SAFLII Note: Certain personal/private details of parties or witnesses have been redacted from this document
in compliance with the law and SAFLII Policy
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
FREE STATE DIVISION, BLOEMFONTEIN
Not reportable
Case no: 2861/2025
In the matter between:
T[…] S[…] PLAINTIFF
and
ROAD ACCIDENT FUND DEFENDANT
Neutral citation: S[…] v Road Accident Fund ( 2861/2025) ZAFSHC 492 (29 October
2026)
Coram: CHESIWE J
Heard: 10- 11 February 2026 and 12- 15 May 2026
Delivered: This judgment was handed down electronically by circulation to the
parties’ representatives by email and released to SAFLII. The date and time for hand- down
is deemed to be 09h30 on 29 October 2026.
Summary: Road Accident Fund – damages – quantum – personal injury – loss
of past and future earning capacity – minor pedestrian – mild traumatic brain injury –
cognitive and behavioural sequelae – future employability – applicable contingency
deductions – actuarial calculations – uncontested expert evidence – rule 38(2) – past l oss
of income.
2
ORDER
The draft order marked ‘X’ dated 2 9 October 2026 as amended and signed, is made an
order of court.
JUDGMENT
Chesiwe J
Introduction
[1] The plaintiff has instituted a claim against the d efendant for damages he suffered
from a motor vehicle collision on 1 April 2012. The accident occurred near S Macholo Way,
Thabong, Welkom, Free State Province. The plaintiff was six years old at the time of the
accident and was a pedestrian playing on the side of the road. The collision occurred when
the insured driver, Nkoale Boy Thateng, who was driving a motor vehicle with registration
letters and numbers DMN […], which was pulling a trailer with registration BXD […], hit the
plaintiff and dragged him for a short distance.
[2] The plaintiff avers that the accident was caused by the sole negligence of the
insured driver, who failed to keep a proper lookout; keep the vehicle under control; failed to
pay due regard to the safety of other road users particularly the plaintiff and failed to apply
the brakes. After the collision, the plaintiff sustained severe bodily injuries as follows: m ild
traumatic brain injury and multiple bodily injuries. The defendant denied the allegations in
its plea and pleaded that the plaintiff was negligent and that such negligence was the
cause of the collision.
[3] The matter was set down for 10 , 11 and 13 February 2026. It was stood down to 11
February 2026 on 10 February 2026. On 11 February, it was postponed to 1 2, 13 and 15
May 2026 for the amendment of the particulars of claim . Before commencement of trial on
10 February 2026, counsel on behalf of the plaintiff submitted that merits and quantum be
3
separated and the matter proceed on merits only. Further that the plaintiff intended to call
three witnesses. The defendant had no witnesses.
Plaintiff’s oral evidence
[4] The plaintiff testified that: at the time of the accident, he was six (6) years old. The
date of the accident was 1 April 2012 and that h e was playing soccer in the street with
some of his friends. The soccer ball rolled onto the tar road, and he wanted to go and fetch
the ball. As he was about to take hold of the soccer ball, he saw a vehicle approaching
pulling a trailer but was driving very slowly. He realised that he won’t be able to run back to
the sidewalk. He laid down in the middle of the road and positioned himself in such a way
that the vehicle will drive over him without injuring him. While he was under the vehicle, he
felt something pulling him. He cannot recall if it was the vehicle or the trailer that pulled
him. He could not remember what happened thereafter.
[5] Under cross examination, the plaintiff explained that he cannot recall what
happened to his friends whom he was playing soccer with nor does he know what
happened between the time of the accident and when he was taken to hospital. He could
also not recall his admission in hospital. At the hospital, he was only sutured and bandages
were put over the wound. After ten days, he went back to the hospital to remove the
sutures. Plaintiff stated that he is does not have much recollection post the accident.
[6] The plaintiff stated that he reported the accident after nine (9) years as his mother
explained to him that she was pregnant at the time of the accident and could not go to the
police to report the accident. Regarding the insured driver, plaintiff explained that he knew
the insured driver but did not know his name. The plaintiff further stated his attempts to get
information regarding the accident. He was assisted by someone, who gave him a contact
information regarding the accident. He was assisted by someone, who gave him a contact
numbers of the insured driver. He called the insured driver, who gave him his details,
including the registration numbers of the vehicle. That was the plaintiff evidence.
[7] At the close of the plaintiff’s evidence, counsel on behalf of the plaintiff, submitted to
court that considering the plaintiff having the details of the insured driver , it was submitted
that the particulars of claim ought to be amended. The matter was postponed to 12, 13 and
15 May 2026 for purposes of amending the particulars of claim.
4
[8] On 12 May 2026, counsel on behalf of the plaintiff submitted that the merits ha d
been conceded at 100% in favour of the plaintiff’s proven damages. The general damages
were rejected by the defendant as the injuries were regarded as non- serious. Further that,
the general damages had been referred to the Health Professionals Council of South
Africa (HPCSA). The only outstanding issue outstanding was the loss of past and future
income.
[9] An application was filed in terms of r ule 38(2) of the U niform Rules of C ourt. The
application was not opposed by the defendant. The plaintiff sought for the admission of the
experts’ reports by way of affidavits pertaining to the quantum of loss of earnings . The
application was granted with costs in the cause. With the merits having been settled, the
matter was rolled over to 15 May 2026. Both counsels agreed to file their written heads of
argument on or before the 15 May 2026. For determination by this Court is only the loss of
past and future income.
Submissions
[10] Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff, submitted in the written heads of argument that
the plaintiff still attending school at the time of the accident; that he failed Grade 2 and
repeated Grade 10. He has been unemployed as he is still a student. Regarding the
contingencies, counsel submitted that the plaintiff injuries allowed for contingency of 0% for
past loss and 25% for future loss of income taking into consideration the plaintiff age.
Several authorities were referred to regarding contingenc ies for a child at 25% and youth
20% and middle age at 10%.
[11] Counsel on behalf of the defendant submitted in the written heads of argument that
the calculations of the actuary and the experts’ reports are highly exaggerated as the
plaintiff was still able to earn an income post-accident. Further that, the plaintiff was at the
beginning of his school career when the accident occurred and that moreover, there is very
beginning of his school career when the accident occurred and that moreover, there is very
little evidence on the plaintiff’s school performance prior to the accident. Counsel proposes
that for uninjured earnings, the appropriate contingency be 25% and injured be 27%. She
also referred to case law in which the court addressed the reports of experts ’ witnesses
where the evidence of the expert is not objective.
5
Plaintiff’s experts’ reports
[12] Dr Seroto, a specialist neurosurgeon, opines in his report that the plaintiff suffered a
mild traumatic brain injury and that the injury suffered will not affect his life expectancy
unless he suffers from late post traumatic epilepsy. Further t hat, the plaintiff he has
memory impairment . L oss of income was deferred to the industrial psychologist and
academic performance deferred to the educational psychologist.
[13] Me Lindelwa Grootboom, clinical psychologist, stated in her report that, b ased on
perused school reports, scholastic difficulties were indicated for grade 1 and 2 prior to the
accident, suggesting a possible premorbid learning vulnerability . Further that the plaintiff’s
performance on p icture completion, which is regard ed as ‘hold the test’, was also a low
average. A low average premorbid functioning was postulated, and the final opinion was
deferred to the educational expert.
[14] Mr Zenzele Kubheka, educational psychologist in his report stated the importance of
noting the plaintiff’s failure of grade 10 and having to repeat the grade, this being indicative
of the effects of the accident. The accident altered his academic and career milestones by
a year so far. This factor the expert opines, should be seriously considered when
reimbursing him . From an academic perspective and within the context of his cognitive,
and neuropsychological challenges, the expert further opines that the plaintiff’s future
academic progression and career prospects would be curtailed. In c onsidering the
plaintiff’s latest school results (2024) and the lenient education system, the plaintiff would
probably manage to pass g rade 12 and will probably reach his academic ceiling at an
equivalent of NQF level 5.
[15] Mr Talent Mature, industrial psychologist, stated in his report as follows:
‘… in his injured state, Mr S[ …]’s career prospects have been significantly compromised, with the
current unemployment rate of approximately 32,1%, the accident has significantly narrowed Mr
S[…]’s employability in the open labour market . Employers will prefer able-bodied and competent
employees; they are unlikely to be accommodative as there are many unemployed able-bodied and
educated individuals in the labour market. He is likely to experience difficulties securing and
sustaining employment in his injured.’
6
Regarding loss of income, Mr Mature reports that the plaintiff was six years old at the time
of the accident and doing Grade 2 hence there would not be any past loss of earning.
[16] Me Catherine Motake, occupational therapists, concludes that the plaintiff has P ost
Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) which will negatively affect his ability to form
interpersonal relationship at work and may result in job loss. Moreover, he will require a
sympathetic employer to accommodate the memory loss and the headaches.
[17] The plaintiff’s appointed Munro Forensic Actuaries in its report calculated the loss of
earnings as follows: past loss at R26 885 (twenty-six thousand eight hundred eighty -five
rand) and future loss at R5 551 700 (five million five hundred fifty -one thousand seven
hundred rand) with a total amount of R5 578 585 (five million five hundred seventy -eight
thousand five hundred eighty -five rand) with a contingency at 5% and 15% respectively
(uninjured) and 25% on future earnings (injured).
[18] The plaintiff’s contention is that his evidence has proven on the balance of
probabilities that he has established a claim for loss of earnings and that the actuarial
calculations are acceptable and that the court ought to rely on these calculations . The
defendant did not file any actuarial report for the court ’s consideration but contends that
the plaintiff did not discharge the onus of proving on a balance of probabilities t hat he is
vulnerable in the labour market and that the plaintiff’s submitted calculations are highly
exaggerated. The defendant did not file any expert reports nor were there any joint
minutes. The reports of the plaintiff therefore stand uncontested , including the report of the
actuary.
Loss of earnings
[19] In South Insurance Association Ltd v Bailey N.O 1 (Bailey), Nicholas JA said the
following: ‘Any enquiry into damages for loss of earning capacity is of its nature speculative,
because it involves a prediction as to the future, without the benefit of crystal balls, soothsayers,
augurs or oracles.’
[20] An enquiry into damages for earning capacity is of its nature speculative, because it
involves a prediction as to the future. All that the Court can do, is to make an estimate,
1 South Insurance Association Ltd v Bailey NO 1984 (1) SA 98 (A) at 99 A.
7
which is often a very rough estimate of the present value of the loss. 2 Based on the above,
as well as the views expressed by the experts which were largely common cause, the
pertinent question is what award would be fair and adequate compensation for the p laintiff
in respect of future loss of earnings or capacity to earn?
[21] In Sandler v Wholesale Coal Suppliers Ltd, 3 it was stated that it is no doubt
exceedingly difficult to value damage in terms of money, but that does not relieve the court
of the duty of doing so upon evidence placed before it. This is a principle which has been
acted on in several cases in South African c ourts. In Rudman v Road Accident Fund, 4 the
court said: ‘[t]here must be proof that the reduction in earning capacity indeed gives rise to
pecuniary loss. ’ It is now accepted that in the assessment of these kinds of damages,
which cannot be assessed with any amount of mathematical accuracy, and c ourts have a
wide discretion.5
[22] In Bailey, Nicolas JA said:
‘In a case where the court has before it material on which an actual calculation can usefully be
made, I do not think that the first approach often any advantages over the second. On the contrary,
while the result of an actuarial computation may be no more than an “informed guess ”, it has the
advantage of an attempt to ascertain the value of what was lost on a logical basis; whereas the trial
judge’s “gut feeling” . . . as to what is fair and reasonable is nothing more than a blind guess.’
[23] The court must in any event make an informed judgment on future losses, even if it
is speculative. 6 In the present matter, the plaintiff’s loss of income was calculated by
Munro Forensic Actuaries. The submission places the loss of earning capacity at 5% and
15% contingencies respectively with inured at 25%. The report of industrial psychologist in
respect of the loss of earnings states that the plaintiff reported the age six and in Grade 2
respect of the loss of earnings states that the plaintiff reported the age six and in Grade 2
scholar at the time of the accident hence there are no past losses of earnings. The
defendant also raised issue with past loss of earnings as the plaintiff was at the beginning
of his school career and could therefore not have suffered any past loss of income.
2 Ibid at 113G.
3 Sandler v Wholesale Coal Suppliers Ltd 1941 AD 194 at 198.
4 Rudman v Road Accident Fund [2002] ZASCA 129; [2002] 4 All SA 422 (SCA); 2003 (2) SA 234 (SCA)
para 11.
5 See AA Mutual Insurance Association Ltd v Maqula 1978 (1) SA 805 (A) at 809A-B.
6 Anthony and Another v Cape Town Municipality 1967 (4) SA 445 (A) at 446B.
8
[24] I am inclined to agree with the defendant that the plaintiff suffered no loss of past
income and must therefore consider the plaintiff’s future loss of income, also taking into
consideration the plaintiff age up to retirement , including the applicable contingency. What
must be borne in mind, is that contingencies are in the court’s discretion. For purposes of
easy mathematical calculations on the different expert reports as well as information
received from the plaintiff, if actuarial calculations are impossible, the court nevertheless
determines the plaintiff’s loss of earning capacity arithmetically based on estimation but not
proved earnings. Except for the one page submitted by the defendant’s counsel that
contingency on future loss be calculated at 27%, the court has no expert calculations from
the defendant’s side . On the other hand, counsel for the plaintiff proposed a 25%
contingency, taking into consideration the plaintiff’s age.
[25] According to the occupational therapists, the plaintiff has a memory problem that will
affect his ability to learn new skills along with headaches that will affect his productivity at
work. However, none of the experts reports specifically states that the plaintiff is totally
unemployable, except that he will have to compete with able- bodied peers in the labour
market. In spite of the injuries sustained by the plaintiff, he was able to complete grade 12,
even though he repeated grade 2 and 10. His school reports, as attached to the experts’
reports, indicate that he had average learning potential and his academic performance
indicated a learning difficulty.
[26] The court takes cognisance of the fact that the plaintiff is severely compromised due
to the accident. From the expert s’ reports, it is not stated unequivocally that he would not
be capable to do any work in the future however, according to the educational
psychologist, his aspiration to study towards a sound engineer career or related
psychologist, his aspiration to study towards a sound engineer career or related
qualifications may not be realised . The plaintiff has had to redirect his aspirations to study
towards a Bachelor of Education at NQF Level 7 . Even though he will compete with able
bodies persons, the careers path does not result in him being totally unemployable.
[27] Therefore, taking into consideration the expert s’ reports, in my view there is a
possibility that p laintiff may post morbid find employment if he completes the Bachelor of
Education Degree.
9
[28] It is now well settled that contingencies, whether negative or positive are an
important control mechanism to adjust the loss suffered to the circumstances of the
individual case to achieve equity and fairness to both parties. There is no hard and fast
rule regarding contingency allowances. For purposes of easy mathematical calculations,
the actuary based the calculations on the different expert s’ reports as well as information
as received from the plaintiff. A contingency of 5% and 15% was applied respectively.
Indeed, it is so that the court must make a calculation that is fair and just for both parties.
Moreover, the defendant did not file an actuarial report to dispute the plaintiff’s calculation.
Thus, the plaintiff calculations stand uncontested.
[29] In aligning myself with finding of the court in the matter of Road Accident Fund v
Reynolds,7 the court said:
‘Thus, allowing for contingencies is one of the elements in exercising the discretion to award
damages’
[30] It was said in Masemola v Road Accident Fund,8 that:
‘It is now settled that contingencies, whether negative or positive, are an important control
mechanism to adjust the loss suffered to the circumstances of the individual case in order to
achieve equity and fairness to both parties. There is no hard and fast rule regarding contingency
allowances.’
[31] Thus, the applicable and appropriate contingencies would be fair at 2 5% for the
future loss of earning, b ased on the plaintiff’s age as calculated by the actuaries .
Regarding the past loss of income, it is unclear where t he calculated R26 885 (twenty-six
thousand eight hundred eighty -five rand) was derived from, as the plaintiff was a scholar
and has suffered no loss of past income.
[32] Therefore, the plaintiff’s filed draft of order with the calculations according to the
actuary ought to be awarded, excluding the past loss of income.
Order
[33] Accordingly, it is ordered as follows:
Order
[33] Accordingly, it is ordered as follows:
7 Road Accident Fund v Reynolds (A5023/2004) 2006 JDR 0245 (W) 18 February 2005 para 5.
8 Masemola v Road Accident Fund [2023] ZAGPPHC 553; 17336/2017 (2 July 2023) para 41.
10
The draft order marked ‘X’ dated 2 9 October 2026 as amended and signed, is made an
order of court.
______________________
S CHESIWE
JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT
11
Appearances
On behalf of plaintiff: L A Roux
Instructed by: MM Hattingh Inc Attorneys,
Bloemfontein
On behalf of the defendant: M Lephoto
Instructed by: Road Accident Fund,
Bloemfontein.