A.Y v D.D.E.Y (12442/24) [2026] ZAWCHC 660 (6 November 2026)

45 Reportability

Brief Summary

Family Law — Divorce — Interim maintenance — Rule 43 application for maintenance and care arrangements — Applicant seeking maintenance for children and spousal support — Respondent providing evidence of financial contributions and disputing applicant's claims — Court finding applicant failed to disclose true financial position — Application dismissed due to lack of merit and no prejudice to children.

SAFLII Note: Certain personal/private det ails of parties or witnesses have been redacted from this
document in compliance with the law and SAFLII Policy


IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(WESTERN CAPE DIVISION, CAPE TOWN)
CASE NO: 12442/24

In the matter between
A[...] Y[...] APPLICANT

AND

D[...] D[...] E[...] Y[...] RESPONDENT
Heard: 16 October 2026
Delivered electronically: 06 November 2026

ORDER

(a) The application is dismissed.
(b) No cost order made.

JUDGMENT

THULARE J

[1] This is an opposed Rule 43 application for interim relief pending the final
determination of the divorce action pending between the parties. The applicant
sought maintenance for two minor children, spousal maintenance , contribution
towards legal costs and the regulation of primary care , which she sought for
both children and contact, by the respondent, with the children. The minor son,
a teenager at 15 years of age , has been residing with the respondent since
August 2025 and the mother exercises contact ; and both parents exercise
alternating blocks of care of 2-2-3 days each with the minor daughter, a 4-year-
old and exercise contact.

[2] The applicant sought maintenance for the children in the amount of
R12 000-00 per month and that the respondent contributes towards all
reasonable educational, medical, pharmaceutical, school -related child-care and
extramural expenses incurre d on behalf of the minor children ; spousal
maintenance in the amount of R10 000-00 per month and a contribution to legal
costs in the amount of R85 000-00. The parties agreed to a provisional parenting
plan in terms of which they shared care and contact. It has drifted to a situation
where the son is with the respondent, with the applicant having reasonable
contact, and in respect of the daughter the parties exercise shared care and

contact. The initial parenting plan , before the provisional one , had provided for
the children to be in the primary care of the applicant with the respondent
having reasonable contact and care.
[3] The main issue between the parties concerns the adequacy of the
respondent’s contribution and the extent of his maintenance obligations. The
respondent contributes R5850 -00 per month towards the maintenance of the
daughter for the period tha t the daughter is with the applicant. The applicant
made no monthly contribution to the maintenance of the son. The applicant and
the children are on the respondent’s medical aid. The respondent made a tender
to continue to contribute R5850 -00 per month and to retain both the applicant
and the children on his medical aid scheme. The respondent broke down the
figure of R5850-00 as follows: R1300-00 for the son’s tutor and the rest for the
daughter at R2500 -00 which is half of the nanny’s fees, R1400-00 half of her
school fees, R650 -00 lunch fees . He made payments of R154-29 as playball
reimbursements which are only payable per school term . He pays for the living
expenses of the son in full, as well as for the daughter for half of the time of the
month that she is with him. He expects the applicant to also cover all the costs
of the daughter for half of the time that she is with her. He also paid for a
V odacom contract which covers four devices which are his phone, the son’s
phone and the applicant’s phone and laptop.

[4] The applicant is self-employed and derives her income from the operation of
her own business. The income is irregular and seasonal with payments
fluctuating from month to month . The business provides professional hair and
make0up services primarily for weddings, bridal bookings and other special
events and as such affected by wedding seasons, bookings, deposits received in
advance and payments made in respect of future events. Deposits do not
constitute personal disposable income. Many relate to future bookings and are

required to be retained or utilized for future business obligations including
stock, products, subcontractors, freelance artists, travel, equipment , refunds,
bank charges and other operating expenses, payments to assistants, suppliers,
insurance and other business-related expenses.

[5] The applicant did not receive a fixed monthly salary from the business but
drew funds from the business as and when available to meet personal expenses,
household expenses, the needs of the minor children and the liabilities which
the respondent previously contributed towards. The applicant attached her
business bank statements for the period December 2025 to May 2026 , but did
not, under oath, indicate how much even on average, she earned from her
business monthly.

[6] In his response, the respondent alleged that the applicant sought, through
this application , to change the current care and contact arrangements without
any input from experts . He took issue with her claiming maintenance for the
children on the basis that they both lived with her full -time, which was not the
case. In his calculations , her business bank accounts showed that she received
on average about R181 000-00 per month and earned approximately R110 000-
00 per month after paying business expenses. The respondent, referring to the
applicant’s bank statements , showed that the applicant received between
R141 500-00 and R223 000-00 per month . Payments to freelance artists were
about R63 000-00 per month, stock and supplied about R3800 -00 per month,
bank charges, website and accounting fees about R2500 -00 per month .
Approximately R109 800-00 remained available monthly to the applicant. The
applicant’s personal expenses were paid by the business. These included school
fees, electricity, groceries, takeaways, clothing, fu el, policies and two vehicle

instalments. The bank statements showed that she spent R47 344-79 on
household necessaries and R32 240-00 on her own personal expenses.

[7] He attached his own pay slips for June, July and August 2026 which showed
total earnings of between R52 916-92 and R57 661-98 with he averaged at
R54 598-68. The net averaged R32 838063 which went to R35 574-63 when he
worked in the bonus. These amounts included emergency overtime and standby
allowances, without which his income would be lower. Save for a voluntary life
cover for which he paid R254 -87, all his deductions were compulsory
deductions, which included medical aid in which the applicant and the children
were registered as his dependents. His expenses included R1533-23 each for
himself and the son, R3066-47 for the applican t payable to V odacom contracts,
R5451-86 to service a personal loan with Absa , R899-98 for security company,
R599-00 for Vitality, R5118-14 for food, R2572-87 for fuel, R3011-78 for uber
transport, R414.29 for electricity R933-66 for children activities , R529 -57 for
airtime and data, R323 -67 for pharmacy, R1558-84 for clothing and personal
care, R1389-58 for bank interest and fees and R 1895-28 miscellaneous. He has
a monthly shortfall of just over R4000-00 between his income and expenses.

[8] Rule 43 serves an important purpose , to wit, to provide a speedy and
inexpensive remedy, primarily for the benefit of women and children and
remains a valid mechanism for urgent relief in matrimonial matters [ S v S and
Another [2019] ZACC 22 ; 2019 (8) BCLR 989 (CC); 2019 (6) SA 1 (CC) (27
June 2019)]. It ensures the equality of arms principle, as both parties in a
specific matter should be treated in a manner that ensures they are in a
procedurally equal position to make their case [ S v S and Another para 40 and

41]. In his article titled Interim maintenance – how to use Rule 43 in divorce
proceedings, Simon Dippenaar (23 August 2019) wrote:
Modern relationships are complex
In the not-so-distant past, it was common for the man to be the breadwinner and the woman
to be the homemaker, particularly where there were children. Now it is normal for both
spouses to be working, but there may be significant differences in income. This may lead to
one party having the means to afford “luxurious litigation” while the other must make do
with a more frugal legal representation.
It is also not unusual for the woman to be the main earner or for both spouses to be of the
same sex. This introduces new complexity into the unravelling of a marriage and may find
either party making a Rule 43 application for a range of reasons, including the cost of
litigation. Furthermore, the financial affairs of one or the other may be intertwined with
family trusts or businesses in South Africa or offshore in which they are beneficiaries.
Therefore, interim maintenance, or any other terms of a Rule 43 order, must be carefully
considered to avoid either party suffering a severe disadvantage, which may haunt them long
after the divorce is finalised.

[9] I am not persuaded that the applicant took this court into her confidence and
disclosed her true financial position , in particular her monthly income from her
business. The respondent’s answer is not far -fetched, clearly untenable or
fictitious. The respondent did not simply state bare denials but provided real
factual rebuttal . I am not persuaded that the applicant is entitled to obtain an
order, which is not appealable, in the face of facts which are genuinely disputed
by a plausible response. The Family Advocate will investigate and hel p provide
an expert report on the care and contact of the children, and there is no reason to
disturb the current arrangements in the absence of prejudice or circumstances

disturb the current arrangements in the absence of prejudice or circumstances
which are not in the best interest of the children. For these reasons I make the
order.
(a) The application is dismissed.

(b) No cost order made.



___________________________
DM THULARE
JUDGE OG THE HIGH COURT

Appearances
Applicant Counsel: Adv. R-L Potgieter
Instructing Attorney: Mr H Zwiegers
Respondent Counsel: Unknown
Instructing Attorney: DDR Y[…]