Mahlatsi and Others v Member of the Executive Council: Department of Education and Others (4442/2025) [2026] ZAFSHC 494 (30 October 2026)

40 Reportability
Administrative Law

Brief Summary

Review — Appointment of principal — Locus standi — Applicants, as members of the School Governing Body, sought to review the appointment of the eighth respondent as principal of ltokisetseng Combined Farm School, alleging unlawful processes in the appointment. Respondents challenged the applicants' standing, asserting that they lacked a resolution from the SGB to institute proceedings. Court found that the applicants failed to establish locus standi as they did not provide evidence of authorization to act on behalf of the SGB. Application dismissed with costs.

1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
FREE ST A TE DIVISION, BLOEMFONTEIN
In the matter between
MOLIFI ZACHARIA MAHLA TSI
TSIE EZELIEL MOFOKENG
LOBIS MOLEFE
and
THE MEC: DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
HEAD OF DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
DISTRICT DIRECTOR, DoE LEJWELEPUTSWA
RAMONTSHI RAKOATA
DIMAKA TSO DINAH MAHOKO
NYAKALLO LILIAN ZONKE
MODIEHI SOPHIA TSHABALALA
NYAMEKO VICTOR PELE
REGINA MAMIMI RADEBE
Not reportable
Case no: 4442/2025
FIRST APPLICANT
SECOND RESPONDENT
THIRD RESPONDENT
FIRST RESPONDENT
SCOND RESPONDENT
THIRD RESPONDENT
FOURTH RESPONDENT
FIFTH RESPONDENT
SIXTH RESPONDENT
SEVENTH RESPONDENT
EIGHT RESPONDENT
NINETH RESPONDENT
Neutral citation: Mahlatsi and Others v The Member of the Executive Council:
Department of Education and Others (4442/2025) [2026) ZAFSHC 494 (30 October
2026)

Coram: DANISO et GREYLING COETZER JJ
Heard: 8 June 2026
Delivered: This judgment was handed down electronically by circulation to the
parties' representatives by email and released to SAFLII. The date and time for hand­
down is deemed to be 14h00 on 30 October 2026.
2
Summary: Review of appointment of principal - locus standi - standing not
established - principles restated.

3
ORDER
1 The application for the review and setting aside the process of election,
recommendation and appointment of the eighth respondent as the principal of the school,
ltokisetseng Combined Farm School in Moedersorg Plaas, Wesselbron is dismissed.
2 The applicants shall pay the costs jointly and severally one paying the other to be
absolved which shall include the costs of counsel on scale B.
JUDGMENT
Daniso, J (Greyling-Coetzer concurring)
[1] In these opposed review proceedings (PART B), the applicants as members of
the School Governing Body ('the SGB') of the school, ltokisetseng Combined Farm
School (the ltokisetseng School) situated at Moedersorg Plaas in Wesselbron seek an
order for the review and setting aside the appointment of the eighth respondent (Mr Pele)
as the principal of the ltokisetseng School {the review application). The appointment was
made with effect August 2025.
[2] The application is directed at the first respondent as the member of the Executive
Committee of Education (the MEC), the second respondent as the Head of Department
(HOD), the third respondent as the District Director of the Free State Department of
Education, Mr Pele, the eighth respondent and the ninth respondent as the former acting
principal and it is premised on the grounds that the processes leading up to his
appointment namely, the shortlisting, interviews and the appointment were unlawful and
inconsistent with the provisions of paragraphs 4.5 and 4.1.2 of the Collective Agreement
1 of 2019 and paragraph B.S.4.5 of the Personnel Administrative Measures No.46879.
[3] No order is sought against the fourth, fifth, sixth, and the seventh respondents.
The application is opposed by the first, second and third respondents, hereinafter

4
collectively referred to as respondents.
[4] The application follows the urgent application launched by the applicants under
PART A on 25 August 2025 for an interim interdict to restrain the second respondent from
appointing Mr Pele pending the outcome of the review application. The applicants have
since abandoned the urgent application contending that the urgency has been overtaken
by events as Mr Pele has already assumed his duties.
[5 In addition to opposing the application on the merits, the respondents have raised
a point of law as predicated in Uniform Rule 6(5)(d)(iii) challenging the applicants' locus
standi to bring these proceedings.
[6] Taking into account that the upholding of the respondents' objection to the
applicants' locus standi would be dispositive of the matter, we directed that the issue be
heard separately from the merits of the application.
[7] It is the respondent's case that ltokisetseng School is a juristic person, and
together with the SGB, which comprises of 11 members, constitutes an organ of state. In
this matter, except to allege in their founding affidavit (para 81} that these proceedings
arise from a decision taken by the parent component of the SGB on 19 August 2025, the
applicants have provided no resolution authorizing them to institute these proceedings on
behalf of the SGB. The respondents contend that absent a resolution, the mandate or
proof that they have been authorized by the SGB as a collective to institute these
proceedings, the applicants have no legal standing to act on behalf of the SGS. The
application ought to be dismissed on this score.
[8] In response to the respondents' objection, the applicants filed supplementary
heads of argument contending that there is no merit to the respondent's objection, it
must be dismissed with costs on a punitive scale.
[9] It is the applicants' submission that these proceedings have been brought by the
applicants in their official capacities as individual members of the SGB. At no stage have

applicants in their official capacities as individual members of the SGB. At no stage have
they claimed to be authorized by a resolution of the SGB. The applicants do not purport
to claim any relief on behalf of the school because in terms of s 38 of the Constitution,

5
they are permitted to act in their own interest and/or as a member of members of the SGB
to approach a competent court alleging that unlawful conduct by some of the members
affecting the rights of the SGB, that is inconsistent with the law, has occurred. They do
not require a resolution of the SGB for the court to assess the merits of the review
application and the lawfulness of the impugned processes.
[1 OJ The doctrine of locus standi concerns the sufficiency and directness of a person's
interest in litigation to qualify as a litigating party. It is for the applicants to allege and
prove their locus standi on the founding papers, 1 it was also pointed out in Four Wheel
Drive Accessory Distributors CC v Rattan N02 that the interest must not be too remote. It
must be actual, not abstract or academic and it must be a current interest and not a
hypothetical one; that includes the Constitutional standing where averred.3
[11] Ex facie the applicants' founding papers, except to aver that they are members of
the SGB, it is evident that the circumstances under which the applicants assert their
interest in the relief they seek have not been pleaded and proven. There is no evidence
that they have been formally authorized to act on behalf of the SGB through a written
resolution.
[12] The applicant's belated reliance on s 38 of the Constitution read with the Promotion
of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 in their heads of argument does not assist the
applicants' case. Arguments are not intended to introduce new factual or legal issues but
to summarize, interpret and apply the law to the evidence already presented. The law is
trite on this aspect.4
[13] Having regard to the facts of this matter, we are not persuaded that the applicants'
locus standi to institute these proceedings has been established. The application stands
to fail on that basis.
1 Kommissaris van Binnelandse lnkomste v Van Der Heever 1999 (3) SA 1051 (SCA) para 10.

1 Kommissaris van Binnelandse lnkomste v Van Der Heever 1999 (3) SA 1051 (SCA) para 10.
2 Four Wheel Drive Accessory Distributors CC v Rattan NO [2018) ZASCA 124; 2019 (3) AS 451 (SCA) para 7.
3 Ferreira v Levin NO And Others; Vryenhoek And Others v Powell NO And Others 1996 (1) SA 984 (CC) at 986A­
C.
4 Director of Public Prosecutions, Johannesburg and Another v Schultz and Others; Director of Public
Prosecutions, Bloemfontein v Cholota [2026] ZACC 3; 2026 (3) BCLR 175 (CC) para 30.

Costs
[14] There is no reason why the costs should not follow the results. In the premises,
the following order is made:
Order
6
1 The application for the review and setting aside the process of election,
recommendation and appointment of the eight respondent as the principal of the school,
ltokisetseng Combined Farm School in Moedersorg Plaas, Wesselbron is dismissed.
2 The applicants shall pay the costs jointly and severally one paying the other to be
absolved which shall include the costs of counsel on scale B.
I concur
----=�--\�bAtill50
JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT
JUDGE OF TH

Appearances
For the applicants:
Instructed by:
For the respondents:
Instructed by:
L Mfazi with A Mashile
Mlozana Attorneys INC
Bloemfontein
K Motholo
Office of the State Attorney
Bloemfontein
7