Nkwinika v Peppadew International (Pty) Ltd (971/2025) [2026] ZALMPPHC 108 (3 November 2026)

62 Reportability

Brief Summary

Delict — Occupational injury — Claim for damages arising from chemical exposure at workplace — Applicant injured by chemical sprayed by co-worker during employment — Respondent raising exception based on Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act (COIDA) — Court finding that injuries sustained did not arise out of Applicant's employment duties — Exception upheld, claim dismissed.

(1)
(2)
(3)
REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(LIMPOPO DIVISION, POLOKWANE)
REPORTABLE: YES
OF INTEREs:r,TO THE JUDGES: YES 0
REVISED YES/NO <:..:.:.;;;_;>
In the matter between:
CECILIA NKWINIKA
and
PEPPADEW INTERNATIONAL (PTY) LTD
JUDGMENT
NAUDE-ODENDAAL J:
CASE NO: 971/2025
APPLICANT
RESPONDENT
[1] The Applicant instituted an action against the Respondent in terms whereof the
Applicant claims damages arising from an accident that occurred at her place of
employment.

2
[2] The parties are referred to as per the heading of the documents filed of record. The
Applicant is the Plaintiff in the action and the Respondent is the Defendant in the
action. The correct citing would have however been that the Defendant, who raised
the exception be referred to as the Applicant in this application and the Plaintiff as
the Respondent. However, to maintain harmony with the record, I will r~fer to the
parties as per the heading of the documents.
[3] The Applicant pleaded that on the 23rd of April 2023, during normal business hours,
the Plaintiff was rightfully on the premises. The f\pplicant was employed by the
Respondent as a cleaner and she was at..work r percforming her duties. The
Respondent's employee by the name of Senyolo, sprayed the Applicant with a
chemical onto her face using a backpack sprayer. The backpack spray was owned
and/or operated on behalf of the f3e.spondent. Senyolo was an employee of the
Respondent and acting within the course and scope of his employment with the
Respondent.
[4] The Applicant further, pleaded that as a result of being sprayed on her face with the
chemical, her eyes suffered severe injuries as she experienced excruciating pain
that her vision vanished and she could not see anything as everything was dark.
The injury to the Applicant's eyes was caused by the wrongful and negligent failure
of the Respondent, or its employees or servants or agents acting within the course
and scope of their employment, to perform their duty to take reasonable steps to
maintain reasonable safety conditions for the Applicant on the premises, further
alternatively in one or more of the following respects below:-

3
4.1 They failed to keep a proper lookout;
4.2 They used the backpack spray negligently without due regard to other
employees within the premises;
4.3 They failed to take cognizance of the fact that other employees may be
present in the premises, and in particular the presence of the Applicant;
4.4 They operated the backpack spray without having the required skill,
knowledge or certification;
4.5 They failed to take adequate steps to prevent the chemical from spraying the
Applicant on her face, when they could and s~ould have done so;
4.6 They failed to avoid injury to the Applicant, wheri by the exercise of proper
care they should have done so.
[5] The Applicant further pleaded t,hat the Respondent could and should have foreseen
that a person in the position of the Applicant could be injured in the circumstances.
The Respondent could and should have taken reasonable steps to guard against
such occurrence. Further, the Respondent failed to take the necessary steps.
[6] The Applicant pleaded, further, that as a result of being sprayed with the chemical
on the face, she sustained the following injuries:-
6.1 • Conjunitins;
6.2 Facial skin change;
6.3 Swelling and unable to count fingers with the right eye;
6.4 Chemical burn to the eyes; and
6.5 Psychological trauma and depression.

4
[7] As a result of the injuries sustained by the Applicant and the sequelae thereof, the
Applicant received medical and hospital treatment and incurred expenses in
connection therewith, will in future undergo medical and hospital treatment and incur
future medical costs in connection therewith, suffered loss of amenities Qf life and
will in future continue to suffer such loss, suffered loss of earning,s' and/or earning
capacity and will in future continue to suffer such loss, experienced pain; suffering
and discomfort and will in future continue to experience same and sustained
emotional shock and trauma and will in future contin!,Je to experience same.
[8] The Applicant pleaded in paragraph 9 of the ParticuJars of Claim that the nature and
extent of the injuries and the effect and duration of the Applicant's disabilities will be
further address in the hospital records from Letaba and Mankweng Hospitals
respectively and medico-legal reports filed in due course in terms of the rules of
court.
[9] As a result of the injuries and their consequences the Applicant suffered damages in
the amount of R1710 000.00 (One Million Seven Hundred and Ten Thousand Rand)
'
as pleaded)and set out in paragraph 10 of the particulars of claim.
[1 O] ,vhe Applicant further pleaded that the amount claimed for past medical and hospital
expenses represents the total amount of the accounts received by the Applicant for
medical treatment and hospital expenses after the incident to date, which will be

5
supplemented with the costs of the Applicant's ongoing treatment in due course. A
further schedule of medical expenses will be prepared in due course.
[11] It was further pleaded by the Applicant that the amount claimed for future medical
and hospital expenses is for the further treatment of the Applicant's injuries, namely:-
11.1 Surgery and reconstructive surgery;
11.2 Conservative treatment;
11.3 Ophthalmologist;
11.4 Optometric therapy and eye glasses.
11.5 Neuropsychological and clinical psychological consultations;
11.6 Further treatment, as will be furth~r .addressed in medico-legal reports to be
filed in due course in terms of the rules of Court.
[12] The Applicant pleaded further, that the amount claimed for past loss of earnings is
an estimate of the amount that the Applicant would have earned to date but was
unable to earn d1:1e to the injuries and the seque/ae thereof and the amount for future
loss of earnings/earning capacity is an estimate based on the fact that the Applicant
will not be able to work as well as she did prior to the incident and that she is less
likely to find employment or gain promotion after the incident. She will also have to
take time off work in order to obtain medical treatment for the injuries and the
,sequelae thereof. Alternatively, the amount is a globular amount based on the fact
that the Applicant is unable to attain her pre-incident earning capacity as a result of
the injuries she sustained.

6
[13] Further, the amount claimed for general damages is a globular amount which cannot
be subdivided in heads of damages.
[14] The Applicant pleaded that notwithstanding demand, the Respondent has failed
and/or neglected and/or refused to make payment to the Applicant as aforesaid or at
all, which payment is now due.
[15] The Respondent filed a notice of intention to defend on 18 February 2025 and on the
5th of March 2025 a notice of exception. The grounds of excepti6n are as follows:-
15.1 The Applicant instituted a common-law 9laim against the Respondent for
damages suffered by her as a result of injuries sustained by her and
consequences flowing from such injuries, •
..
15.2 In paragraph 5 of the particulars of claim the Applicant alleges that she was
on 23 April 2023 during normal business hours rightfully on the Respondent's
<,
premises performing her duties as a cleaner when another employee by the
name of Senyolo: acting within the course and scope of his employment with
the Respondent, sprayed her with a chemical onto her face using a backpack
sprayer ("the incident"), which incident caused her to suffer severe injuries to
her eyes.
15.3 The Applicant is an "employee" and the Defendant is an "employer'' as
defined by the Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act, 130
of 1993 ("COIDA")
15.4 Section 22(1) of COIDA provides as follows:-

7
"If an employee meets with an accident resulting in his disablement or death
such employee or the dependants of such employee shall, subject to the
provisions of the Act, be entitled to the benefits provided for and described in
this Act."
15.5 An "accidenf' is defined in COIDA as follows:-
'"accident' means an accident out of and in the course of an employee's
employment and resulting in a personal injury, illness or the death of the
employee ."
15.6 Section 35(1) of COIDA provides as follows: ,
"No action shall lie by an employee or any depen(jant of an employee for the
recovery of damages in respect of 9riy occupational injury or disease resulting
in the disablement or death of such ,, employee against such employee's
,
employer, and no liability ,,for cempensation on the part of such employer shall
arise save under the provisions of this Act in respect of such disablement or
death."
15. 7 An "occupationc:11 injury" is defined in Section 1 of COi DA as follows:
'" occupational injury' means a personal injury sustained as a result of an
accident.,,,,
15.8 In Mankayi v Anglogold Ashanti Ltd 2010 (5) SA 137 (SCA) the Supreme
Court of Appeal held that Section 35(1) of COIDA also precludes an action for
general damages in respect of which no compensation can be recovered in
terms of COi DA.
15.9 The incident relied upon by the Applicant in her claim against the
Respondent, is an "accidenf' as contemplated by COIDA, which accident

8
arose out of such employment and which have occurred during the course of
her employment.
15.10 The Applicant is accordingly statutorily barred from claiming directly against
the Respondent by virtue of Section 35(1) of COIDA.
15.11 The Applicant in the premises has no common-law claim against the
Respondent arising from the incident.
[16] Consequently, the Respondent prays for an order that the exception be upheld with
costs and that the Applicant's claim be dismissed with costs.
[17] The Applicant in opposition submitted that the injuries sustained by the Applicant do
not fall within the ambit of the Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases
Act, 130 of 1993.
[18] It was submitted th~t in Churchill v Premier, Mpumalanga (889/2019) [2021]
ZASCA 16 (4 March 2021), the Court at paragraph 12 held that there are three
elements to the definition of an accident, namely:-
18.1 An accident;
t82 Ari§ing out of and in the course of an employee's employment; and
18.3 Resulting in a personal injury, illness or the death of the employee.
[19] It was further submitted by the Applicant that in Minister of Justice v Khoza 1966
(1) SA 410 (A) the court developed two tests in deciding whether an incident is an
"accident" which arose out of or in the course of employment which is as follows:-

9
19.1 The first is by the majority concurring in the judgment of Rumpff C.J - an
injury from an assault at work is not an accident where the motive or the
reason for the assault is unrelated to the job.
19.2 Secondly, by Williams JA in the minority judgment - It is that an injury from an
assault at work is an accident where the fact of employment ,Qrings the
employee within the range or zone of the hazard that gave ri~e to the injury.
[20] It was further submitted by the Applicant that in MEC for Health, free State v DN
(MEC v DN) [2014] ZASCA 167; 2015 (1) SA 18) (SCA), Navsa ADP said "the
question that might rightly be asked is whether the act c9using the injury was a risk
incidental to the employment".
[21] It was submitted that the court wen't,,Ju\rther at paragraph 20 in MEC v DN supra
and said that "the plaintiff in that case was at her place of employment and about her
duties at the time of tti,e assault. Her employment had brought her within the zone of
the hazard giving rise to her injuries. That pointed to her injury arising out of her
,
employment. But when the question was asked whether the risk was incidental to
her employment, the answer was an emphatic 'No"'.
[22] The Applicant submitted that in casu as per paragraph 5 of her particulars of claim,
,,she alleged that she was at work as a cleaner and the Respondent's employee, Mr.
Senyolo was busy spraying using a backpack sprayer when he sprayed her on her
face with a chemical. The Applicant submitted that the fact that the incident
occurred in her workplace when she was going about her duties is undoubtedly a

factor that connected it to her employment. Her employment brought her within the
zone of risk, but that is where it ends as it did not arise out of her employment.
[23] The Applicant submitted further that the only connection between the incident and
her employment was that she was at work at the time of the incident. The incident
bore no relation to her duties and was the result of negligence op the part of the
Respondent's employee, Mr. Senyolo by failing to exercise care in handling his
backpack sprayer. The injuries the Applicant does not arise out ofJhe performance
of her duties and as such, were not incidental to t)er employment. Therefore, it is
submitted that, the Respondent's exception stands to;be dismissed.
[24] The core issue that this Court has to decide in the present case is whether the injury
had been sustained at the workplace and whether the employee was eligible for
damages under COIDA, or whether the employer could be held liable given that
COIDA indemnifies the employer. As stated in Churchill v Premier of Mpumalanga
and Another (889/2019) [2021] ZASCA 16 (4 March 2021), this would indeed be
the position if the injuries were sustained in the course of the employee's duties.
There needs to be a direct nexus between the employee's injury(-ies) and the
execution of her duties. However, the Court held in Churchill supra that if the injury
took place at the workplace but was not related to the employee's duties, then
COIDA does not indemnify the employer and the employer is therefore liable.
[25] The Court in Churchill v Premier of Mpumalanga and Another (889/2019) [2021]
ZASCA 16 (4 March 2021) held as follows: 'In this case the only connection

11
between the incident and Ms Churchill's employment was that she was at work at
the time. The incident bore no relation to her duties and was the result of misplaced
anger directed at her because of a misunderstanding. She was not assaulted
because of the position she held, or because of anything she had done in carrying
out her duties, or for any reason related to the protest action that took place that day.
She was assaulted because one individual mistakenly thought she had sworn at him
and he, together with others, responded by assaulting and humiliating her. In my
opinion her injuries did not arise out of her employment.'
[26] In my view, in the present matter, the spraying of Chemicals by Mr. Senyolo with a
backpack sprayer at the premises of tbe Respdpdent bore no relation to the
Applicant in her duties as a cleaner. She did n9t sustain the injuries because of the
position she held, or because of anything she had done in carrying out her duties.
She was injured because Mr. Senyolp had sprayed her on her face with a chemical
using a backpack sprayer, whether negligently so or deliberately as an assault is for
the trial court to determine.
[27] In the result, in my view, the Respondent is not excluded from liability by Section 35
of the Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act, 13 of 1993 and the
exception stands to be dismissed with costs. In my view, Costs on Scale B of
Uniform Rule 67A read with Uniform Rule 69, in the circumstances are justified.
[28] It the result, following order was made:-
28.1 The Exception is dismissed.

12
28.2 The Respondent (employer) is ordered to pay the Applicant's costs of the
exception, which costs are to be taxed and paid on Scale B.
APPEARANCES:
HEARD ON:
JUDGMENT DELIVERED:
\
For the Applicant/Plaintiff :
Instructed by:
ENDAAL
POPO DIVISION,
POLOKWANE
~12 AUC3UST 2026
3 NOVEMBER 2026
Adv. H.P. Mabuza
Mokhobi P Attorneys Inc.
C/O Mabjana Thulare Attorneys
146 Marshall Street, Polokwane
malokathulare@gmail .com

13
For the Respondent/Defendant:
Instructed by:
Adv. R. Grundlingh
Joubert & May Attorneys
C/O Kampherbeek Twine & Pogrund
Attorneys
25A Biccard Street, Polokwane
ktp6@ktpsa .co.za
aldo@joubertmay .co.za