Semantis Law Reports

My Library

Lamour v S (Appeal) (A294/2024) [2026] ZAWCHC 426 (19 August 2026)

Criminal Law — Appeal — Rape of minor — Appellant convicted of raping a 10-year-old child and sentenced to life imprisonment — Appeal against conviction and sentence dismissed — Court finding that the trial court's credibility assessments and evidentiary conclusions were sound and supported by medical evidence, with no substantial and compelling circumstances to deviate from the minimum sentence.

Criminal Law
Score: 65

Mothibi v Koshy and Another (CT02631ADJ2026) [2026] COMPTRI 88 (19 August 2026)

Company Law — Removal of director — Application for removal of director under section 71(8)(b) of the Companies Act — Applicant alleging fraudulent misrepresentation, breach of fiduciary duty, and gross misconduct by the First Respondent — Tribunal finding sufficient grounds for removal based on negligence and dereliction of duties — First Respondent ordered to be removed as director of INK ENGINEERING (PTY) LTD.

Company Law
Score: 65

Seick NO and Others v Proud Heritage Properties 60 (Pty) Ltd and Another (2025/064578) [2026] ZAWCHC 427 (19 August 2026)

Company Law — Winding Up — Just and Equitable — Application for provisional liquidation of Proud Heritage Properties 60 (Pty) Ltd due to breakdown in relationship between shareholders — Court exercising discretion under s81(1)(d)(iii) of Companies Act 71 of 2008 — Liquidation granted as company unable to pay debts and circumstances deemed just and equitable.

Company Law
Score: 65

Presiding Officer of the Tribunal and Others v Pretorius (Leave to Appeal) (A04/2026) [2026] ZAWCHC 432 (19 August 2026)

Appeal — Leave to appeal — Jurisdiction — Applicants seeking leave to appeal a judgment of the High Court regarding a decision of the Tribunal under the Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act 130 of 1993 — Court finding it sat as a court of appeal, thus jurisdiction to grant leave to appeal lies with the Supreme Court of Appeal — Application for leave to appeal struck from the roll with costs.

Administrative Law
Score: 60

Silver River Estate (Pty) Ltd v Jackson and Others (380/2026) [2026] ZAWCHC 434 (19 August 2026)

Interdict — Final interdict — Unauthorized wood harvesting — Applicant seeking interdict against respondents for illegal wood harvesting on its property — Respondents lacking authority to harvest wood — Court finding applicant has a clear right to protect its property and income — Interdict granted to prevent further unauthorized activities.

Land and Property Law
Score: 60

MEC for Department of Health North West v Shashape and Another (1105/2016) [2026] ZANWHC 215 (19 August 2026)

Execution — Stay of warrant of execution — Urgent application to stay warrant of execution pending proceedings on disputed taxed items — Applicant alleging double billing in costs from two taxations — Court finding prima facie right established on duplication of items, urgency justified, and granting stay of execution pending resolution of disputes.

Civil Procedure
Score: 55

Mothapo v Mathibedi (Appeal) (HCA30/2025) [2026] ZALMPPHC 82 (19 August 2026)

Appeal — Rescission of judgment — Application for rescission of default judgment granted in motor vehicle accident case — Appellant contending judgment granted by error due to late filing of exception — Court finding no iustus error and dismissing rescission application — Appeal upheld, rescission granted, and matter referred back to court a quo for further proceedings.

Civil Procedure
Score: 55

Motsitle Mining - Vlakfontein Site (Pty) Ltd and Another v Swart Risk Management (Pty) Ltd and Others (2026/142472) [2026] ZANWHC 211 (19 August 2026)

Mining Law — Validity of mining agreement — Applicants seeking declaratory relief that a mining agreement was concluded without authority and is invalid — Respondent opposing on grounds of jurisdiction and authority — Court dismissing points in limine regarding jurisdiction and semi-urgency, finding genuine disputes of fact warranting oral evidence — Final interdict sought to restrain mining operations pending resolution of authority issues.

Mining Law
Score: 55

Trustees for the time being of the Lazarevic Trust v Havenga (2025/044627) [2026] ZAWCHC 425 (19 August 2026)

Non-joinder — Joinder of interested parties — Application for rule nisi issued by court to address non-joinder of residents in estate — Applicant seeking declaration of breach of title deed condition regarding tree height — Court finding necessity for participation of other residents due to shared interests in the outcome — Rule nisi granted to allow interested parties to show cause regarding the relief sought

Civil Procedure
Score: 55

Enquiry: Nkatha; In re S v Shangase and Another (Sentence) (CCD6/2024) [2026] ZAKZDHC 48 (19 August 2026)

Criminal Law — Contempt of court — Sentencing — Accused, a legal practitioner, found in contempt for failing to comply with court orders — Accused representing himself and failing to secure legal representation despite opportunities — Court imposing a sentence of 12 months imprisonment or a fine of R10,000, with part of the sentence suspended — Court emphasizing the need for deterrence and accountability in the legal profession.

Criminal Law
Score: 45

Gatvol Lobby Group NPC v Ngaka Modiri Molema District Municipality and Others (2026/177070) [2026] ZANWHC 212 (19 August 2026)

Administrative Law — Urgent application — Interim interdictory relief — Applicant seeking to suspend alleged resolution removing Acting Municipal Manager — Court finding no resolution existed as appointment lapsed by operation of law — Urgency not established, leading to dismissal of application with costs.

Administrative Law
Score: 45

Kekana v S (Appeal) (A222/2025) [2026] ZAGPPHC 932 (19 August 2026)

Criminal Procedure — Appeal — Incomplete record — Appellant convicted of kidnapping and multiple counts of rape — Appeal against conviction and sentence based on alleged inadequacy of appeal record — Court finding that despite omissions, the record was sufficient for fair adjudication of appeal — Automatic right of appeal under Section 309(1)(a) of the Criminal Procedure Act confirmed — Conviction and sentence upheld.

Criminal Procedure
Score: 45