IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
GAUTENG DIVISION, JOHANNESBURG
Case number: 2019-13721
In the matter between
BUZME KHALID SHAH CHISTY SABRI INTERNATIONAL NPC Applicant
and
BAZME KHALID SHAH CHISTY SABREE INTERNATIONAL NPO First Respondent
AHMED CASSIM Second Respondent
MOHAMED SALIM ISMAIL RANDEREE Third Respondent
YAKOOB KHAN Fourth Respondent
___________________________________________________________________
Order
___________________________________________________________________
1. The application against the First and Second Respondents succeeds and it is
declared that the First and Second Respondents are in contempt of this Court’s
order dated 18 April 2019.
2. The application against the Third and Fourth Respondents is dismissed.
(1) Reportable: yes / no
(2) Of interest to other judges: yes / no
(3) revised: yes / no
5 November 2026 __________________________
Date Signature
2
3. The First and Second Respondents are ordered to pay, jointly and severally,
the Applicant’s costs in respect of the application, or portions thereof, against
the First and Second Respondents on the party and party scale, including the
costs of one counsel on scale B.
4. The Applicant is ordered to pay the Third and Fourth Respondents’ costs in
respect of the application, or portions thereof, against the Third and Fourth
Respondents on the party and party scale, including the costs of one counsel
on scale B.
___________________________________________________________________
Judgment
___________________________________________________________________
J Mitchell AJ
[1] Sorry, reader, this may be a confusing read. It’s a dispute between two
religious organisations with just about the same name: Buzme Khalid Shah
Chisty Sabri International and Bazme Khalid Shah Chisty Sabree
International. The only way to tell them apart is Buzme versus Bazme and
Sabri versus Sabree (and to make things more difficult , there’s a third entity
to keep an eye on, Buzme Sabree, but more on it later).
[2] Buzme Sabri and Bazme Sabree are locked in lawfare. Each claims to be the
rightful host of an annual religious ceremony honouring an Islamic saint. This
Court twice entered the fray with orders in favour of Buzme Sabri in 2019 and
2022. Buzme Sabri alleges Bazme Sabree breached the orders. It asks me to
hold Bazme Sabree and three of its senior members—Mr Cassim (chairman),
Mr Randeree (secretary), and Mr Khan (treasurer)—in contempt.
3
[3] Buzme Sabri wins against Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim. They are both in
contempt of the 2019 order. Declarations of contempt are warranted, but
coercive or punitive sanctions are not . Buzme Sabri loses against Mr
Randeree and Mr Khan.
[4] To see why I reach those conclusions, keep this diagram close by:
[5] Rewind a few decades . A voluntary association called Buzme Sabree was
formed to honour the life of Hazrat Sayed Muhammad Khalid Shah Chishti
Sabiree Jahangiri Kambal Posh. Many in the local Muslim community revere
Hazrat Khalid Shah Bawa as a saint.
Buzme Sabree
(the original voluntary
association)
Buzme Sabri
(the Applicant)
Bazme Sabree
(the First Respondent)
- Mr Omar (director and
deponent of founding
affidavit)
- Mr Cassim (chairman
and Second Respondent)
- Mr Randeree (secretary
and Second Respondent)
- Mr Khan (treasurer and
Second Respondent)
4
[6] Hazrat Khalid Shah Bawa is buried in the Wattville Cemetery in Benoni.
Buzme Sabree bought the burial site from the local municipality and built a
large shrine—or a mazaar as it’s known to adherents of Islam (it seems that
the local municipality owns the Cemetery but some portions of the Cemetery
are privately owned). Buzme Sabree also bought property near the Cemetery
and built a mosque. The life and legacy of Hazrat Khalid Shah Bawa is
celebrated each year at the mazaar—at an event known as an urs.
[7] According to Buzme Sabri, Buzme Sabree was “defunct” by 2012, and a
restructuring saw the formation and incorporation of Buzme Sabri as a non -
profit company . Bazme Sabree disputes this . It alleges that it and Buzme
Sabree are one and the same: “the original [v]oluntary [a]ssociation”, as
Mr Cassim puts it. Bazme Sabree describes Buzme Sabri a s a dissenting
“splinter group”.
[8] Amongst many other disputes, Buzme Sabri and Bazme Sabree disagree
about who owns the mazaar and the mosque (or at least who is entitled to
ownership). Buzme Sabri says its name is on the title deeds . Bazme Sabree
seems to accept that’s what the title deeds say but it accuses Buzme Sabri of
“hijacking ownership” through “fraudulently misrepresent[ations]” to the Deeds
Office (Bazme Sabree argues that it owns the mazaar and the mosque
because it draws a straight line between it and Buzme Sabree) . Ownership
aside, Buzme Sabri has controlled the mazaar and the mosque for several
years.
5
[9] Buzme Sabri says that in 2018, Bazme Sabree “unlawfully took possession”
of the mazaar by changing the locks. Buzme Sabri sued in urgent court.
Buzme Sabri says it withdrew its urgent application because the parties
agreed to arbitrate ; Bazme Sabree says Buzme Sabri withdrew because it
couldn’t prove ownership of the mazaar . Be that as it may, there was an
arbitration. And in April 2018 an award was made by consent, signed by Mr
Omar for Buzme Sabri and Mr Cassim for Bazme Sabree. The award says it’s
“final and binding” on Buzme Sabri and Bazme Sabree.
[10] Amongst other things, t he award records that “[t]he name of the
controlling/administrative association” of the mazaar and of the mosque is
Buzme Sabri “to the exclusion of any other body or association” . The award
directed Buzme Sabri to hold an AGM by October 2018 and appointed an
interim board that included Mr Omar and Mr Cassim. The award directs that
the urs “will be conducted in the name of [Buzme Sabri] and the parties will
co-operate with each other in the interests of ensuring the smooth running of
the Urs and other activities at the Mazaar from time to time.”
[11] Despite Mr Cassim signing it for Bazme Sabree, Bazme Sabree distances
itself from the award. Mr Cassim argues that the terms of the settlement (which
he describes as “favourable to [Bazme Sabree]”) were “not converted to
writing”, and that the award he signed was a “misrepresentation” that he only
saw after he signed. Mr Cassim also describes the arbitration as a “sham”.
6
[12] According to Buzme Sabri, an AGM was held in October 2018, and it expected
Mr Cassim to stand for election as a director. Mr Cassim was not at the AGM
and was not elected.
[13] Several years of litigation between Buzme Sabri and Bazme Sabree followed,
mostly to do with the urs. In 2019, Bazme Sabree advertised that it would host
the urs at the mazaar —in Buzme Sabri’s view, contrary to the arbitration
award (which leaves the urs to Buzme Sabri ). So Buzme Sabri went back to
urgent court, this time for an interdict. This Court granted an order against
Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim that, amongst other things:
- interdicts Mr Cassim and Bazme Sabree (and “any members” of Bazme
Sabree) “from directly and/or indirectly from interfering and/or disrupting
the operations and activities” of Buzme Sabri; and
- interdicts Mr Cassim and Bazme Sabree (and “any members” of Bazme
Sabree) “from being within 150m of the gate” of the mazaar or the
mosque.
[14] Buzme Sabri says the same thing happened in 2022: Buzme Sabri advertised
the urs at the mazaar and, a few days later, Bazme Sabree advertised that it
would host the urs at the mazaar. Buzme Sabri went back to court. This Court
granted an order against Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and
Mr Khan that, amongst other things:
- ordered Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan to
withdraw their advert for the urs and inform the public that Buzme Sabri,
not Bazme Sabree, would host the urs;
7
- declares that Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan “remain interdicted
and restrained from directly and/or indirectly interfering and/or disturbing
any of [Buzme Sabri’s] businesses and/or activities and/or operations”;
- allows Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan to visit the mazaar and
the mosque “on any day save for when [Buzme Sabri] is hosting any
event … with the written permission of [Buzme Sabri], whose permission
will not be unreasonably withheld”; and
- declares that the 2019 order “will remain in force”.
[15] Later in 2022, Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan applied
to rescind (or “review”) the 2019 order and the 2022 order. They allege that
both orders were fraudulently obtained because Buzme Sabri misled this
Court about ownership of the mazaar and the mosque. The rescission
application remains pending.
[16] Buzme Sabri says the same pattern played out in 2024 and again in 2025:
soon after Buzme Sabri advertised it would host the urs at the mazaar, Bazme
Sabree advertised that it would host the urs at the mazaar (for both 2024 and
2025, there seems to be some dispute about whether Buzme Sabri or Bazme
Sabree advertised first, but in my view not much turns on it).
[17] For the 2024 urs, Bazme Sabree put up a marquee in the Wattville Cemetery
close to the mazaar. It says it got permission from the local municipality (which
owns the Cemetery, or at least owns the Cemetery except for privately owned
portions like the mazaar). Mr Omar alleges that the marquee was “in an area
allocated to [Buzme Sabri]”, which I take to mean within 150 metres of the
8
gate of the mazaar (and Mr Omar attaches a photo around the time of the
2024 urs that he describes as showing the marquee “erected next to the gate
of the Mazaar”).
[18] Buzme Sabri asked the police and the local municipality to intervene, but ,
according to Mr Omar, they “refuse[d] to enforce the court orders”. Mr Omar
says the police and the local municipality left Buzme Sabri with a Hobson’s
choice of letting Bazme Sabree and its marquee stay or there would be no urs
at all. In the end, Bazme Sabree moved its marquee a bit farther away—it says
voluntarily, Buzme Sabri says on orders of the police and the local
municipality. Mr Omar says the marquee was still within 150 metres of the
mazaar even after it was moved, which Mr Cassim denies.
[19] The urs went ahead , both at the mazaar and in the nearby marquee.
According to Mr Cassim, “[b]oth functions took place peacefully”.
[20] Buzme Sabri alleges that a few days later, Mr Cassim and other members of
Bazme Sabree went into the mazaar without Buzme Sabri’s consent for a
“musical session”. Mr Cassim says they were invited “as musical artists” by
“the Khan and Rahman family”.
[21] After Buzme Sabri advertised the 2025 urs, the police asked Buzme Sabri to
a meeting. Bazme Sabree was also at the meeting—Buzme Sabri and Bazme
Sabree both applied for permission for the urs, and the police wanted to
“mediate an agreement”. Nothing seems to have come of it and, after some
back and forth, Bazme Sabree advertised that it would host the urs at the
mazaar.
9
[22] Bazme Sabree again put up a marquee close to the mazaar ( “less than 150
metres away”, according to Mr Omar). Mr Omar says Bazme Sabree disrupted
Buzme Sabri’s urs and “violated the court orders”, including by playing loud
music and forming a procession that went into the mazaar.
[23] Buzme Sabri now asks for an order declaring Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim,
Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan in contempt of the 2019 order and the 2022 order
based on what they did at the urs in 2024 and in 2025.
[24] Buzme Sabri must prove the existence of the orders, that Bazme Sabree, Mr
Cassim, Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan knew about the orders, and that they did
not comply with the orders , Secretary, Judicial Commission of Inquiry Into
Allegations of State Capture v Zuma 2021 (5) SA 327 (CC) at para 37. If
Buzme Sabri proves those three requirements, “wilfulness and mala fides are
presumed” and they “bea[r] an evidentiary burden in relation to wilfulness and
mala fides”, Zuma, above, at para 37. Coercive remedies like imprisonment or
a fine require proof of the requirements of contempt beyond reasonable doubt,
but proof on a balance of probabilities is enough for non -coercive remedies
like a declaration of contempt, Fakie NO v CCII Systems (Pty) Ltd 2006 (4) SA
326 (SCA) at para 42.
[25] There’s no dispute about the existence of the 2019 order and the 2022 order.
Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim are parties to both orders. Mr Randeree and
Mr Khan aren’t parties to the 2019 order, but they’re parties to the 2022 order.
They all argue that the 2019 order and the 2022 order were obtained
fraudulently, but that’s at best a ground to rescind the orders; it’s not a reason
to ignore them, see Van Dyk v Rhodes 2025 (4) SA 313 (GJ) at para 1 (citing
10
Department of Transport and Others v Tasima (Pty) Ltd 2017 (2) SA 622 (CC)
for the proposition that “ a court order can no longer be ignored or rescinded
merely upon proof that it would have been regarded as a common-law nullity”
and that “[t]he ordinary principles of rescission or appeal will always apply to
court orders wrongly granted, no matter what er ror led to their issuance”).
Their pending application to rescind the 2019 and 2022 orders doesn’t matter
because merely applying to rescind an order doesn’t affect its binding force.
[26] There’s also no dispute that Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and
Mr Khan knew about the orders before 2024. Mr Cassim admits as much as
far as Bazme Sabree goes. I also infer knowledge on the part of Bazme
Sabree and Mr Cassim, and on the part of Mr Randeree and Mr Khan, from
the litigation timeline: Buzme Sabri attached the 2019 order to its application
for an interdict in 2022 (which was served on Mr Cassim, Mr R anderee, and
Mr Khan personally), and Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan applied to
rescind the 2022 order the same year.
[27] As for non -compliance, and taking each of Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim,
Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan in turn, Buzme Sabri discharged its burden to
prove non-compliance by Bazme Sabree. Bazme Sabree advertised its urs for
the same date as Buzme Sabri’s urs. The advert says the urs will be held at
the Wattville Cemetery, with an illustration of the mazaar. The advert also adds
that the urs “has been solely organised for the past 40 years” by Bazme
Sabree. In my view, the advert amounted to, in the words of the 2019 order,
“direc[t]” or “indirec[t] … interfer[ence] and/or disrupti[on]” of the “operations
and activities” of Buzme Sabri , and so Buzme Sabri has discharged its onus
11
to prove that Bazme Sabree breached that part of the 2019 order in respect
of the 2024 urs.
[28] There’s then Bazme Sabree’s marquee for the 2024 urs. Mr Omar alleges that
the marquee “was not 150 metres away”. Mr Cassim argues that Mr Omar
doesn’t “cite any evidence or proof” of the marquee’s distance from the
mazaar. But Mr Omar’s allegation is evidence, and Mr Cassim’s bare denial
means there’s no real or genuine dispute of fact about whether the marquee
was within the 2019 order’s 150-metre radius, Wightman t/a JW Construction
v Headfour (Pty) Ltd 2008 (3) SA 371 (SCA) at paras 12 to 13. Buzme Sabri
has accordingly also discharged its onus to prove that Bazme Sabree
breached this part of the 2019 order in respect of the 2024 urs.
[29] I find the same for Bazme Sabree’s conduct for the 2025 urs. Bazme Sabree’s
advert for the 2025 urs is materially the same as the previous year’s advert
(and, as I’ve already concluded, that amounted to “direc[t]” or “indirec[t] …
interfer[ence] and/or disrupti[on]” of the “operations and activities” of Buzme
Sabri). Mr Omar’s evidence is that Bazme Sabree’s marquee for the 2025 urs
was “less than 150 metres” from the mazaar, which Mr Cassim just denies.
I accordingly conclude that Buzme Sabri has discharged its onus to prove that
Bazme Sabree breached the 2019 order in respect of the 2025 urs.
[30] Bazme Sabree’s main defence about the marquee is that the local municipality
permitted Bazme Sabree to put up the marquee in the Wattville Cemetery for
the urs in 2024 and in 2025 . Buzme Sabri doesn’t dispute the existence of
permission, but it argues that it ’s legally irrelevant because it “does not
override, negate, or excuse [Bazme Sabree’s] obligations to comply with the
12
binding court orders”. Permission from the local municipality may be relevant
on several levels: consent to do something that a court order otherwise
prohibits could, in principle, mean there’s no breach of the order, or consent
could be an affirmative defence to contempt, or consent (or belief in consent)
could be the basis for someone in Bazme Sabree’s position to rebut wilfulness
and mala fides.
[31] I deal with the third possibility later. I reject the first and second possibilities.
Neither the 2019 order nor the 2022 order has a carve out for municipal (or
police) consent (unlike the carve out for consent by Buzme Sabri to enter the
mazaar in the 2022 order). And neither a municipality nor the police has an
all-purpose power to turn court orders on and off. Bazme Sabree points out
that the marquee was on the municipality’s p roperty. But two things can be
true at once: Bazme Sabree could’ve had permission from the municipality to
put up its marquee on municipal land but still interdicted from being within 150
metres of the mazaar.
[32] So much for Bazme Sabree, the marquee, and the 2019 order. Buzme Sabri
hasn’t proved that Bazme Sabree breached the 2022 order, either in respect
of the 2024 urs or the 2025 urs. There’s no evidence that Bazme Sabree didn’t
withdraw its advert for the 2022 urs, and there’s no evidence that it didn’t
publish the “official communique” that the 2022 order required. The rest of the
2022 order applies only to Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree, and Mr Khan.
[33] For his part, Mr Cassim doesn’t deny he went into the mazaar shortly after the
urs in 2024. He argues that “the Khan and Rahman family” invited him, but he
doesn’t even allege, let alone adduce any evidence, that they had any
13
authority to extend the invitation. Nor does Mr Cassim deny that he was part
of a procession that went into the mazaar during the urs in 2025. He argues
that this was “agreed upon between the parties” at a meeting at the beginning
of 2025, but Buzme Sabri sent a letter to Bazme Sabree shortly after that
meeting (and before the urs) which clarified that “any concessions” that Buzme
Sabri “tentatively suggested” at that meeting were “without prejudice”.
[34] In those circumstances, Buzme Sabri has, in my view, discharged its onus to
prove that Mr Cassim breached the 2019 order because he went into the
mazaar without Buzme Sabri’s consent in 2024 and in 2025. This also means
that Buzme Sabri discharged its onus of proving that Bazme Sabree breached
the 2019 order in the same respect because Mr Cassim was, at the time, one
of its senior representatives, Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp v Playboy Films
(Pty) Ltd 1978 (3) SA 202 (W) at 203C -D (holding that “[a] director of a
company who, with knowledge of an order of Court against the company,
causes the company to disobey the order is himself guilty of a contempt of
Court” because “[b]y his act or omission such a director aids and ab ets the
company to be in breach of the order of Court against the company”).
[35] In my view, Buzme Sabri has not discharged its onus to prove that Mr Cassim
breached the 2022 order, at least not in any different respects to the 2019
order. The problem for Buzme Sabri on this score is that the only material
difference between the 2019 order and the 2022 order is that the 2022 order
additionally says that Mr Cassim “may attend to visit the Mazaar and the
Mosque on any day save for when [Buzme Sabri] is hosting any event and/or
is carrying out any activities, with the written permission of [Buzme Sabri]”. It’s
not clear to me what that part of the 2022 order is obliging Mr Cassim to do or
14
to refrain from doing. In my view, that part of the 2022 order is too vague to be
enforced through a contempt application, at least on the evidence before me
in this application.
[36] Buzme Sabri’s evidence is similarly thin against Mr Randeree and Mr Khan .
Neither is a party to the 2019 order. They are parties to the 2022 order, but
nothing in the 2022 order expressly incorporates by reference the 2019 order.
The 2022 order says that the 2019 order “will remain in force”, but the use of
“remain” suggests that the 2019 order applies only to its original parties. The
2022 order also says that Mr Randeree and Mr Khan “remain interdicted” from
interfering with or disrupting Buzme Sabri’s activities , which could’ve been
phrased better : it’s awkward for an order to say someone “remain[s]
interdicted” if they were never previously interdicted. Nonetheless, that part of
the order can reasonably be interpreted to interdict Mr Randeree and Mr Khan
from “directly and/or indirectly interfering and/or disrupting any of [Buzme
Sabri’s] businesses and/or activities and/or operations” —that is, “remain
interdicted” is a tolerably clear way to say “are interdicted”. But even so,
Buzme Sabri doesn’t adduce enough evidence to show what Mr Randeree or
Mr Khan did, if anything, that interfered with or disturbed Buz me Sabri’s
activities (apart from allegations levelled at “the Respondents”, which, in my
view, are inadequately particularised as against Mr Randeree and Mr Khan).
That leaves the last relevant part of the 2022 order, which says Mr Randeree
and Mr Khan, like Mr Cassim, “may attend to visit the Mazaar and the Mosque
on any day save for when [Buzme Sabri] is hosting any event and/or is carrying
out any activities, with the written permission of [Buzme Sabri]”. I ’ve already
15
explained why, in my view, that part of the 2022 order is too vague to sustain
a finding of non-compliance, at least on the evidence in this application.
[37] To sum up, these are my findings on breaches of the 2019 order and the 2022
order:
- Bazme Sabree breached the 2019 order . It interfered with, and
disrupted, Buzme Sabri’s activities when it advertised that it would host
the 2024 urs and the 2025 urs. It breached the 2019 order when it put
up a marquee within 150 metres of the mazaar at the 2024 urs and the
2025 urs. And it breached the 2019 order when Mr Cassim, acting as its
representative, went into the mazaar without Buzme Sabri’s permission
in 2024 and in 2025. Buzme Sabri hasn’t, however, proved that Bazme
Sabree breached the 2022 order.
- Mr Cassim breached the 2019 order. He went into the mazaar without
Buzme Sabri’s permission in 2024 and in 2025. Buzme Sabri hasn’t,
however, proved that Mr Cassim breached the 2022 order.
- Mr Randeree and Mr Khan aren’t parties to the 2019 order. Buzme Sabri
hasn’t proved that they breached the 2022 order.
[38] It’s next necessary to determine if Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim discharged
their evidentiary burden to rebut a presumption of wilfulness and mala fides.
[39] Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim adduce little, if any, evidence to rebut the
presumption when it comes to the adverts for the 2024 urs and the 2025 urs,
and Mr Cassim entering the mazaar in 2024 and 2025.
16
[40] As for the marquee at the 2024 urs and the 2025 urs, they argue that the local
municipality gave them permission. I’ve already rejected that argument as an
affirmative defence to contempt. But even if Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim
were objectively mistaken about the legal effect of the local municipality’s
permission, a genuine belief that permission was effective would be enough
to rebut wilfulness and mala fides, JR v AL 2021 JDR 2661 (GJ) at para 9
(holding that a “deliberate failure to comply with a court order is not enough if
good faith is established”, including if there is a “genuine (albeit mistaken)
belief that the conduct constituting non -compliance does not brea ch the
order”). This follows because the fault requirement for contempt is intention,
not negligence. Intention in the form of dolus eventualis is enough, HEG
Consulting Enterprises (Pty) Ltd v Siegwart 2000 (1) SA 507 (C) at 518H -I
(noting that it is “settled law” that “intention in the form of dolus eventualis is
sufficient for criminal contempt of court”). This means that the intentio n
element of contempt is satisfied if an alleged contemnor “subjectively foresaw
the possibility of the act being in contempt of court and he was reckless as to
the result”, DW v JLK 2026 JDR 2791 (WCC) at para 19. Recklessness
includes “[w]here a person deliberately closes his or her eyes to what the law
requires”, DW, above, at para 19. And because of the presumption in
contempt proceedings and the resulting evidentiary burden, Bazme Sabree
and Mr Cassim must adduce evidence to negate subjective foresight of the
possibility of contempt and recklessness to that result.
[41] Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim don’t meet their evidentiary burden. They rely
on the local municipality’s permission as a complete answer to contempt.
Mr Cassim says nothing about whether he foresaw a possibility of contempt
17
and says nothing about whether he took any steps to ascertain the legal effect
of the local municipality’s permission. Quite the opposite: Mr Cassim’s own
evidence is that his attorney “advised us to comply with the court order”.
Mr Cassim simply didn’t do enough to rebut dolus eventualis, and so the
presumption of wilfulness and mala fides isn’t disturbed. And burdens and
presumptions aside, “common sense dictates” that the possibility that the local
municipality has no power to override a court order “would have been obvious
to any person of normal intelligence” and there’s no reason to think that
Mr Cassim “would not have shared this foresight, derived from common
human experience, with other members of the general population”,
S v Humphreys 2015 (1) SA 491 (SCA) at para 13.
[42] Bazme Sabree’s and Mr Cassim’s only other defence is “laches”, arguing that
Buzme Sabri unreasonably delayed in bringing this application. In faraway
jurisdictions, laches is a bar to equitable relief that operates if a delay means
granting relief would cause injustice: see generally S Elliott KC Snell’s Equity
(35th ed., 2025) at 5-012 (recognising the maxim of equity that delay defeats
equities but noting that “…the question is whether the lapse of time has given
rise to circumstances that now mean it would not be inequitable to deny
relief”). Laches is “peculiar to courts of equity” and, influential as English law
may be in many areas of South African law, we never signed up to equity or
its courts, Zuurbekom Ltd v Union Corporation Ltd 1947 (1) SA 514 (A) at 535.
So the short answer to the laches argument is that laches isn’t a thing down
here. Unreasonable delay is, in principle, a basis to “dismiss an action for want
of prosecution” if reviving long-dormant litigation would amount to an abuse of
process, Cassimjee v Minister of Finance 2014 (3) SA 198 (SCA) at para 10.
18
But there’s no unreasonable delay on this timeline: Buzme Sabri relies on
conduct from 2024 and 2025 in an application it launched in 2025.
[43] To sum up, Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim haven’t met their evidentiary
burden to rebut wilfulness and mala fides, and they haven’t made out any
affirmative defences to contempt. I accordingly find that Bazme Sabree and
Mr Cassim are in contempt of the 2019 order.
[44] I have broad remedial discretion when it comes to what follows, SH v GF 2013
(6) SA 621 (SCA) at para 9 (holding that when a court imposes a sanction for
contempt, it exercises “a discretion in the strict sense”). Relevant factors
include “the seriousness of the contempt, the need to vindicate the authority
of the courts, and the imperative that any sanction be proportionate”,
Van Rooyen v Kilbride 2026 JDR 2606 (WCC) at para 59.
[45] In the exercise of that discretion, my view is that a declaration of contempt is
remedy enough. The instances of contempt were, as far as contempt goes,
relatively minor and isolated. I also take into account the undertaking given at
the hearing on behalf of Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Rand eree, and
Mr Khan that they will comply with the 2019 order and the 2022 order pending
their rescission application. Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim were wrong to
disobey the orders—and it was especially wrong for a community leader like
Mr Cassim, who should lead by example. So the declaration of contempt
comes with a heavy dose of this Court’s disapproval of their conduct. Bazme
Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Rand eree, and Mr Khan must take their community
leadership roles seriously. They must obey court orders —even if they think
the orders are wrong and even if they have taken steps to rescind.
19
[46] Nothing in this judgment affects Buzme Sabri’s right to sue again in response
to future instances of disobedience. Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Randeree,
and Mr Khan would be wise to read my decision not to impose a coercive
sanction as the very last warning of a court left with very little patience.
[47] Buzme Sabri achieves substantial success against Bazme Sabree and
Mr Cassim, so it’s entitled to costs against them. Buzme Sabri wants punitive
costs, arguing that “by its very nature, contempt of court warrants a punitive
costs order.” I don’t read the cases to say punitive costs follows as a rule after
a finding of contempt, see Zuma, above, at para 134 (noting that punitive costs
orders are “exceptional”). Yes, c ontempt entails a finding of wilful non -
compliance. And yes, courts should “jealously guard against defiance of its
orders”, Medihelp Medical Scheme v De Wet 2026 JDR 0643 (GP) at para 43.
But I have reason to curb my jealousy her e. Bazme Sabree and Mr Cassim
litigated reasonably and they eventually gave an undertaking to comply with
the orders. On balance, party and party costs is enough. Buzme Sabri
achieves no success against Mr Randeree and Mr Khan, so there the general
rule on costs goes the other way. Both costs orders should include costs of
counsel on scale B because this case falls somewhere between “[r]un-of-the-
mill” and “unusually complex, important or valuable”, Mashavha v Enaex Africa
(Pty) Ltd 2025 (1) SA 466 (GJ) at para 16 . I leave it to the Taxing Master’s
discretion to work out the net effect, but it seems fair and proportional that the
costs and attendances of both sets of bills be allocated in equal proportions
between Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Rand eree, and Mr Khan (who had
the same attorney and counsel), as the case may be.
20
[48] Buzme Sabri asks for costs de bonis propriis against Avon Singh, the attorney
for Bazme Sabree, Mr Cassim, Mr Rand eree, and Mr Khan. Buzme Sabri
argues that Mr Singh was at the 2025 urs, and so he “attended an event held
in direct violation” of the 2019 order and the 2022 order , which “brings the
legal profession and the judiciary … into disrepute.” Costs de bonis propriis
are awarded against a “representative” for “improper conduct”, Pheko v
Ekurhuleni City 2015 (5) SA 600 (CC) at para 51. The point is to ensure that
the representative, not the person he represents, pays the price for improper
conduct. The point is not simply to punish the representative. For that reason
alone, this isn’t the right type of c ase for costs de bonis propriis because no
cost-shifting purpose would be achieved. In any event, there’s insufficient
evidence of the type of exceptional, egregious conduct that warrants costs de
bonis propriis (not least because Mr Singh is not party to either order).
[49] I make this order:
1. The application against the First and Second Respondents succeeds
and it is declared that the First and Second Respondents are in
contempt of this Court’s order dated 18 April 2019.
2. The application against the Third and Fourth Respondents is
dismissed.
3. The First and Second Respondents are ordered to pay, jointly and
severally, the Applicant’s costs in respect of the application, or
portions thereof, against the First and Second Respondents on the
party and party scale, including the costs of one counsel on scale B.
21
4. The Applicant is ordered to pay the Third and Fourth Respondents’
costs in respect of the application, or portions thereof, against the
Third and Fourth Respondents on the party and party scale, including
the costs of one counsel on scale B.
__________________
J Mitchell AJ
Acting Judge of the Gauteng Division, Johannesburg
Date of hearing: 21 October 2026
Date of judgment: 5 November 2026
For the Applicant: Z E Mahomed instructed by
Samnakay Attorneys Inc.
For the Respondents: A Singh instructed by Avon Singh
Attorneys Inc.