REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(LIMPOPO DIVISION, POLOKWANE)
(1) REPORTABLE: YES
(2) OF INTERES..T:. TOT E JUDGES: YES@
CASE NO: 2464/2023
(3) REVISE~JNO
Naude - Od fl~
In the matter between:
EMMANUEL ASSEMBLES NPO
REG NO: 219-941
and
R.M. MABITSELA
M.A. SEALE
NAUDE-ODENDAAL J:
\
JUDGMENT
APPLICANT
1st RESPONDENT
2nd RESPONDENT
[1] The Applicant instituted an application in terms whereof the applicant applied for
condonation for the late filing of the replying affidavit and in the Notice of Motion in
the main for a declaratory order to be issued that the National Executive Council of
2
the Applicant, as elected at the September 2019 conference, and again as
confirmed on 23 March 2022, be declared to be the valid, legal and only National
Executive Council of the Applicant. Further, that the Respondents be interdicted
from engaging in the affairs of the Applicant and/or its National Executive Council,
and not to disrupt any conference meetings, church services or any affqirs, of the
National Executive Council or the Applicant. The Applicant also ,,c;Jpplied that the
Respondents be interdicted from inciting any person, faction or organization to
engaging in the affairs of the Applicant and/or its National Executive Council, and not
to disrupt any conference meetings, church services or any affairs of the National
Executive Council of the Applicant. The Applicant further applied that the
Respondents be interdicted and ordered,, fo return possession of the conference
center and offices and/or premises of the' National Executive Council immediately,
and to refrain from occupying, -0r cau~ing any person, faction or organization to
occupy the conference center and offices and/or premises of the National Executive
Council of the Applicant.
[2] The Applicartt submitted that the National Executive Council of the Applicant has
been nominated and elected according to the constitution of the Applicant. The 1st
Respondeht was a founding member of the Applicant, but he retired many years
ago. The 2nd Respondent was also a founding member of the Applicant but retired
in the year 2013.
[3] The Applicant submitted that the drama and reasons for the present application
started at the Applicant's annual general conference on 24 September 2019. During
3
the conference the members that attended were informed that the Applicant had
been registered as a non-profit organization and such a decision was taken by the
executive council of the Applicant. The house was divided on the matter and diverse
views were expressed. It was then agreed that the executive council would have a
meeting with the concerned elders over the registration of the Applicant as a non
profit organization.
[4] After the conference, a meeting was held on 5 February 2.020. This meeting was
attended by the 1st and 2nd Respondents and their dissdtisfaction as to the
registration of the Applicant as a non-profit organizc1.tion ,was discussed. After this
·'
meeting, the Covid-19 pandemic broke oµt and the ·first meeting that could then be
/
held again was on 23 March 2022.
[5] It was submitted by the Applicant that both the 1st and 2nd Respondents were
present at the 23 ,March 2022 meeting. They once again reiterated their
'-
unhappiness about the fact that the Applicant had now been registered as a Non-
Profit Organization. The National Executive then highlighted to both the ..
Respondents that the Non-Profit Organization (NPO) was a necessary consequence
of moving forward, and that they were all willing to meet with the Respondents to try
and r~solve any concerns that they might have had.
[6] The Applicant submitted that they secured the services of a person in Pretoria who
agreed to assist in trying to explain to the Respondents what the organization as an
NPO was about, but since there was still some restrictions in place as a result of the
4
Covid-19 Regulations, this had to be done on a virtual platform which was declined
by both Respondents. The meeting then took a turn for the worst where the 1st
Respondent for instance accused one of the Applicant's co-pastors of being a liar,
and the entire meeting was thrown into chaos as a result of the actions of the two
Respondents.
' [7] It was further submitted that it appears from the minutes of the 'meeting that
especially the 2nd Respondent had some misinformation tllat apparently churches
that were registered as NPO's would be compelled to conduct gay marriages, and
that since he was a founding member of the Appliq.mt, this did not carry his
approval. The two Respondents further raised the issue that the National Executive
took the decision to register the Applicant as ,a NPO by themselves, and that this
was not approved by the whole ,assembly and congregation as such. The Applicant
however agrees with the Respondents on this point, as the decision was taken by
the National Executiv.e Council to register the Applicant as a NPO.
[8] It was submitted by the Applicant that they did not need the approval of the whole
congreg~tion or even a majority vote, as this decision to register the Applicant as a
NPO was part and parcel of the everyday functioning and required functions of the
National Executive.
[9] Further mediation was then embarked on by the Applicant and both the
Respondents. After this further meeting, the Respondents then wrote
correspondence to the Applicant which created division in the church between the
5
Applicant and the group that was formed by the Respondents. The Respondents
then started referring to themselves as "the Remnant Founders". The Respondents
then started to approach more and more members of the congregation to convince
them to now become part of the associa.tion that they had erected that was known
as the Remnant Founders. The Applicant attempted for several months to resolve
the issues with the Respondents in a peaceful manner, but without any success.
[1 O] On the 1 ylh of October 2022 the Respondents wrote a further letter which was
distributed to the members of the congregation of the Applicant'inviting the members
to a special annual general conference meeting that was scheduled for 5 November
2022. The letter initiated the takeover of Jhe Applicant. The two Respondents now
seemed set in their way to take over the' church of the Applicant despite the two
Respondents being retired and the fact that they do not form part of the national
executive of the Applicant or serve on any committee as such.
,.
[11] The Applicant suomitted that the Respondents therefore had absolutely no authority
to call any meeting on behalf of the Applicant or in the name of the Applicant or
involving the congregation or executive of the Applicant as such, and their conduct is
1;1ot onJy against the constitution of the Applicant, but also disruptive as far as the
unity of the congregation is concerned. A lot of the pastors during this time also
,started complaining that they are being threatened by the Respondents who were
intent on sowing division and trying to create their own movement as a form of
rejection of the Applicant.
6
[12] On the 5th of November 2022 a letter was received from the Respondents, as
assumed. This letter was bearing the name of the Applicant, being Emmanuel
Assemblies (Bushbuckridge), and was addressed to Emmanuel Assemblies National
Office with the Applicant's NPO Registration Number in brackets thereafter. The
Respondents had now resorted to act as another organization and inst(ucted the
executive committee of the Applicant to dissolve immediately anc:i/ to refrain /from
/ ,,
engaging with Emmanuel Assemblies members in any way. The Respondents also
emphasized that an interim committee was elected 'and that a motion of
disbandment was based on an attached 15 point document. This letter in essence
divided the Applicant with definitive action by the R,.espondents.
[13] The Applicant further submitted that a further letter was received, dated the 22nd of
November 2022, which was now apparently sent by the Emmanuel Assemblies
Highveld District, but which had the same logo as that of the Remnant Founders that
was initially distribut,ed by -thei Respondents. In this letter the congregation was
;
notified of the disbandment of the executive committee and invited to the
establishment of the interim district council. It is submitted by the Applicant that from
the contents of this letter it is clear that the whole purpose of the letter was to take
/
over control of the Applicant, which the Respondents and their faction ultimately did.
[14] The Applicant submitted that this new council that had now been formed, was never
elected by any annual general conference, nor nominated as required by the
Applicant's constitution. The Applicant was then deprived of the church, physically
7
and with force, and the offices of the national executive occupied by the faction
started, was managed and controlled by the Respondents.
[15] The Respondents effectively after this letter of 22 November 2022, took control of all
institutions relating to the national executive, and the conference center and the
offices were occupied and taken by the Respondents and the faction who changed
the locks to the offices, effectively preventing the Applicant's executive council from
conducting their duties in the interest of the Applicant.
[16] The Respondents further went on a number of occasions from church to church to
propagate the fact that the national executive of the Applicant were no longer
functioning and had been disbanded by the. faction of the Respondents. This
created a lot of concern, confusitfn ~od divi~ion in the congregation, and delegated
the national executive to bring thi.s application.
[17] In opposition the Respondents raised three points in limine, being that the deponent
of the found(ng affidavit lacks the necessary authority and has no locus standi to
institute the application on behalf of the Applicant, secondly that the attorneys of
/
record lacks the necessary authority to act on behalf of the Applicant and thirdly, the
reguirements of an interdict has not been met.
[18] The first two points in limine are without any merit. The Applicant attached
confirmatory affidavits to its replying affidavit after the first point in limine was raised
by the Respondents. It is clear that the whole of the executive took the decision to
8
bring this application. In respect of the second point in limine, the Respondents did
not utilize Rule 7(1) of the Uniform Rules of Court as required by law. The
Respondents, if they wanted to dispute the attorney's power to act, had to invoke the
provisions of Rule 7(1 ), which they did not do. Absent a Rule 7 challenge, this point
in limine fails.
[19] In the matter of Eskom v Soweto City Council 1992 (2) SA 703 .(W) the following
was held:-
"The care displayed in the past about proof of authority was ra,tlonal. It was inspired
by the fear that a person may deny that he wasparty to litigation carried on in his
name. His signature to the process, or when that does not eventuate, formal proof
of authority would avoid undue risk to the opposite party, to the administration of
justice and sometimes even to his own ;;ittorney. (Compare Viljoen v Federated Trust
Ltd 1971 (1) SA 750 (0) at 752D-F and the authorities there quoted.)
The developed view, adopted in Court Rule 7(1), is that the risk is adequately
managed on a different level. If the attorney is authorized to bring the application on
behalf of the applicant, the application necessarily is that of the applicant. There is
no need that any other person, whether he be a witness or someone who becomes
involved especially in the context of authority, should additionally be authorized. It is
• therefore sufficient to know whether or not the attorney acts with authority.
As to when and how the attorney's authority should be proved, the Rule-maker mad
a policy decision. Perhaps because the risk is minimal that an attorney will act for a
person without authority to do so, proof is dispensed with except only if the other
party challenges the authority. See Rule 7(1). Courts should honour that approach.
9
Properly applied, that should lead to the elimination of the many pages of
resolutions, delegations and substitutions still attached to applications by some
litigants, especially certain financial institutions."
[20] In MEC for Department of Health North West v Shashape and Another
(11 05/2016) [2026] ZANWHC 215 (19 August 2026) the following was stated:-
"The manner of challenging such authority had been decided in Eskom v Soweto
City Council 1992 (2) SA 703(W) at 705C-J and confirmed by the Supreme Court of
Appeal in Ganes and Another v Telecom Namibia Ltd 2004 (3) SA 615 (SCA},
wherein it sets out how that challenge must be raised. Uniform Rule 7(1) allows a
respondent who disputes authority to give notice within ten days of becoming aware
of the apparent lack of such authority to require proof of authority. This issue is aptly
dealt with by Petersen J in the judgment of this Division in Mahikeng Local
Municipality v Clayton Virgil Harrison [2021] ZANWHC 87 para 19. as follows:
'In this Division the legal position is clear. Any challenge to the authority of a
Municipal Manager to launch an application on behalf of a municipality must be
brought by way of Rule 7(1). The respondent has not challenged the authority of the
Municipal Manger by way of Rule 7(1) and the point in limine on locus standi must
accordingly fail.'
[15] No Rule 7(1) notice was delivered by the first respondent. The point is raised
only in the answering affidavit. Absent a Rule 7 challenge, this point in limine fails."
[41] The last point in Jimine in respect of the requirements for an interdict deals with the
;merits of the application and will be dealt with together with the merits.
[22] In respect of the merits, the 2nd Respondent submitted that he, as one of the
founding members of the church, established the church in or around 1977. After
many people were converted, more branches were opened in various regions across
the spectrum of the Republic. During 1978 the church was formally registered in
Pretoria under the name and style Emmanuel Assemblies.
[23] The 2nd Respondent submitted that as per the church's norms and standc:1rds, they
held elections of the National Executive Members after every two )lears to occupy
'".i
the office for the smooth running of the church. In these elections, office bearers
were elected to act as Chairperson, Secretary, Trea,stlrer, their deputies and
additional members. Once the elected members assume offick, they are expected
to obey and to follow the Constitution of the Emmanuel Assemblies, as they execute
their mandate with care and diligence.
[24] It was submitted that the Cpnstitution and General Rules of the Emmanuel
Assemblies, Article VIII, page 4, provides that "the governing body of the Emmanuel
Assemblies shall be }he General Conference constituted according to the General
,_
Rules of the Emmanuel Assemblies, with the Executive Council as its instrument of ' •
authority and administration". In other words, the National Executive Council takes
"
and implements the mandate of the General Conference.
[25] The Hespondents submitted that this Executive Council was properly elected on or
jaround 2019 and were disbanded due to inter alia financial mismanagement and
other misconducts.
11
[26] According to the Respondents, the Executive Council have behaved in an
unacceptable manner which caused the division of the Church, and their demeanor
of approaching this Court for an interdict, shows that they are not remorseful. The
Executive Council has acted in a manner which is unbecoming.
[27] It was further submitted by the Respondents that the Executive Council has hijacked
; , '~
the church by registering it as a NPO without approval of the Annual General
Conference. They have further refused to disclose the registration certificate despite
several requests. It was further submitted that the-Executivd Council went on to
print the Pastors credential cards with the Applic~nt's NPO number 219-941 without
'
the approval of the Annual General Conference.
+ ''
[28] The Respondents further submitted that the Executive Council went on to change
the name Emmanuel Assemqhes (Bushbuckridge) on the letter heads to Emmanuel
Assemblies International and alte'rnatively Emmanuel Assemblies National Office.
[29] The Respondents further submitted that the Executive Council has shown the lack of
proper financial management and accounting. In terms of the Executive Council's
financial report dated 23 March 2022 for the period of 1 October 2020 to 28
February 2022, a deficit of R735 096.41 is reflected.
[30] The Respondents submitted that a General Conference was held on 4 October 2022
with the view to discuss matters concerning the running of the Church. A consensus
could not be reached on the day and an indulgence of 30 days was then given to the
12
Executive Committee before formal disbandment. On the 5th of November 2022, the
Executive Committee was not in attendance, they were then disbanded and an
Interim Committee comprising of nine members was elected.
[31] According to the Respondents, the fact that they retired is of no consequ~nce, they
remain the founding members of the Emmanuel Assemblies (Bushb1..Jckridge~.
[32] To obtain a final interdict, the Applicant must prove all three of .the following
requirements on a balance of probabilities:-
32.1 A Clear Right;
32.2 An Actual or Reasonably Apprehended Injury;
32.3 The Absence of a Satisfactory Alternative Remedy.
[33] In this court's view, e Respondents managed to prove all the requirements on a
balance of probabilities to obtain a final interdict. The Respondents acted without
authority and took the law in their own hands when they hijacked the Applicant. The
Respondents are disgruntled as to how the Applicant has evolved over the years
since 1978 when they founded the Applicant and now wants to take over control and
run and control the Applicant as they believe it should be relying on the mere fact
Jhat they were the initial founders of the church. This can never be. The
Respondents have resigned and are no longer serving on the Executive.
13
[34] The only issue remaining is the question of costs. The Applicant applied for costs on
an attorney and client scale. In this court's view attorney and client costs are not
justified, however considering the language used in the Answering Affidavit and the
slandering remarks made without a single shred of proof, a punitive cost order is
indeed justified. In my view, costs on Scale C of Uniform Rule 67A read with ,uniform
Rule 69, in the circumstances are justified.
[35] In the result, the following order is made:-
35.1 Condonation for the late filing of the Replying Affidavit is,granted.
35.2 It is declared and a declaratory order is issµed that the National Executive
Council of the Applicant, as elected at the September 2019 conference, and
again as confirmed on 23 March 2022, is the valid, legal and only National
Executive Council of the Applicant.
35.3 The Respondents are interdicted from engaging in the affairs of the Applicant
and/or its National Executive Council, and not to disrupt any conference
meetings, church services or any affairs of the National Executive Council or
the Applicant.
35.4 The Respondents are interdicted from inciting any person, faction or
organisation to engaging in the affairs of the Applicant and/or its National
Executive Council, and not to disrupt any conference meetings, church
services or any affairs of the National Executive Council or the Applicant.
14
35.5 The Respondents are interdicted and ordered to return possession of the
conference centre and offices and/or premises of the National Executive
Council immediately, and to refrain from occupying or causing any person,
faction or organization to so occupy the conference centre and offices and/or
premises of the National Executive Council of the Applicant.
35.6 The Respondents are ordered to pay the Applicant's costs, which costs are to
be taxed and paid on Scale C, jointly and severally, the one to pay, the other
to be absolved.
E HIGH COURT,
LIMPOPO DIVISION,
POLOKWANE
APPEARANCES:
DATE OF HEARING:
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
For the Applicant:
Instructed by:
15
12 AUGUST 2026
3 NOVEMBER 2026
Adv. J. De Necker
EE Sethole Attorneys
C/O Calvin Mnisi Attorneys
78 Schoeman Street, Polokwane,
info@cmnnisiattorneys .co.·za
erwinsethole27@gmaiJ.com
For the 1st and 2nd Respondents: Mr. KN Maleka
Instructed by: K~ Maleka Attorneys Inc.
9 Camel Thorn Street, Polokwane
~. admin@knmattorneys.co.za
~