Rev Danzel P van Rensburg/Pose v Electoral Commission of South Africa and Others (0023/26 EC) [2026] ZAEC 15 (3 November 2026)

40 Reportability
Constitutional Law

Brief Summary

Electoral Law — Local government elections — Objection to candidacy — Applicant seeking clarification on the employment status of a ward candidate — Court finding that Schedule 3 of the Electoral Act does not provide for objections to candidacy — Application dismissed as unsustainable and outside the Court's jurisdiction.

THE ELECTORAL COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(BLOEMFONTEIN)
Not Reportable

Case No: 0023/26EC

In the matter between:

REV DANZEL P VAN RENSBURG/POSE APPLICANT

and

ELECTORAL COMMISSION OF SOUTH AFRICA FIRST RESPONDENT
IEC EASTERN CAPE PROVINCIAL OFFICE SECOND RESPONDENT
IEC NATIONAL OFFICE THIRD RESPONDENT
SOUTH AFRICAN POLICE SERVICE (SAPS)
ROBERT SOBUKWE STATION FOURTH RESPONDENT
STATION COMMANDER ROBERT
SOBUKWE STATION COLONNEL SOOI FIFTH RESPONDENT
MARLON CALVINE OORMEYER SIXTH RESPONDENT

Neutral Citation: Rev Danzel P van Rensburg/Pose v Electoral
Commission of South Africa and Others (Case no
0023/26 EC) [2026] ZAEC 15 (03 November 2026)
Coram: ZONDI DP and STEYN and MANGCU-LOCKWOOD AJJ
Heard: 22 October 2026
Delivered: This judgment was handed down electronically by
circulation to the parties’ representatives by email, publication on the Electoral
Court of South Africa website and release to SAFLII. The date and time for
hand-down of the judgment is deemed to be 11h00 on 03 November 2026

2
Summary: Electoral Law – local government elections – objection
regarding a ward candidate standing in a local election – Schedule 3 of the
Electoral Act 73 of 1998 does not provide for objections to electoral candidacy
– seeking factual and procedural clarification on candidate employment
status.

3
______________________________________________________________

ORDER
______________________________________________________________

1 The application is dismissed.
2 There is no costs order.
______________________________________________________________

JUDGMENT
______________________________________________________________

Steyn AJ (Zondi DP and Mangcu-Lockwood AJ concurring):
Introduction
[1] The applicant, Rev van Rensburg, approaches this Court for an order
to obtain , inter alia , information concerning the candidacy of the sixth
respondent, Marlon C alvine Oormeyer (Mr Oormeyer). He also seeks factual
and procedural clarification as to whether Mr Oormeyer may have committed
a p olicy or statutory contravention . The alleged misconduct relates to Mr
Oormeyer’s candidacy as a ward candidate in the intended municipal
elections. The notice of motion is not a model of clarity, but I am mindful that
the applicant is bringing the application in person.

[2] Mr Oormeyer is nominated as a ward candidate in the local upcoming
elections for the African National Congress (the ANC). He has been
nominated for a position in the Dr Beyers Naud é Local Municipality (the DBN-
Municipality). The application is opposed by the first to third respondents.

[3] The members of this Court, having considered the papers filed in the
application and all the issues raised by the parties, decided to dispose of the
matter on the papers without hearing oral arguments. This decision accords
with the directives issued by the Registrar.

Factual Background
[4] The applicant avers that he is the founder/representative of Protect
Organise and Support Empower ( POSE). He brings the application in the

4
public interest, concer ning the integrity, transparency, and procedural
correctness of the pending elections . His complaint relates to a candidate, Mr
Oormeyer, who is a candidate in the DBN-Municipality, more specifically Ward
7. The relief sought by the applicant at times contradicts the averments made
by him in the founding affidavit but not much turns on it, and it is unnecessary
for purposes of this judgment to repeat these contradictions.

[5] At the outset , it is necessary to emphasise that the statutory duties of
this Court are defined in s 20 of the Electoral Commission Act 51 of 1996 (the
ECA) read with various sections of our Constitution. 1 This Court remains a
specialist tribunal responsible for electoral justice in South Africa. When the
entire affidavit filed by the applicant is , however, analysed, then he seeks
guidance on policies and rules not relevant to electoral justice but to labour-
related matters.

Legal Framework
[6] Section 158 of the Constitution2 provides:
‘Membership of Municipal Councils
(1) Every citiz en who is qualified to vote for a Municipal Council is eligible to be a
member of that Council, except-
(a) anyone who is appointed by, or is in the service of, the municipality and receives
remuneration for that appointment or service , and who has not been exempted from
this disqualification in terms of national legislation;
(b) anyone who is appointed by, or is in the service of, the state in another sphere,
and receives remuneration for that appointment or service, and who has been
disqualified from membership of a Municipal Council in terms of national legislation;
(c) anyone who is disqualified from voting for the National Assembly or is disqualified
in terms of section 47(1)(c), (d) or (e) from being a member of the Assembly;
(d) a member of the National Assembly, a delegate to the National Council of
Provinces or a member of a provincial legislature; but this disqualification does not

Provinces or a member of a provincial legislature; but this disqualification does not
apply to a member of a Municipal Council representing local government in the
National Council; or

1 See inter alia ss 19, 165 and 190 which form the constitutional core of this Court’s functions.
2 The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996.

5
(e) a member of another Municipal Council; but this disqualification does not apply to
a member of a Municipal Council representing that Council in another Municipal
Council of a different category;
(2) A person who is not eligible to be a member of a Municipal Council in terms of
subsection (1)(a), (b), (d) or (e) may be a candidate for the Council, subject to any
limits or conditions established by national legislation.
(3) Vacancies in a Municipal Council must be filled in terms of national legislation.’
(Emphasis added.)

[7] The Public Service Act 103 of 1994 (the PSA) regulates the
organisation and administration of the public service and the conditions of
employment of members of that public service. Accordingly, s 36 of the PSA
is central to the enquiry before this Court. The provision reads:
‘Employees as candidates for, and becoming members of, legislatures
(1) An employee may be a candidate for election as a member of the National
Assembly, a provincial legislature or a Municipal Council, subject to the code of
conduct contemplated in section 41(1) (b)(v) and any other prescribed limits and
conditions.
(2) An employee elected as a member of the National Assembly or a provincial
legislature or a full -time member of a Municipal Council shall be deemed to have
resigned from the public service with effect from the date immediately before the
date, he or she assumes office as such member.
(3) An employee appointed as a permanent delegate of the National Council of
Provinces shall be deemed to have resigned from the public se rvice with effect from
the date immediately before the date, he or she assumes office as such delegate.
(4) An employee elected as a member of a Municipal Council-
(a) may only remain an employee in the public service if he or she serves as a part -
time member of the Council; and
(b) shall comply with section 30(1).’

[8] I turn now to the legislation that specifically regulates the activities of

[8] I turn now to the legislation that specifically regulates the activities of
the South African Police Service ( SAPS) employees. Section 46 of the South
African Police Service Act 68 of 1995 (the SAPSA) governs the political
activities of SAPS members. It reads as follows:
‘Political activities of members
(1) No member shall-

6
(a) publicly display or express support for or associate himself or herself with a political
party, organisation, movement or body;
(b) hold any post or office in a political party, organisation, movement or body;
(c) wear any insignia or identification mark in respect of any political party,
organisation, movement or body; or
(d) in any other manner further or prejudice party-political interests.
(2) Subsection (1) shall not be construed as prohibiting a member from-
(a) joining a political party, organisation, movement or body of his or her choice;
(b) attending a meeting of a political party, organisation, movement or body : Provided
that no member shall attend such a meeting in uniform; or
(c) exercising his or her right to vote.’

[9] What is apparent from the section is that it does not expressly prohibit
a SAPS member from being nominated as a candidate in a municipal election.
Whether the nomination of a candidate constitutes conduct prohibited by s 46
of the SAPSA need not be decided in this matter. Any breach of that section is
primarily a matter between the individual SAPS member and SAPS as the
employer. It is also not a matter that the Electoral Commission of South Africa
(the Commission) is empowered to determine when it certifies the candidates.

[10] This brings me to s 21 of the Local Government: Municipal Structures
Act 117 of 1998, which provides:
‘Qualifications for councillors
(1) Every citizen who is qualified to vote for a particular municipal council has the
right-
(a) to stand as a candidate in an election for that council, except a person disqualified
in terms of section 158(1)(c) of the Constitution; and
(b) if elected, to become and remain a councillor, except a person disqualified in
terms of section 158(1)(a), (c), (d) or (e) of the Constitution.’

[11] A plain reading of the section suggests that any person may be entitled
to stand for election, even though, if elected, he or she would need to remove

to stand for election, even though, if elected, he or she would need to remove
any disqualification before assuming office. In my view, the provision has to
be considered through a constitutional lens, specifically s 158 of the
Constitution. This section supports the notion that state employees are not

7
automatically barred from candidacy in local government elections; once
elected, restrictions may arise regarding their ability to serve as councillors.

[12] The Commission’s central argument before us is that it has neither a
statutory duty nor the power to investigate a candidate’s employment status or
compliance with obligations owed to an employer before certifying a candidate
for election. The responsibility for ensuring the eligibility of a candidate rests
with the nominating party and the candidate, who must submit to the
prescribed statutory declaration. The prescribed declaration , however, does
not require disclosure of employment status. The Commission further explains
that this approach is practical and necessary , given that in the relevant
election cycle, over 142,000 candidates were nominated for proportional
representation and ward elections.

[13] The election timetable in the Local Government: Municipal Electoral
Act 27 of 2000 (the MEA) contains no procedure for objections to candidates
before certification. 3 Schedule 3 to the MEA contains no procedure for the
lodging and determination by the Commission of objections relating to the
eligibility of ward candidates before their certification. Once the Commission
certifies candidates in terms of the MEA, any challenge to their eligibility must
ordinarily be pursued through appropriate court proceedings . A person
seeking such a challenge must therefore approach the court promptly, within
three days after the certification.

[14] The Commission submitted in its heads of argument that whether Mr
Oormeyer breached his obligations as an employee of SAPS, if he is so
employed, is not a question falling within the Commission ’s obligations. That
issue remains to be an issue between the employee and the employer. The
Commission further notes , quite rightly in my view , that th is Court need not
decide whether s 46 of the SAPSA prohibits a SAPS member from accepting

decide whether s 46 of the SAPSA prohibits a SAPS member from accepting
nomination as a candidate , since that issue is not directly before th is Court.
The reason for this is that the applicant did not seek to set aside the

3 See Schedule 3 of the Municipal Electoral Act, no provision is made for an objection to be
lodged against candidates for the local elections.

8
nomination of Mr Oormeyer . Any determination on that question would
therefore be academic and should be left for a future case.

[15] Accordingly, having considered all submissions from all parties, I am
satisfied that the applicant’s complaint before this Court is unsustainable . An
analysis of the relief sought by the applicant shows that he is not seeking a
review of any decision taken by the Commission, nor is he challenging the
candidacy of Mr Oormeyer. I find no electoral dispute raised by the applicant.
Effectively, he is seeking legal advice on the interaction between employment
law and the electoral law. T his Court does not provide legal guidance on
matters falling outside its jurisdiction.

[16] This brings me to the issue of costs. In general, this Court does not
order an unsuccessful party to pay costs , and there is no reason to deviate
from this rule. The respondents also do not seek a costs order against the
applicant.

Order
[17] The following order is issued:
1 The application is dismissed.
2 There is no costs order.


______________________
EJS STEYN
Acting Judge of the Electoral Court

9
Appearances:
For the appellants: Rev Danzel P van Rensburg
Instructed by: In person

For the first, second and
third respondents: Adv De Beer
Instructed by: Eversheds Sutherland (SA) Inc.,
Johannesburg
Honey Attorneys, Bloemfontein