in most cases only be determined after evidence has been led in
relation to the cause of action.7


7 See Esofranki supra at paras 101 to 102.

12


Conclusion.

[22] In our view, the trial court erred on a procedural point regulating the admission of
evidence and, in particular, the management of the proceedings. It went off on a tangent
and found itself in a labyrinth of paper purporting to be evidence when it was not. It was
therefore unsurprising to us that the trial judge remarked that he was in the dark as to how
the accident happened. We also do not know, as no facts were placed before the court as
evidence.

[23] As there was no evidence placed before the court, it follows ineluctably that the
findings made regarding liability and onus cannot be allowed to stand. They were not
founded on the established facts. The appeal should succeed. The appellant urged us to
substitute the order and find that negligence was proved. We cannot do so in the absence
of evidence establishing the proven facts. We will be committing the same error as the
trial court. We believe the correct approach is to remit the matter to the trial court. In this
regard, we are guided by the Supreme Court of Appeal in Minister of Police v Mboweni
and Another.8

Costs
[24] Both parties contributed to the state of affairs, and neither should benefit from the
ineptitude displayed here. They should have known there was a genuine dispute of fact
relating to causation and alerted the court accordingly. Additionally, they should have
formally brought an application in full compliance with Rule 38(2) of the Uniform Rules,

8 2014 (6) SA 256 (SCA).

13

as mentioned above, or, better still, approached the court with a stated case in terms of
Rule 33.9 There should be no order as to costs.

[25] In the result, it is ordered that:
1. The appeal is upheld.
2. The order of the court a quo is set aside, and the matter is remitted for trial de
novo before another judge.
3. There shall be no order as to costs.


____________________
MI MANGENA
ACTING JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

I agree.

____________________
PL NOBANDA-MOOTI
ACTING JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT


I agree, and it is so ordered.
____________________

9 LMP v NJDP [2025] ZALMPPHC 122 at para 18, in which the court referred to Minister of Police v Mboweni and
Another (supra) at para 8. In it the court stated , “It is clear therefore that a special case must set out agreed facts, not
assumptions. The point was re -emphasised in Bane and Others v D'Ambrosi , where it was said that deciding such a
case on assumptions as to the facts defeats the purpose of the rule, which is to enable a case to be determined
without the necessity of hearing all, or at least a major part, of the evidence…”

14

TV RATSHIBVUMO
DEPUTY JUDGE PRESIDENT

Appearances
For the Appellant: Adv K Toma
Johannesburg Society of Advocates
Tel: 011 282 3700 Cell: 073 0100 750
Email: kumbi.toma@rsabar.co.za
Instructed By: PN Hlatshwayo Attorneys
Nelspruit
Tel: 013 752 3647 Cell: 082 420 8424
Email: plato.nhlamulo@gmail.com


For the Respondents: Adv V Mukwevho
Johannesburg Society of Advocates
Email: mukwevho@rsabar.com
Instructed By: State Attorney Gugu Mokoena
Email address: gugum1@raf.co.za
Cell: 066 308 9159
Tel: 013 101 3722
Nelspruit
3rd floor admin block,
R104 Samora Machel Drive