IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
WESTERN CAPE DIVISION, CAPETOWN
CASE NO: A186/2026
In the matter between
R GALLANT Appellant
And
THE STATE Respondent
Coram: CLOETE J; PETERS AJ
Heard: 30 October 2026
Delivered ex tempore: 30 October 2026
Summary: Criminal Appeal – Single Witness – evidence found not credible to
sustain conviction – conviction set aside – Appeal Succeeds.
JUDGMENT
___________________________________________________________________
Peters AJ (Cloete J concurring):
[1] The appellant, Randall Gallant, was convicted in the Wynberg Regional Court on
1 (one) count of Murder and thereafter sentenced to 15 (fifteen) years imprisonment.
He now appeals against both the conviction and the sentence.
[2] In convicting the appellant, the learned Regional Magistrate only had the
evidence of Eileen Jacobs, mother of the deceased, to rely on. She testified that she
knows the appellant for about 30 years. She knows him by the nickname "Robot". He
stays around the corner from her. On Sunday afternoon, 6/8/2023, she and her
boyfriend, Peter, were planning to go to a confirmation party. She went to her
neighbour (Miriam), opposite the road, to get a pedicure. She saw the appellant, with
his friends, standing on the corner. Mariam was just about to finish her toenails,
when Peter shouted, informing her that their transport was on the way. As she was
walking across the road to her house, she looked down the street and again saw the
appellant standing on the corner, with his friends, about 30 (thirty) metres away from
her. His arms were stretched out in front of him and he was holding a "black thing",
resembling a firearm, in his hands. Several gunshots (3 to 4) went off and she was
pulled into the house by Peter. After the gunshots had subsided, she heard people
shouting her son's name. When she went out she saw her son laying in the street
with a gunshot to his head.
[3] The appellant was the only witness who testified in his defence. He confirmed
that he goes by the nickname of Robot. He testified that in the afternoon in question,
he was standing on the corner, as testified to by Ms Jacobs. He was in the presence
of two other gentlemen. They however left and he remained standing on the corner
alone. He then saw two male persons, a tall one (with a firearm in hand) and a short
one, walking in the road close to Ms Jacobs' house. The taller of the two walked
towards the opposite corner, where another male person was standing. The two of
them then got into a gunfire exchange, shooting at each other. The tall and the short
persons ran away. The one with whom the tall person had the gunfire exchange,
came towards him and fired a shot at him. He ran away.
[4] In convicting the appellant, the learned Regional Magistrate correctly made
mention of the fact that Ms Jacobs was a single witness and that her evidence had to
be approached with caution. In his assessment of the evidence, the Regional
Magistrate found that although there were certain contradictions between her
evidence in court and her sworn statement, her evidence could not be rejected,
because the contradictions were not material. He further endeavoured to explain
away the contradictions with reference to the decision of S v Mafaladiso en Andere 1.
He also found that, although Ms Jacobs was subjected to extensive cross -
examination, she was able to answer all questions without hesitation and was able to
explain herself. He found that "She explained that she saw that it was the appellant
with a firearm and he was shooting." I cannot agree with that assessment.
[5] Regarding the evidence of the appellant, the learned Regional Magistrate
makes mention of the fact his version needs only to be reasonably possibly true. He
then states that it amounted to a bare denial of the allegations and that the appellant
did not deny that he was at the scene of the shooting. Based on that, he then finds
that notwithstanding the fact that Ms Jacobs did not specifically say that the
appellant fired shots at her son, she did see him with a firearm, leading to the only
inference that the appellant was the one who fired the shots that killed the deceased.
[6] As indicated already, Ms Jacobs was a single witness in respect of the killing of
[6] As indicated already, Ms Jacobs was a single witness in respect of the killing of
her son. In terms of the provisions of section 208 of a Criminal Procedure Act, 51 of
1997, an appellant person can be convicted of any offence on the single evidence of
a competent witness. Such evidence should however be approached with caution.
1 2003(1) SACR 583 (SCA).
The application of the cautionary rule was set out in S v Sauls and Others 1981(3)
SA 172 (A) at 180E-G2 as follows:
"There is no rule of thumb test or formula to apply when it comes to a consideration
of the credibility of a single witness (see the remarks of Rumpff JA in S v Webber...).
The trial judge will weigh the evidence, will consider its merits and demerits and,
having done so, will decide whether it is trustworthy and whether, despite the fact
that there are shortcomings or defects or contradictions in the testimony, he is
satisfied that the truth has been told. The cautionary rule referred to by De Villiers JP
in 1932 [in R v Mokoena 1932 OPD 79 at 80] may be a guide to a right decision but it
does not mean ‘that an appeal must succeed if any criticism, however slender, of the
witnesses' evidence were well founded’ (per Schreiner JA in R v Nhlapo (AD 10
November 1952) quoted in R v Bellingham 1955 (2) SA566 (A) at 569.) It has been
said more than once that the exercise of caution must not be allowed to displace the
exercise of common sense."
[7] As will be indicated below, the judgment of the Regional Magistrate did not take
into account all the evidence led during the trial. Factual findings were made in
favour of the credibility of the state witness, without them being fully motivated. On
the other hand factual findings were made against the credibility of the appellant
without reasons being advanced. Regrettably t he Regional Magistrate paid lip
service to the cautionary rule pertaining to the evidence of a single witness and the
onus of rebuttal.
[8] The finding by the Regional Magistrate that contradictions in the evidence of the
state witness were not material, cannot be agreed with. The contradictions were
between her evidence during the trial and her sworn statement. It further related to
the contradictions between her evidence in chief and during cross -examination.
These contradictions related to the circumstances under which the events unfolded,
These contradictions related to the circumstances under which the events unfolded,
that led to the killing of the deceased.
[9] As indicated above, the Regional Magistrate tried to explain away the
contradictions between the state witness' evidence during the trial and her sworn
2 1981(3) SA 172 (A) at 180E-G.
statement, with reference to the decision of S v Mafaladiso (supra). He did not
explain why and how that decision finds application to the contradictions at hand. (As
a reminder, it was stated in S v Mafaladiso that the mere fact that there were self -
contradictions, must be approached with caution. It must, firstly, be ascertained what
the witness actually intended to say in order to determine whether there was a
contradiction and what the extent of it was. It must, secondly, be remembered that
not every contradiction by the witness affects his/her credibility. Thirdly, that the
contradictions must still be considered and evaluated on a holistic basis.)
[10] It should be remembered that the state witness never, in any way, disavowed
the content of her sworn statement. She furthermore offered no credible explanation
for the contradictions. For these reasons the contradictions could not simply be
ignored.
[11] The contradictions are as follows:
(i) In her sworn statement she indicated that when she saw the appellant just before
gunshots went off, he was with only one other person. In court she testified that he
was with a few other males. When confronted with this, during cross-examination,
the witness changed her version, indicating that when she walked over to Miriam she
saw the appellant with a group of his friends and when she later returned she saw
him with only one other person.
(ii) In her sworn statement she indicated that she was crossing the road and she
heard gunshots going off. She looked and saw the appellant with a firearm, shooting.
In her testimony in court, however, she testified that she first saw the appellant
before hearing gunshots going off and she cannot say if the appellant was the
shooter.
(iii) She testified in chief that the black thing that the appellant had in his hands
resembled a gun. On page 23 of the transcribed record the following exchange
between the prosecutor and the witness is found:
"Prosecutor: A black thing?
between the prosecutor and the witness is found:
"Prosecutor: A black thing?
Ms Jacobs: Ja. 'n Gun."
By contrast, during cross -examination, being confronted with the appellant's version
that he was not in possession of a firearm, she testified that she did not see a
firearm, she only saw the appellant with outstretched arms, holding a black item in
his hands. No mention then about the black item resembling a firearm.
(iv) On page 83 of the transcribed record the following exchange is found between
the learned Regional Magistrate and the witness:
"Questions by Court: Were there other people shooting there?
Ms Jacobs: Not that I know of, Your Worship."
By total contrast the following exchange happens on page 78 of the transcript
between the appellant's legal representative and the witness:
"Ms May: He says (the appellant) the two guys, the tall and the short one that went
down the road they were shooting on or towards other guys that was standing on the
other side.
Ms Jacobs: That is what is happening, it was an exchange of shots, Your Worship.
Robot them are firing to the other group and the other group is retaliating and my
child was caught in the middle of that."
(v) As indicated above, the witness intimated in her evidence in chief that the
appellant must have been in possession of a firearm and must have shot and killed
her son. This is however in contrast to her evidence in cross-examination, where she
unequivocally testifies that she never saw the appellant in possession of a firearm
and never saw him shooting.
[12] The Regional Magistrate also did not take into account the fact that the state
witness, by her own admission was in a hurry, when she crossed the road and that
the incident unfolded rapidly. She testified that she was preoccupied by the fact that
the transport had arrived and everything happened fast.
[13] The Regional Magistrate appeared to have not taken into consideration, in his
judgment, the full extent of the appellant's version and the probabilities contained in
judgment, the full extent of the appellant's version and the probabilities contained in
it. The appellant testified that when the exchange of gunshots happened, he was
alone. He denied being in possession of a firearm and firing shots. On a conspectus
of all the evidence , it is reasonably possible that the state witness, being in a hurry
crossing the street, saw the appellant standing on the corner. She, associating the
appellant with gang involvement, and gunshots going off, came to the wrong
conclusion that he must have been the shooter. This will explain the material
contradictions in her evidence, as pointed out above.
[14] The Regional Magistrate failed to give sufficient weight to the contradictions in
the State's case and failed to properly weigh the state witness' evidence against that
of the appellant and against the probabilities.
[15] It follows that t he appeal must succeed and the conviction and sentence set
aside.
[16] I thus propose the following order :
1. The appeal is upheld.
2. The appellant’s conviction and sentence are set aside.
3. Provided that the appellant is not in custody for any other criminal charge or
conviction or sentence, he is to be released immediately.
1 2003(1) SACR 583 (SCA).
2 1981(3) SA 172 (A) at 180E-G.
______________________________
K PETERS
ACTING JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT
I agree and it is so
ordered
______________________________
J CLOETE
JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT
APPEARANCES:
For the appellant : Ms P Andrews, Legal Aid South Africa
For the respondent: Mr T Ntela, Office of the Director Public Prosecutions