Semantis Law Reports

My Library

JP Fourie NO and Another v Master of the High Court, Mahikeng and Another (595/2024) [2026] ZASCA 104 (29 July 2026)

Insolvency — Appointment of liquidators — Interpretation of s 18(4) of the Insolvency Act 24 of 1936 — Provisional liquidators appointed by the Master — Creditors failing to attend the first meeting — Court determining that the Master is obliged to appoint provisional liquidators as final liquidators despite creditor non-participation — Appeal upheld and order of the High Court set aside.

Insolvency Law
Score: 70

Spar Group Limited v Velvetcream 7 (Pty) Ltd (in business rescue) and Others (2026-155421) [2026] ZANCHC 73 (29 July 2026)

Companies — Business rescue — Interdictory relief — Applicant seeking urgent interdict to prevent business rescue practitioners from selling first respondent's business without consent — Court finding applicant has established a prima facie right and reasonable apprehension of irreparable harm — Interdict granted pending determination of rights in Part B of the application.

Company Law
Score: 65

NM Imuva Trading (Pty) Ltd v Truck and Finance Corp. (Pty) Ltd (2024/019497) [2026] ZAGPJHC 862 (29 July 2026)

National Credit Act — Section 129 notice — Juristic entity claiming entitlement to notice under Section 129 of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005 — Court finding that no evidence was presented to show compliance with notice requirements — Judgment granted erroneously in breach of statutory requirements — Rescission of judgment ordered as a result of non-compliance with Section 129.

Consumer Protection
Score: 62

Motsie v S (Leave to Appeal) (K/S 18/2022) [2026] ZANCHC 74 (29 July 2026)

Criminal Procedure — Leave to appeal — Application for leave to appeal against conviction and sentence for murder — Applicant convicted under s 51(1) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 105 of 1997 — Court considering whether the appeal has reasonable prospects of success and if there are compelling reasons for the appeal to be heard — Leave to appeal granted to the Supreme Court of Appeal due to compelling reasons identified in the application.

Criminal Procedure
Score: 60

Nilsen Steenkamp & Inc and Another v Coetzee (Appeal) (CIV APP MG33/2024) [2026] ZANWHC 198 (29 July 2026)

Advocacy — Fees — Liability for advocate's fees — Advocate's services rendered on behalf of attorney, not directly to client — Default position that instructing attorney liable for advocate's fees unless expressly agreed otherwise — Appellants disputed liability on grounds of absence of fee provision in mandate — Evidence established tacit agreement for attorney's liability — Appeal dismissed with costs.

Legal Practice
Score: 60

Ex parte: Eagle Canyon Golf Estate Homeowners Association NPC (CT02835ADJ2026) [2026] COMPTRI 77 (29 July 2026)

Companies — Social and Ethics Committee — Exemption from establishment — Applicant, a non-profit homeowners association, seeking exemption from establishing a Social and Ethics Committee as required by section 72 of the Companies Act — Tribunal considering the nature and extent of the Applicant's activities, which are limited to its members — Tribunal granting exemption for five years despite concerns regarding the adequacy of the application and the need for detailed evidence of existing committees' functions.

Company Law
Score: 55

Mogotsi v S (A33/2026) [2026] ZAGPJHC 851 (29 July 2026)

Criminal Procedure — Bail — Appeal against refusal of bail application — Appellant charged with multiple firearm-related offenses and perjury — Alleged new facts presented to support bail application — Court finding that new facts did not constitute genuine new evidence but rather a rearrangement of previously considered material — Appellant failing to establish a verifiable residential address — Appeal dismissed.

Criminal Procedure
Score: 55

Mjali All Stars FC v South African Football Association (SAFA) Mpumalanga Province and Another (2026/153080) [2026] ZAMPMHC 52 (29 July 2026)

Administrative Law — Mandamus — Urgent application for mandamus to compel first respondent to hear complaint — Applicant, a football club, alleging procedural irregularities in playoffs determining promotion to higher league — Court finding that applicant failed to join necessary parties with direct interest in outcome — Application dismissed due to non-joinder and lack of urgency.

Administrative Law
Score: 45

Mplatyi v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and Others (PR15/2023) [2026] ZALCPE 21 (29 July 2026)

Labour Law — Review application — Dismissal of review application for inordinate delay — Applicant alleging unfair labour practice and unfair dismissal — Third respondent seeking dismissal based on delay in prosecution — Court finding that delay was due to CCMA's failure to provide complete record — Application to dismiss review application dismissed, with no order as to costs.

Labour Law
Score: 45